12 ms·
Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan?
- d23 4y ago> I know many vegans. They have access to the same information as I do about the treatment of animals, and they have made informed decisions about their lifestyle, which I fully respect. > I myself remain a meat-eater. It strikes me as off that one would consider themselves informed enough to have decided not to be a vegan but consider image generation AI unethical. As a former carnivore (literally sometimes going an entire day eating mostly or entirely meat), access to the information about just how horrific factory farming is and the willingness to open my eyes to it was the only thing that stopped me from being persuaded.
- simonw 4y agoThat's my point. Even though I understand how unethical it is to eat meat, I continue to chose to eat it. I am not proud to remain a meat eater! I only eat meat once or twice a week, and I try to consider the sources, but despite understanding the moral implications of doing so I have not gone vegan or vegetarian. To my mind, this is similar to a situation in which I determine that using AI trained on unlicensed images is unethical but continue to chose to use those AIs.
- lupire 4y agoI encourage you to use a term like "aspiring vegan" or "mostly vegan" or whatever describes you. Binary terminology is a disservice. Everyone cutting meat by 50% is more impactful than 5% of people cutting meat to 0%
- teaearlgraycold 4y ago“Fake vegetarian” is my current preferred term.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jszymborski 4y agoI feel like "flexitarian" is a largely deceased remnant of the mid-aughts but I like it. It expresses that one is not dogmatic about the practice, but is mostly conforming. "Aspiring vegan", to my ear, kinda sounds like one thinks about it, but performs zero action towards it, which is a bit of a disservice to those who do indeed consciously do not eat meat for the majority of their meals.
- Klonoar 4y agoI’ve used the term “opportunistic vegan” before - I.e if it’s possible I’ll probably do it, but I’m not gonna kill myself over it.
- jszymborski 4y agoI like that!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hbn 4y agoSomething as fundamental as eating -- a process you do multiple times a day to keep yourself alive, and compromising on is an incredibly large convenience/monetary/lifestyle tradeoff -- versus using AI models for generating images from text prompts are very different.
- RosanaAnaDana 4y agoYeah, I found the taking issue with copyright as the primary reason for being averse to AI to be almost breathtakingly hilarious (I at least exhaled through my nostrils once I read it). This quibble to me seems like the most anemic criticism one could muster around the ethical considerations implied by this new generation of AI.
- simonw 4y agoThere's been an interesting conversation about this post over on Lobsters, including debate over whether or not the "vegan" analogy is effective here: https://lobste.rs/s/kxqvam/image_generation_ethics_will_you_be_ai https://lobste.rs/s/kxqvam/image_generation_ethics_will_you_...
- spywaregorilla 4y agoHumans learn to produce good art largely by learning from existing art. Copying, mimicking, or just generally taking inspiration. We're going to need to get over this hang up. Status quo bias is dumb. Especially among people who are otherwise fond of piracy or anti-ip legislation.
- simonw 4y agoSounds to me like you've decided that AI veganism is not for you! I've thought about this comparison to human artists taking inspiration from each other a bit. The problem becomes the scale. A human artist can't look at 5bn images and use them to be able to instantly mimic the style of another artist, hundreds of times an hour. Consider facial recognition technology. At an individual level, empowering people to quickly see all of the photos they have taken of their spouse through running facial recognition against their photos is useful and harmless. Allowing governments to run the exact same technology against every photo uploaded to Facebook is a massively harmful expansion of the surveillance state. I don't think training models against 5bn unlicensed images is in the same scale of harm as running facial recognition against an entire country's worth of people. But this example does show that things that are fine on a small scale can be harmful at a big scale.
- atemerev 4y ago> Allowing governments to run the exact same technology against every photo uploaded to Facebook We should allow _everybody_ to run the exact same technology. Governments are not special. Power to the people.
- fragmede 4y agoI don’t own my own supercomputer to run the same analysis the NSA can, though.
- spywaregorilla 4y ago> Sounds to me like you've decided that AI veganism is not for you! I feel it is insulting to veganism to try and coin this term. The moral arguments are not similar, and this one is frankly much weaker. > I've thought about this comparison to human artists taking inspiration from each other a bit. The problem becomes the scale. A human artist can't look at 5bn images and use them to be able to instantly mimic the style of another artist, hundreds of times an hour. A human can mimic something with a single reference. It might not be good, but that can hardly matter for a discussion of ethics. The morality cannot depend on whether or not humans can do something poorly or not. > Consider facial recognition technology. At an individual level, empowering people to quickly see all of the photos they have taken of their spouse through running facial recognition against their photos is useful and harmless. Allowing governments to run the exact same technology against every photo uploaded to Facebook is a massively harmful expansion of the surveillance state. Entirely different issue that happens to utilize a similar tech. > But this example does show that things that are fine on a small scale can be harmful at a big scale. It does not.
