3 ms·
> your position is unfounded In the context of an argument, this is the same as wrong. You can't use evidence to refute an unfounded argument; there are no sup
by pessimizer 4y ago
> your position is unfounded
In the context of an argument, this is the same as wrong. You can't use evidence to refute an unfounded argument; there are no supports to attack.
- notch656a 4y agoHaving no evidence is not the same as being wrong. For instance, I can claim there is a flying spaghetti monster in heaven watching over us. My argument would be unfounded, with no supports to attack, but an assertion to the contrary would be similarly wrong. There is essentially no way to disprove it. Of course OPs statement is arguably one that is able to be disproven, or at least evidence towards disproving it. Unfortunately, the person claiming it was not sophisticated enough failed to provide that evidence. So in my book, they both made unfounded statements.
- yibg 4y agoIf you claim there is a flying spaghetti monster in heaven watching over us, the default position isn't "well maybe it's true maybe it's not, so let's call it 50/50". The default position is that's silly until you can show some evidence.
- notch656a 4y agoThat's an excellent straw man equating 'unfounded' with '50/50'! Congrats!