6 ms·
The real question is whether it's a good thing to stop "mind wandering" when it hasn't reached the level of disorder. From the perspective of evolution, it alm
by jessriedel 15y ago
The real question is whether it's a good thing to stop "mind wandering" when it hasn't reached the level of disorder. From the perspective of evolution, it almost certainly has a purpose. Paul Graham pointed out that its probably useful for problem solving:
http://www.paulgraham.com/top.html http://www.paulgraham.com/top.html
I wonder if it would be good to have the ability to better focus one's self when one's mind is wandering into unproductive subjects (e.g. agonizing over an ex) without necessarily getting to the point where your default mode has been changed so much as to prevent insights in the shower (and instead being deeply aware of the hot water).
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- unignorant 15y ago> Bringing the mind to its unmoved state, a state of no-thought, leads to an indescribable bliss. Do you have evidence to support this claim? I can empty my mind, and it is not blissful. It is nothing. > A wandering mind is more prone to distraction, which can be fatal. Assuming, of course, we are speaking of survival factors. Tradeoffs. Personally, I would want to be distracted by an event that might otherwise prove fatal.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- jessriedel 15y ago>This empty state of mind allows for better problem-solving This is the claim I'd like evidence for.
- WayneDB 15y agoI'm not aware of any studies here, but it's been said many times that solutions to tough problems often present themselves while the ponderer isn't thinking about the problem, sometimes upon waking up or just before falling asleep.
- michaelfeathers 15y agoA good book about this is: The Breakout Principle by Herbert Benson. His model is that creative insight comes from periods of intense activity followed by a down period. http://cbass.com/Breakout.htm http://cbass.com/Breakout.htm
- unignorant 15y agoWell, it seemed a rather strong claim. I was wondering whether I had reason to believe myself abnormal in this respect (a fact which I would find interesting). I suppose you meant that it leads to bliss for yourself? > You say you can empty your mind, I doubt that. Can you give me evidence? This is a much weaker claim, the scope of which is myself. The evidence is my personal anecdote, and from your perspective this may constitute poor evidence. But at least if my anecdote was true, then my statement would be true. The same cannot be said for your statement, unless you would like to present (at least) a set of anecdotes.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- Alex3917 15y ago"Do you have evidence to support this claim? I can empty my mind, and it is not blissful. It is nothing." Just emptying your mind isn't meditation. But there definitely are states of pure bliss if you're doing it properly. For example, this guide to attaining first level enlightenment in ten days talks about some of the bliss states one will experience: http://thehamiltonproject.blogspot.com/2010/11/going-for-stream-entry-on-goenka-10-day.html http://thehamiltonproject.blogspot.com/2010/11/going-for-str... Bliss is actually one of the easiest mind states for a beginning meditation to experience, it shouldn't take more than a half hour or so before you're experiencing at least some level of blissfulness.
- aik 15y agoI've pondered the same thing. However, personally from meditation I feel I have greater focus, a clearer mind, and less stress (or a much better handle on stress), which I couldn't imagine being without today. Concerning shower-insights -- I find myself having less mind wandering in the shower, and instead more deliberate focused insights.
- jessriedel 15y agoThen what evolutionary purpose do you think mind-wandering serves? We clearly tend to think about various current problems of ours (whether technical, social, or other) when our mind wanders; it's not an accident.
- xavoy 15y agoI'd say we're half evolved. We have this facility and don't know how to properly control it. It's a byproduct of some other facility (the ability to communicate).
- cpeterso 15y agoI think we're always "half evolved". Our minds and bodies are an amalgam of "good enough" traits for overcoming yesteryear's evolutionary challenges, not entirely suited for today's challenges.
- xavoy 15y agoTotally agree.
- jessriedel 15y agoI don't see any link between (1) communication and (2) my mind wandering away from my immediate surroundings and settling on an outstanding problem I have. My mind could (and occasionally does) wander over a million other things in my brain (e.g. past memories, imagining the future, or the feel of my clothes on my body) but predominantly focuses on outstanding problems, so I tend to think this is a highly purposeful adaptation.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- blackman 15y agomeditation is not about clearing your mind and stopping it from wandering (although that is a basic way of practising it), it is about understanding the nature of your mind and how to control it. it is control of your mental state the same way types of yoga are control over your physical body. if was about stopping the mind from wandering only, well there are drugs for that.
- asmala 15y agoI think we need to differentiate between different types of wandering here. I think we can agree that letting our minds roam looking for creative solutions and creative questions is a good think. But it's less useful to have our minds stuck in a loop ("Peanut butter or jam? PB or J?" ad infinitum). Anecdotal evidence based on four years of active meditation would in my case seem to indicate that the jittery loopiness lessens while the capacity for creative wandering increases. I would conjencture that our minds are over-stimulated and hence unable settle down to make room for the truly novel.
- StacyC 15y agoAnecdotal evidence based on four years of active meditation would in my case seem to indicate that the jittery loopiness lessens while the capacity for creative wandering increases. This is exactly my experience as well. After about three years of meditation I have also found that I almost never get angry any more - things that used to piss me off or frustrate me just kind of roll off now, and I can really think more objectively about them and tackle problems in a constructive way. I think one of the keys with meditation is to become the observer of our thoughts and not self-identify with them. You are not your thoughts.
- thesz 15y agoSimpler explanation could be just hormonal levels changes. For example, increased testosterone levels correspond to increased stress tolerance. The testosterone levels increase in man and woman up to age of 35-40 years. So if you just sit and do nothing, your body could work in favor of your mind, if you're young enough. Chances are you were.
- asmala 15y agoHmm, interesting. I can definitely see how age-related changes in the endocrine system could cause certain improvements that are similar to the effects of meditation. And being as it is that I'm still 29, that could be a factor. But if I'm reading you correctly, you seem to imply that all the benefits mentioned could be explained away by age-related hormonal changes. I find that hard to believe based on the strong correlation I experience between active meditation practice and greatly increased mental ability. It is particularly noteworthy that I'm able to observe a clear decline in my capability to stay equanimous and focused whenever I have had longer periods away from practice, which should not be the case if we were dealing with mere age-related endocrine changes.
- GiraffeNecktie 15y agoPeople should also be aware that meditation, while generally beneficial, does not always have a benign effect on the mind. Look up "meditation induced psychosis".
- Alex3917 15y agoActually the best place to learn more is probably this two-part talk from Buddhist Geeks: http://www.buddhistgeeks.com/2011/09/bg-231-the-dark-side-of-dharma/ http://www.buddhistgeeks.com/2011/09/bg-231-the-dark-side-of... There is very little academic literature on meditation sickness, so this is probably the best source for information right now.