- prometheus76 4y agoArtists look at images (copyright or not) while working on their own images all the time. Many of Shakespeare's works are re-writes of stories that were common in his era? How is this any different?
- brodouevencode 4y agoDid copyright exist in the Shakespearean era?
- lupire 4y agoDoes that affect the morality of it?
- spywaregorilla 4y agoCopyright has no bearing on ethics.
- Stupulous 4y agoI don't know if that's true for everyone. If someone doesn't believe that an idea should be the property of the first person who thought of it for an innate moral reason, they might still believe that it's unethical to take that property away after it is guaranteed by the state. A utilitarian who is pro-copyright because it encourages creation and innovation might not be concerned with works that were published without that encouragement.
- breck 4y agoThere's a slight relationship. If you believe in copyright then you don't believe in ethics^1 ;). [1] Assuming you've actually thought about copyright from first principles—I think many people are too busy to have given it enough thought.
- kixiQu 4y agoI recommend reading more about copyright law. The questions you are raising have been considered carefully for centuries. While the modern US settled compromises may be repugnant to you as to me, the expertise behind how these things are considered is valuable and constitutes many-years-of-study's worth. Learning about the complicated contours of what is considered legal and what is considered ethical in "artists [looking] at images" – among which there is a lot of distinction – may explain why others here would expect there to be legal and ethical distinctions among how deep learning systems may process and regurgitate their input.
- AndyNemmity 4y agoI feel like there was a reasonable article here about Image generation ethics that ends up completely muddled by a bad analogy to veganism.
- brodouevencode 4y agoSadly yes. The first 2/3 are pretty good.
- adrianmonk 4y agoYeah, vegetarianism is on the list (along with religion, politics, and vi/emacs) of subjects that can completely derail a discussion. Another analogy might have created less distraction. I would have avoided this one personally.
- 411111111111111 4y agoI find modern meat factories abhorrent. While I'm not against eating meat, I cannot condone eating any that can be bought in our modern world. As even the best places are complete horror shows. Considering this, I find it incredibly obnoxious to use the term vegan in this fashion, somehow equating training a software on copyrighted material to literally torturing living, feeling and thinking animals for their short lives. It is so completely out of touch with reality that I'm just speechless.
- legohead 4y agoDo you feel the same when X person is compared to Hitler or a Nazi? Happens to pretty much every President...
- simonw 4y agoIt can be seen as offensive from both directions: - Artists: you’re comparing us to animals raised for meat now? - Animals: you’re saying killing and eating us is equivalent to stealing someone’s picture? Honestly though, the more I think about this particular analogy the more I like it. The key to the analogy isn't meant to be about eating animals compared to ripping off art though - it's about personal ethical choices. From the article: > ... my current mental model is to think about this in terms of veganism, as an analogy for people making their own personal ethical decisions.
- jelliclesfarm 4y agoi see..you are comparing a living being to art. how about AI Cannibal? apt, i feel...by your logic. and better than "AI vegan". everyone has access to human flesh and sadly only a few indulge in this opportunity. how about we leave vegans out of this?
- simonw 4y agoCannibalism doesn't work for me as an analogy to my personal ethics, because I am not a cannibal.
- cmcconomy 4y ago
- orblivion 4y agoOf all the deep questions surrounding this, copyright I must admit was not the first one that came to mind when I read the headline.
- dfxm12 4y agoI don't think this is universally unethical, and even if one does find this unethical, it seems low on the list of unethical things to be worrying about. Even in the context of exploiting people's labor. Furthermore, I think a lot of art generated by actual intelligence is made by those consuming tons of copyrighted material and putting a twist on things. Is it unethical to listen to The Monkees, since, to put it in the terms of the article, they were so clearly trained on the Beatles with a few tweaks here or there?
