5 ms·
AMD's Bulldozer server benchmarks are here, and they're a catastrophe
- saulrh 15y agoAgain, one can't help but feel that a hypothetical 16-core Magny-Cours would have been a better option. I think that this quote demonstrates exactly the reason that AMD went forward with their catastrophe - current architectures can't get much more parallel. AMD is betting (heavily) that Intel's architecture will max out in the near future while AMD keeps improving Bulldozer. Should be interesting.
- wmf 15y agoI don't see evidence of this. Intel has moved to a more scalable ring bus while AMD is still using a crossbar (although the Bulldozer module design should allow each pair of cores to share a crossbar port).
- zdw 15y agoThe HyperTransport (HT) crossbar offered more options, although people didn't tend to use it like that. I can only think of a handful of examples (the Sun X4500/X4540 for example) that took full advantage of the expanded I/O functionality it offered, and there were even a few FPGA solutions that could have been used to create really innovative custom logic designs. The problem was that, outside of totally custom solutions like the above, it didn't offer enough of a benefit to AMD, especially once Intel jumped on the memory directly attached to CPU bandwagon.
- zdw 15y agoAMD's problem is that they can't compete either in the low power high performance (the 45w and under laptop chips), or high power high performance markets (like the high end Xeons). So they build massively parallel chips, and try new stuff like the Bulldozer platform, which creates a bunch of trade offs. It's very similar in concept to the Sun/Oracle Sparc T-series, with lots of great performing integer cores, and (at least on the first models) less than stellar floating point. The best thing they ever did was to acquire ATI, which gave them great integrated graphics and allowed fairly balanced and inexpensive platforms. Their long term problem is that the really lucrative parts of the business are all being taken by Intel.
- bad_user 15y agoThey did the same thing back in the days of AMD K6 ... fast integer ops, poor floating point. Then AMD Athlon came, built on the same foundation and Intel never knew what hit them. Don't dismiss Bulldozer just yet. AMD has this uncanny ability to make short term compromises that benefit them in the long term.
- gjm11 15y agoI worry that you're saying they have "this uncanny ability" on the basis of one instance where they've done it. The other possibility would be that they just got lucky once (helped by Intel's terrible, horrible, no good, very bad P4 design) and haven't had similar luck success before or since.
- lucian1900 15y agoI would say the have the best you can get on the market for low power, high performance with the Fusion chips. I have one in my Thinkpad and it has great CPU performance, excellent GPU performance and the battery lasts 7h.
- jsnell 15y agoThis doesn't exactly come as a surprise. It was already obvious from the desktop parts that something had gone horribly wrong. There just weren't any bright spots there. Worse single-threaded performance despite much larger cores (even counting each "module" as two "cores" rather than two "threads"). No improvement in clock speeds despite a newer design an deeper pipelines. No improvement in multi-threaded workloads core-for-core. And it seems hard to give credit for the improved multi-threaded performance per-socket, given the huge increase in both transistor count and die size. It would really be interesting to know what actually went wrong. The new process? The rumored switch to automated design methodology? Unfortunately the answer to the question posed by the article seems obvious... They had to persevere with this and ship it, since they didn't have the resources for a plan B.
- iFire 15y agoWho here wants to play with 64 cores? That's 4 sockets of Opteron 6272 which is around 540 dollars each on newegg.
- Jach 15y agoHow about 144? ;P http://www.greenarraychips.com/home/products/index.html http://www.greenarraychips.com/home/products/index.html
- iFire 15y agoDB003 Evaluation Board Reference for EVB001 seems to have low interconnect bandwidth. I don't see anything like hypertransport.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- onenine 15y agoThis article is impressively bad. While the 8-module chip does share a few things (mainly a vector processing unit, that becomes two when doing the 128-bit SSE operations) they really can run 16 threads on 16 ALUs. But, they'll have sse contention if they schedule more than 8 256-bit vector operations (sadly intel won't bring this instruction set to market for a bit). Bulldozer is pretty cool, but sadly the tech press decides to shit on the underdog in a market that multiple companies have successfully sued the monopolist for anti-competitive behavior. :(
- DarkShikari 15y agoWhile the 8-module chip does share a few things (mainly a vector processing unit And more importantly, the decode and dispatch unit, which only run every other clock for a given core -- thus limiting any given core to a theoretical maximum of a mere 2 IPC, and in practice a lot more than that since the dispatch unit has limitations of its own, nevermind branch mispredictions and such.
- onenine 15y agoI'm not sure what it would look like in the video [d]ecoder world, but I don't think that would matter since most the time you'd want to use the 256-bit vector instructions (in practice this would hardly be a high priority until they're nearly ubiquitous...). For use cases where you are addressing large memory regions this hardly seems like that big of a deal. There are times when you can schedule tons of calculations without leaving L1 but for some odd reason people are finding 500GB+ of RAM useful.
- DarkShikari 15y agosince most the time you'd want to use the 256-bit vector instructions There are no 256-bit integer vector instructions on x86, and AVX is slower than SSE on Bulldozer.
- onenine 15y agoSad but true...You can issue SIMD instructions on 4 doubles at once though (and put whatever you want in those 16 registers)....