5 ms·
How do you become financially independent by developing your own Open Source project? Short answer --- in most cases you don't. To earn enough money to surviv
by jqpabc123 4y ago
How do you become financially independent by developing your own Open Source project?
Short answer --- in most cases you don't.
To earn enough money to survive, most have to do something other than software development --- like provide a service, provide support or sell a non-open version. Becoming a charity (a software panhandler) is an option but most can't survive this way.
Down vote if it makes you feel better but the most obvious, basic fact remains --- open source devalues the work of software development --- and is thus self limiting. Do it long enough and financial reality will intrude and convince you that you need to do something else.
- ohiovr 4y agoSoftware has no intrinsic value. It is harder to convey value of any kind unless it makes life easier somehow. But soon it gets replaced in a cascade of new solutions from the future that are hard to predict.
- jqpabc123 4y agoSo you're telling me that my software doesn't make life easier for my clients? It's pretty obvious that they disagree; otherwise, they wouldn't pay me. My bank account has the proof to the contrary.
- ohiovr 4y agoIt is hard(-er) to convey value of any kind unless it makes life easier somehow.
- chrisseaton 4y agoWhat software doesn’t make life easier? Why would such software ever get built?
- ohiovr 4y agoAdobe Flash and Actionscript 3.0. As for why actionscript 3.0 was made it was built I think Adobe wanted to turn Flash into an application programming language. And it failed pretty badly at this. Actionscript 2.0 had a well defined purpose that is to control animation. But Actionscript 3.0 became a monster that imposed a lot of work to do those basic things and it really did not excel at anything beyond that.
- chrisseaton 4y agoWhy does anyone use them if they don’t make life easier? They must do, otherwise nobody would use them.
- ohiovr 4y agoBecause they are or were fooled like me.
- tremon 4y agoThat's extrinsic value -- the value is derived not from the software itself, but from the gain in quality of life it gives your clients.
- beecafe 4y agoSoftware is trivial to make, it should rightly have no value.
- jqpabc123 4y agoHave you ever developed software? It consumes the most precious, valuable thing you will ever have --- your time. Time is more valuable then money --- you can always get more money but you can never get more time. *Your* time may not have any value --- but mine does.
- beecafe 4y agoEverything takes time. Something has (exchange) value if you get given something of value in exchange for it. Something has (intrinsic) value if you value that thing itself to give value in exchange for it, even if nobody else would give it any exchange value. This could be due to scarcity, sentimentality, or rarity. Unless you're deeply sentimental about the software you've produced, it has no value.
- jqpabc123 4y agoEverything takes time. Everything that takes time costs money. Why is software an exception? Try telling a carpenter or an auto technician he shouldn't be paid for his work time because "everything takes time". How did software developers take a left turn at reality? it has no value. I really don't care as long as people pay me for it.
- lupire 4y agoLook up the term "public good".
- JustSomeNobody 4y ago> Software is trivial to make... ... after one has developed countless man-years obtaining knowledge of how to solve complex problems. Actually, you know what? Still not trivial. It's easier for people with the desire to do this type of work. It's easier depending on the domain. But it's not "trivial".
- nvln 4y agoIf you have an itch to scratch, and you are really good at scratching that itch, and if many have that itch or will get it, OSS will open a lot of doors for you. If you can build a OSS-ish company like supabase or n8n, good for you. But you stand to win anyway. It's not as cut and dried as direct compensation for effort or time, but with some luck, you will get to places that a regular job may not take you.
- jqpabc123 4y agoIf you can build a OSS-ish company like supabase or n8n, good for you. Notice that one of the first things you'll find at the very top of these company's web sites is *Pricing*. These are primarily service providers --- with a limited/non-tested/demo/??? version of the source available --- mainly for marketing purposes.
- lupire 4y ago> open source devalues the work of software development Deprices, not devalues.
- jqpabc123 4y agoTomato, to-mato.
- silent_cal 4y agoI am so grateful for open source software because it is a huge sacrifice for someone to develop it for free when they could easily charge for it, and would be totally justified in doing so.
- jqpabc123 4y agoSure, if someone wants to make the sacrifice, by all means go for it. But the point is that everyone needs some financial return on their work in order to survive. And a sacrifice may not be the best plan to obtain it.
- eesmith 4y agoYour comment is incomplete, because in most cases you don't become financially independent by developing your own proprietary project. Most proprietary projects also need to do something other than software development, including providing support. Also, software development itself devalues the work of software development. That's what software libraries do. Around 1990 I would use Borland's graphics library, which came with the compiler I bought, because it was better than what I could do, and I had already paid for it. That said, I agree that an open source product is NOT an effective way of maximizing wealth extraction. Even something as simple as market segmentation, like discounts for students, is difficult if that student can turn around and place it on GitHub. Other options, like an OSS project funded by being cost savings to your employer (eg, to leave an expensive vendor, or to drive the supplier prices down), are easier to get paid for, though yes, also not enough to be financially independent.
- jqpabc123 4y agobecause in most cases you don't become financially independent by developing your own proprietary project. The last *job* I had was over 20 years ago. And I am not alone --- I know others who have done similar --- but not by way of open source. including providing support. True --- but the difference is, I can actually *pay* others to do most of this for me. My primary job is developing new software.
- eesmith 4y agoSure, and I made a living for 5 or so years selling open source software w/ support. The thing is, both of use are in the small minority. Few software projects result in financial independence for the original authors, open source or proprietary. After all, selling something in Apple's app store isn't a sure way to earn money.
- jqpabc123 4y agoSo what you're saying is that after 5 years of trying to make open source work, financial reality intruded and convinced you to do something different? This places you in a little different minority than me. My current financial reality has convinced me of just the opposite --- that doing something different would actually be detrimental.