- acomjean 4y agoPeople have found inspiration in other works since we've been creating art. In music if you use a snipet of someone else's recording you have to pay them. It wasn't always clear that would be the case, but thats where they landed. (You end up with Led Zeppelin and Beatles Samples in some early rap). Even "Sound alike " singers get litigated: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Midler_v._Ford_Motor_Co https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Midler_v._Ford_Motor_Co. But in visual art its a little different. Borrowing is more common and remixing is kinda allowed. When does it become "transformative?" (I always think of the "Hope" poster lawsuit, where the borrower sued the photographer as a strange one. ) https://www.law.columbia.edu/news/archive/obama-hope-poster-lawsuit-settlement-good-deal-both-sides-says-kernochan-center-director https://www.law.columbia.edu/news/archive/obama-hope-poster-... But what is the AI doing? I don't think its taking the input given and being inspired... Its kinda just sampling, in a way that makes it seem like its being original. Or is the unique training set/ annotations that are is giving the AI its unique output the art, in which case its more original. At some point some AI is going to spit something out too close to something else and the courts will probably have to decide.
- ChrisLomont 4y ago>At some point some AI is going to spit something out too close to something else and the courts will probably have to decide. People have been spitting out stuff too close to decide and letting courts decide for well over a hundred years. This is nothing new. If people make art that is in the style of someone else, by hand or by AI, it's generally fine to do so. If it gets too close, then courts can step in as always.
- freedude 4y agoJust because the image is publicly available doesn't mean it should have been copied. Some legalities worth pondering. Are the AI generated images copyrighted? Are they protected behind any form of paywall? Are those using the images generated by the AI responsible for derived works?
- simonw 4y agoThese are all very good questions, and I don't think any of them have obvious answers yet.
- spywaregorilla 4y ago> Just because the image is publicly available doesn't mean it should have been copied. There is no "Should" that makes sense here either way. > Are the AI generated images copyrighted? No, this is already established in the US. > Are they protected behind any form of paywall? You can if you want. > Are those using the images generated by the AI responsible for derived works? Derived works of the images? Like I generate a picture of a dog, and you draw a dick on it? Obviously not.
- ChrisLomont 4y ago>> Are the AI generated images copyrighted? > No, this is already established in the US. The case you're likely thinking of [1] is not at all this case. Thaler tried to have the AI assigned the copyright, then transfer it to himself. USPTO denied that the AI could have the copyright, so it could not be transferred. This is completely the opposite of what this case is. He wanted AI to be the sole copyright holder, which the court ruled cannot be. Any creative human input to make the AI create the image (text prompts, post selection from among any images to find one that is good) is fully copyrightable by the person. The text that an artist uses and then selects final images from are both considered creative enough to make the final copyrightable, just as if they entered numbers into Photoshop tools to make an image the way they wanted it. Plenty of these are creative enough and take significant tweaking by the authors via the text they fiddle with to be copyrightable, the same as the text they created to generate the work. [1] https://www.copyright.gov/rulings-filings/review-board/docs/a-recent-entrance-to-paradise.pdf https://www.copyright.gov/rulings-filings/review-board/docs/...
- KingOfCoders 4y ago"Stable Diffusion has been trained on millions of copyrighted images scraped from the web." Artists have been trained on hundreds of copyrighted images in magazines, museums and on the web.
- bioemerl 4y agoI will not on the simple basis that this tool will empower me to create things I never could have imagined and essentially have a tool that transforms imagination into images in the same way that my own imagination does. It will take very very large ethical issues, direct death or suffering, for me to reconsider. It's just such an amazing opportunity that I am not willing to just give it away for nothing.
- scotty79 4y ago> Stable Diffusion has been trained on millions of copyrighted images scraped from the web. How is it different from how human artists train on copyrighted images? We have no trouble to award them copyright on art which consists of elements, or is heavily inspired by elements of copyrighted works they've seen during their education? Human imagination can't create anything really novel. Everything you create is just cutting, stitching and deforming what you already seen in semi-random ways until you get something interesting to somebody. Try imagining how an alien might look.
- simonw 4y agoI think there is a difference here, and it's one of scale: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32640014 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32640014
- scotty79 4y agoThat's weird argument. So art stops being art if it's done at scale and draws inspiration from more not less sources and then becomes ... plagiarism?
- lm28469 4y ago> How is it different from how human artists train on copyrighted images? The part where the company training the models makes $$$ on copyrighted work can definitely be a debate point.
- scotty79 4y agoCompany consisting of trained artists also makes $$$ on copyrighted work. Why is it ok if the creative stitching engine is made of humans but not when it's made of computers?
