3 ms·
I agree that the tolerance for risk is different today. But the argument would seem to imply, that NASA was then somehow more willing to endanger the lives of t
by belter 4y ago
I agree that the tolerance for risk is different today. But the argument would seem to imply, that NASA was then somehow more willing to endanger the lives of the crew. As mentioned, people died, so the increased caution was already a part of the program.
Let's not diminish the brilliant, flawless execution of the Apollo program, with the argument that they cared less for the lives of Astronauts.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoSorry, they were more willing to endanger the lives of the crew, and they even admitted it. I remember watching a documentary where they were estimating the percentage chance of the loss of the crew, and comparing that to the chance the Russians would beat them to the moon. The comment you replied to is correct. Every launch has a non-zero chance of death, and the Apollo program was simply willing to tolerate a higher probability of loss than we are today. I think if you want to call that "they cared less for the lives of Astronauts" that that's your own interpretation.
- foobarbecue 4y agoBrilliant, but certainly not flawless.
- eropple 4y ago"Flawless execution"? Apollo 1 burned three astronauts to death during a rehearsal test. They had astronauts back on top of a rocket in under twenty months. Acknowledging that their risk tolerances were higher than politics necessitates today doesn't "diminish" anything.
- cratermoon 4y ago> They had astronauts back on top of a rocket in under twenty months. In a redesigned spacecraft (based on the Block II that was already in development) that replaced the pure oxygen environment at launch with a Nitrogen/Oxygen atmosphere that was slowly bled off to pure O2 at the desired partial pressure once it was in space.
- p_l 4y agoSome of the critical changes were previously vetoed until Apollo 1 confirmed the worth of doors that opened to outside rather than inside, despite increased weight of the sealing mechanism.
- cratermoon 4y agoAnd yet the inward-opening door was itself a response to a near-fatal failure of the hatch on Liberty Bell 7. That almost killed the second American in space, Virgil I. "Gus" Grissom. Grissom was one of the three astronauts that died in the Apollo 1 fire.
- wiredfool 4y agoThere's a movie about one of the flawed launches. "Houston, we have a problem"
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]