4 ms·
I possibly don't know all the ins and outs of the various religious food rules so let's stick to the less flame-war-y nut allergies. The people who have nut al
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
I possibly don't know all the ins and outs of the various religious food rules so let's stick to the less flame-war-y nut allergies.
The people who have nut allergies, and the people who don't want the people with nut allergies to die, and the people who don't want the people with nut allergies to feel socially excluded, and those that feel some social obligation not to kill the guests at their child's birthday party and a further fuzzy group of people who have other allergies or preferences or care about people who do, or follow some kind of "do unto others" morality is probably quite large.
And the cost of skipping nuts (as he discusses) is fairly minor, even to people who would actively like to kill anyone with nut allergies.
So, how does "dictatorship of the minority" deserve that title?
And how did we get from there, via some name dropping anecdotes, to "western civilization is commiting suicide"?
- RichardCNormos 4y ago[flagged]
- NoraCodes 4y agoYou've made two extreme leaps (accepting not eating nuts would lead to accepting an untested vaccine; accepting an untested vaccine would lead to accepting genital mutilation) and implied at least four complete falsehoods (that the COVID vaccine was "loosely tested", that COVID has a 99.98% survival rate, that GRS involves "chopping off genitals", and that absolutely anyone supports making GRS available to minors) here. Is that intentional?
- RichardCNormos 4y ago
- NoraCodes 4y agoI did not say "no u," I said you were factually incorrect. You made silly and extraordinary claims without evidence. Don't come asking me for a higher standard than you're willing to uphold yourself.
- RichardCNormos 4y agoAnd yet you come to me, asking me for a higher standard than you're willing to uphold yourself?
- iforgotpassword 4y agoWell then you have to skip the nuts. And the seashells. And the milk. And everything containing gluten. And probably eggs. And whatever else people can have allergies to. Gonna be an interesting diet.
- NoraCodes 4y agoBut we actually _do_ accommodate those allergies. I know someone with severe peanut, tree nut, and milk allergies. I spend lots of time with her, and yet I can still drink milkshakes and eat Reese's Cups. The idea that accommodating someone means utterly restricting everyone else's freedom is, frankly, ridiculous.
- iforgotpassword 4y agoBut yes that's the point, we do this on a case-by-case basis, after communicating, not generally because someone could show up and be allergic to nuts. Making a lemonade kosher is a no-brainer, so there's no problem with doing it. But if I had to go out of my way to find food with peanuts because we want to be safe by default, I'd have a problem with that.
- NoraCodes 4y agoYeah, completely agreed. But the reason you don't have to go out of your way is because the majority does care about that. This article isn't describing a hypothetical future of minority rule; this is how the world works right now, for the most part.
- iforgotpassword 4y agoI was reading the comment I replied to like that, but on a second read it doesn't suggest that so much.
- drewrv 4y agoI've seen some epic flame wars over the peanut restrictions in schools. They tend to catch my eye since one of my kids has a peanut allergy. People assume that these rules are created by pearl clutching "concerned parents". I've never seen parents advocate for peanut bans in real life. It has probably happened but it seems like the "preachy vegan", more of a myth than a reality. I suspect the real reason many schools have put restrictions in place on peanuts is that it simply makes their job easier. When you have to deal with hundreds of unruly kids it's hard to keep an eye on individuals. Sending kids to the ER is a bad look. Dealing with insurance stuff or lawsuits is a pain. Eliminating a source of headaches and shoving the inconvenience onto the parents is a no-brainer.