- a_shovel 4y ago> Human imagination can't create anything really novel. Everything you create is just cutting, stitching and deforming what you already seen in semi-random ways until you get something interesting to somebody. That's an awfully low opinion of art and humanity.
- dleslie 4y agoFor those opining that training a model isn't dissimilar to how humans acquire knowledge: human artists take decades to do it; and eventually, human artists die. These aren't constraints on AI developed, controlled, and accessible only to enormous corporate entities; even if they deign to provide limited access to the public at times.
- abetusk 4y agoWow, this take is so utterly infuriating. There's so much wrong with this take on so many levels that I wonder if it isn't just trolling. Let me answer it in what I think is the most generous reading: Copyright is not meant to be used a bludgeon to inhibit the sharing of ideas, it's meant to incentivize the creation of works while still providing a mechanism to enhance the commons [0]. The limitations of copyright are: * You cannot copyright ideas, only realizations [1] * Copyrighted works can be copied without the authors consent if it falls under fair use [2]. In particular, the amount republished is considered in addition to whether it harms the original copyrighted author * To show copyright infringement, you have to show a "substantial similarity" [3] and have the challenged work in question not be protected under other non-infringing uses [4] such as being an "aggregator" or other such service In particular, if we're having a conversation about copyright but we don't talk about scraping for search (Google, Bing, Yahoo, etc.) or other aggregation services, then I'd ask why Google is allowed to aggregate information but everyone else isn't. In terms of 'transformative work', I'd point out that many artists copy the style of other artists, sometimes even using code, and while there are many "ethical" dilemmas that artists bring up about this point, this very clearly falls outside of the scope of copyright. Also, to not talk about the over reach of copyright, the nearly 100+ year copyright terms and the level of automation to demonitize and bully smaller artists using copyrighted work fairly is negligent. Is this harming artists more than it's helping? If so, why is the argument different now than when it was used in the past for similar issues? Let's say an artist is mad that their work got used in one of these AI models. How would they prove it? What if it turned out that the model was actually using work from another, older, artist that the angry artist used as an influence and didn't actually use any of the "angry" artists work at all. Should we start suing the angry artist because they made their art "in the style of" the older artist? I'm all for having these conversations but hot takes like this are simplistic and counter productive. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_law_of_the_United_States#Purpose_of_copyright https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_law_of_the_United_St... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_law_of_the_United_States#Works_subject_to_copyright_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_law_of_the_United_St... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fair_use https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fair_use [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Substantial_similarity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Substantial_similarity [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_infringement#Limitations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_infringement#Limitat...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pdntspa 4y agoPeople need to stop being so deferential to copyright. Once a work is out in the public, it's no longer yours or anyones'.
- theptip 4y agoAnother example to consider as an intuition pump might be to ask how many engineers are going to publish their FOSS with a “using this as AI training input is forbidden” clause, or otherwise battle against training Copilot and other code authoring systems. Art is typically quite style-promiscuous, and mostly protected by copyright. It’s also quite analog/continuous. Code is more discrete; you can diff it and easily see if an AI copied a particular block that doesn’t appear in other projects. Personally I don’t think there is a strong argument that training an AI on art is problematic, as long as the AI doesn’t then commit copyright infringement. I think this process is equivalent to art students consuming art and synthesizing their own styles. I think it’s more problematic if AI starts regurgitating discrete chunks of FOSS code, since that’s probably a license violation. For digital artists, lots of skills are going to become irrelevant; the raw skill of pixel pushing and line work may well become obsolete. But the hardest part was always having good taste, composition, ideation. These are not going away any time soon. And if you enjoy pushing pixels around, nothing to stop you doing that; we still play chess for fun even though computers dominate humans at the task. Indeed, computers make very scalable and accessible coaches; one could argue that chess is more fun, and easier to learn, now that computers have superseded humans. Perhaps the same will be true about art, and later, coding.
- shpx 4y ago> how many engineers are going to publish their FOSS with a “using this as AI training input is forbidden” clause That clause would make their software not Free and Open Source by definition.
- thomasahle 4y agoI suppose the Open Source Definition of Applied works apply: > The license must allow modifications and derived works, and must allow them to be distributed under the same terms as the license of the original software. So AI training would be allowed, but all code subsequently generated by the AI would have to be under a compatible license.
