3 ms·
[T]hey differentiated being a varsity college athlete, preferably one that was also a national or Olympic champion, versus playing intramurals; having traveled
by cperciva 15y ago
[T]hey differentiated being a varsity college athlete, preferably one that was also a national or Olympic champion, versus playing intramurals; having traveled the globe with a world-renowned orchestra as opposed to playing with a school chamber group; and having reached the summit of Everest or Kilimanjaro versus recreational hiking. The former activities were evidence of "true accomplishment" and dedication, whereas the latter were described as things that "anyone could do."
This seems perfectly reasonable to me. Almost all of the "top achievers" I know also demonstrate exceptional talent in a completely different field.
- tomsaffell 15y agoAgreed, but I take exception to Everest and Kilimanjaro being put in the same bucket. Climbing Kilimanjaro is evidence of: appetite for travel; willingness to take on challenges; reasonable fitness; good will power. ~10,000 people do it each year. It's probably two or three sigma off Olympic / Everest standard - not that Everest is the pinnacle..
- cperciva 15y agoI happily defer to your superior knowledge of mountain climbing. :-)
- sardonicbryan 15y agoSounds like there might be an inefficiency in the resume filler market that an enterprising future IBanker/Lawyer/Consultant could exploit.
- msellout 15y agoIt also sounds like the filter is more about money. If you have expensive hobbies, you probably can relate to other wealthy people. Consulting firms in particular are looking for people that can "build relationships" with clients.
- microarchitect 15y agoAlmost all of the "top achievers" I know also demonstrate exceptional talent in a completely different field. I'm not so sure about that. What was Dennis Ritchie's exceptional "other talent"? Sergey Brin? David Patterson? Yale Patt? Linux Torvalds?
- cperciva 15y agoI don't know any of the above personally. Maybe they don't do anything exceptional in their private lives -- but I think it's more likely that they do and we don't hear about it.
- microarchitect 15y agoSo who are the top achievers you are referring to? I think it's more likely that they do and we don't hear about it. I'm pretty sure if Dennis Ritchie had climbed Everest or something, it would be all over the internet now. Anyway, my point is that as humans we often make the mistake of seeing patterns where none exist. So, we should be wary of making claims that are unsupported by strong evidence.
- spariev 15y agoLinux Torvalds? heh, nice typo ;)
- buff-a 15y agoWhat was Dennis Ritchie's exceptional "other talent"? Sergey Brin? David Patterson? Yale Patt? Linux Torvalds? Conviction?
- JoeAltmaier 15y agoYou don't actually hire any of those people - they hire you. Those are 'not the droids you're looking for'
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]