- sulam 4y agoJust like those art students you reference, engineers regularly find bits of code and regurgitate it in their projects. Stack Overflow gets its reputation for a reason. They especially do this earlier in their careers, before they develop their own intuition and style, just like an art student. Why would you treat the ML model (I very much hesitate to call it AI) differently in these two cases?
- ajdegol 4y agoPick another word; vegan isn't good here. At best you could use it to not depict cruelty to animals but... just doesn't work.
- jollyllama 4y agoAn iconoclast. An image smasher.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- TazeTSchnitzel 4y agoThe reason we got Hatsune Miku, a virtual singer who doesn't sound quite human, rather than a perfect Vocaloid-based recreation of a well-known actor's voice, was that no actor was willing to volunteer to have their career destroyed by the latter. Therefore, they fell back on sampling an actor's voice to produce a new, distinct character, not one that sounded just like the actor. For “machine learning”, though, it seems the big players aren't even going to pay artists for the work they use, let alone try to avoid hurting their livelihoods.
- jszymborski 4y agoI'm not an AI Vegan, but perhaps an advocate of the AI "Eat Local" movement (of which I might be the only member :P)? I similarly understand and sympathise with the apprehension of generating images from this massive harvesting of data with little regard of what should and should not be in the dataset. I think by using these models as pre-training weights and fine-tuning on data which one believes they have the right to use or (even better) has created themselves, you can (IMHO) greatly minimise the harm of your model's output. I also like this from a conceptual stand-point. We have the right to learn and be inspired by others, but when it comes to putting the paint brush to the canvas or the ink to the page, it should be our own experiences that we draw primarily from.
- simonw 4y agoOh I really like that. I think I'm ready to join your AI Eat Local movement too. I'd love to be able to run GitHub Copilot weighted heavily towards code that I've written myself, as an additional training layer.
- natch 4y agoI have seen many copyrighted images and learned from them. Does that make my knowledge tainted? Pearl clutching is a thing.
- bogwog 4y agoNobody can stop the march of progress. Being “vegan” with AI is just setting yourself up for failure in the (probably near) future. If you’re a professional artist today, you need to lean into this and adapt somehow. Current AI is pretty limited, but that’s not going to last. I wish I had an answer for the “how to adapt” question, but I don’t. All I know is that this isn’t the first time people have tried to futilely resist a technological revolution. I do think though that copyright law needs to be updated to deal with this AI stuff. Copyright was created to protect creative works, since that is a very important thing to protect both for the economy and culture. I just hope that the people and companies creating these AI are on the right side of that fight. I doubt it though.
- tomrod 4y agoThis isn't the first industry where laborious craft has been rendered a commodity by technology. There will still be room for artistic genius and patronage models in many places, but the people who want the plastic knockoffs will get a reasonable product too.
- hot_gril 4y agoThe other march of progress is that everything on Google Images can and will be copied. Nobody cares unless it's commercial use. The biggest joke was in high school being told to only use Creative Commons images in essays/presos. As if any kid is not just going to Google "dog" then drag the first image that pops up.
- lm28469 4y ago> Nobody can stop the march of progress. technological progress*, it's very debatable if that can be called "progress" in the general sense of the term
- trention 4y ago>Nobody can stop the march of progress. Several periods of known human history, starting from the late bronze age, disagree.
- colordrops 4y agoThis is ridiculous. It's not just AIs models that built their abstract conceptions on copyrighted material, but humans too. When a human artist paints a futuristic dome, they are also subconsciously accessing millions of copyright images they've seen throughout their lives and using them "without consent". To be consistent the author would need to avert their eyes and never look at copyrighted imagery. Also the comparison to veganism and animal suffering is off putting.
- nonrandomstring 4y agoAs the author of "Digital Vegan" [1] and "Ethics For Hackers" there's much about this thread that pleases me. Some very intelligent discussion is emerging. I feel both that the time has come for fundamental cultural change within the tech/hacker community, and that expressions like "AI Veganism" are indeed appropriate and useful on many levels. They enable the discussion of lifestyle choice, rights, health, ecology and many other salient factors in relation to digital technology. At this point, those still clinging to a rejection of modern tech-critique as in any sense anti-progressive or "Luddite" are in fact the ones woefully out of date and out of step with how the world is turning. [1] https://digitalvegan.net https://digitalvegan.net
- waffletower 4y agoIs there a comment section on http://digitalvegan.net http://digitalvegan.net where we can rightfully downvote its terrible name?
- nonrandomstring 4y agoWhy do you think it's terrible? FWIW, so do I. But much like we say of capitalism and democracy, it's the worst apart from all the others. I have yet to find a better one that captures the attendant issues.
- brudgers 4y agoFor me, this is easy because I consider copyright amoral — that is to say that copyright does not involve morality or immortality, and only its formal legal definition is meaningful. I am not saying that attribution doesn’t have an ethical dimension. Only that attribution is morally/ethically independent of the legal construct of copyright. Not that I think it matters much because I don’t expect AI art will have much impact as art in the long run…which is not the same as saying it won’t have much impact in the realm of disposable images. The reason I think AI art won’t be terribly important is that there do not appear to be very many intellectually interesting things to say about it as art beyond is-it-art-because-I-hung-it-on-the-wall? And none of this is to say that artists won’t make interesting AI art. Because artists and their processes are intellectually interesting in ways that training sets are not. I mean David Hockney’s iPad art is interesting because of David Hockney not because of iPads. YMMV.
- TaylorAlexander 4y agoI consider copyright immoral, but I still struggle with the idea that most of us have to honor copyright but the big companies scraping for image models don't have to. Maybe we could view that as a positive erosion of copyright, but we could also see it as unfair exploitation of artists. Google can scrape from artists but what would happen if one of us tried to take Google's code? I have been playing with Stable Diffusion for a week. I think it is going to have a significant impact. The so-called disposable art probably gives lots of artists their first paid gigs that gives them paid time to practice and build a portfolio, while learning to work with customers. I think a lot of that work will shift to prolific prompt-engineers who know their way around the software. I'm very pro-automaton (I'm a robotics engineer) but I don't like the idea of taking work from a bunch of artists without their consent to build a model that depresses their wages. I would rather these companies worked on sample-efficiency (an important area of research) and stuck to the millions of openly licensed images available on the web, then worked with twitter and instagram to add image license options to the photo widgets so that we can all build up a consent-based model. And artists that want to keep their work for themselves have that choice. I don't think it will happen, but I do wish we actually honored the consent of the artists. I think it's a shame we're not.
- CivBase 4y agoThere is so much doomsay around these image generation AIs and I don't really understand it. Did photographs devalue painters? Did digital art devalue painters? Did movies devalue theater? Did YouTube videos devalue cinematographers? Did Twitch streams or TikTok videos devalue YouTubers? Technology has continuously brought us easier and more immediate ways to create art, inspiring new generations of artists who hone their skills with the new tech. Meanwhile, older forms of art continue to be valued along side the new stuff. I'm also having a hard time seeing the ethical crisis with these AIs being trained on copyrighted material. Styles are not (or at least should not be) copyrightable. An artist can be inspired by the works of another and go on to create something new. Many forms of derivative work are even specifically granted safety under existing copyright law. Besides, it would be practically impossible to prove that a model was trained on copyrighted works. Even if we decided it was unethical, any law against it would be theoretical and practically unenforceable. Either way, artists will have to adapt. I don't think the situation is near as dire as so many seem to believe. An AI can only reproduce a style that has been thoroughly explored by the content which it is trained on. New styles will continue to be rewarded. Digital artists will be encouraged to push boundaries. And for the time being, the AIs still have some pretty severe limitations so artists will be able to capitalize on those. And one more thing I never see brought up when talking about these AI image generators: there's already precedent for how this will play out. AI music composers have been around for many years now, but Dua Lipa and The Weeknd appear to be doing just fine. Even the more classical composers and orchestras seem to be going just as strong as ever. If AI artists show no sign of toppling the music industry, why should we expect the fate of digital images to be so different?
- trention 4y ago>There is so much doomsay around these image generation AIs and I don't really understand it. Did photographs devalue painters? Did digital art devalue painters? Did movies devalue theater? Did YouTube videos devalue cinematographers? Did Twitch streams or TikTok videos devalue YouTubers? All of those are tools which did not lead to potentially the same final product produced for a miniature fraction of the labor costs. AI composition is generally pretty shit. If (more like when) it becomes better, we will be having the exact same argument regarding composers.
- gdubs 4y agoWith StableDiffusion in particular, their business model (so far) is charging for an easy to use front-end. At the same time they've (essentially) given away the model for free for people to develop on. To me, personally, this seems like a fair trade in the sense of giving back to humanity from something that was made from the collective imaginations of humanity, and finding a way to also recoup on investment. (The model didn't train itself, and GPU time isn't free.) Everyone essentially benefits from this new technology that enables completely new forms of expression. Now, could someone choose to use it in a completely derivative way to essentially rip-off a well known artist? Sure. That would be really crappy to do to someone. And also a very brain dead use of something so nearly infinite in its capabilities for generating new things. Could art directors replace illustrators, filmmakers replace concept artists? Sure. But I think something different is likely to happen which is that artists will use these tools to go further. The "bicycle of the mind" Steve Jobs always used to talk about. As someone who put in the proverbial ten thousand hours in art and technology, I'm completely excited about what this tech enables. Now, that doesn't mean people's fears aren't valid. Desktop publishing decimated the traditional printmaking industry. Many artisans lost their living. But many small independent publishers were suddenly able to put out their own material to a vast audience. Similar with the internet. I think it ultimately comes back around to things like universal basic income, or what have you. Rather than taking away amazing tools, we should solve the problem of economic fear that automation and displacement has and continues to bring. Anyway, this is all so new that these are just my roughly formed personal opinions. I could very well be wrong! But I feel like a lot of the debate is superficial. That there's a lot of misconception about how these models really work. And it also reveals a lot of holes in our own understanding of what it means to think, be original, etc.
- peteradio 4y ago> And also a very brain dead use of something so nearly infinite in its capabilities for generating new things. What would be brain dead about making lots of money? The popular artist has already found market fit and potentially has an easy corpus of work on which to train.
- gdubs 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- aaroninsf 4y agoSo many takes on this are so foolish in so basic a way. They recapitulate in a naive way fundamentally broken world-views derived from the anglo-american analytic philosophical reductionism with respect to language, sematntics, and representation. TL;DR: the models behind these things objects are more like human minds than databases. They perform integration and reproduction as do our minds (within very narrow constraints of course). These attempts to reason about ethics around them predicated on pearl-clutching about IP and originality miss the point and significant and nature of such models and the systems around them in a forest-trees way. Attempting to describe what they do and what relationship it bears to prior work is only sensible when you start with the premise that they are more like human minds, than "tools for replication" in any of the senses we have had to reason about as a society before. A worse problem is certain: our legal system is certain to lag even further behind in both comprehension and ability to respond. Oh well!
- benreesman 4y agoSo soft-PSA: the following is more than a little misleading: “The fact that it can compress such an enormous quantity of visual information into such a small space is itself a fascinating detail.” This is not a detail: it’s the principle mechanism. The ability to compress something is conferred by the identification and exploitation of structure, conversely the scarcity or absence of structure inhibits or prohibits compression. You can eyeball check an RNG with compression techniques. This has counter-intuitive consequences that you can test on your laptop! Even using off-the-shelf codecs it only takes a modest corpus to see that pop music compresses better than eclectic jazz, which compresses better than white noise. The same thing holds for headshots of people: a big pile of headshots drawn from a reasonably broad corpus of humans will enjoy a noticeably lower compression ratio than a subset selected by any plausible “conventional attractiveness” filter. “Conventional attractiveness” (defined any common-sense way) correlates sharply with bilateral symmetry, with obvious implications for storage space. Information theory is the thread that ties together all this AI craze stuff!
- Imnimo 4y agoDoes this AI veganism extend to every model with training data that is not in the public domain? Every language model, every translation model, every classification and detection model build on top of Imagenet weights?
- holy_kek 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- benreesman 4y agoI’d love it if someone tuned up a language model for soooo-thirsty click-magnet AI metaphors and left it running so that it would destroy the incentive to SEO “Your Model Architecture Horoscope: Are You A Stable Stacy or an Adversarial Andrew? Either Way, You Probably Need Some Variational Autoencoding in Your Love Life!”
- boredtofears 4y agoI wonder how many commenters here are fine with AI models trained on copyrighted images but feel differently about copilot learning on copyrighted code.
- xnx 4y agoAmazing from-the-future level technology. Interesting topic. Very distracting analogy. Might be a textbook example of technological progress: Lots of people have their jobs eliminated (which suuucks), but many more benefit from having access to professional-level custom artwork that they didn't have before. AI/ML is coming for everything. High-paying jobs like doctors, lawyers, and developers are definitely not immune.
- threevox 4y agoClothing manufacturing ethics: will you be a textile manufacturing vegan?
- plaguepilled 4y agoLebron James himself would be astounded by the reach of the author.