7 ms·
The reasons why it's postponed matter. It was not weather, but clearly technical issues the program is struggling with. 50 Years ago...With less experience, mo
by belter 4y ago
The reasons why it's postponed matter. It was not weather, but clearly technical issues the program is struggling with.
50 Years ago...With less experience, more challenging technical issues, doing something never done, the Kennedy Space Center to the Moon line, had no scrubs and typical schedule delay was 1 second. Think about that...
https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/37482/reason-of-apollo-17-launch-delay https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/37482/reason-of-ap...
"...Only Apollo 17 had a long launch delay of 2 hours 40 minutes, Apollo 14 of 40 minutes. Most delays were less than a second..."
- justapassenger 4y ago50 years ago no one wore seatbelts and things were great? Nowadays everyone wears them, which means cars got more unsafe? Half of century is a a lot of advancement in safety. You have many orders more of magnitude of data, sensors and understanding of what to look for. Is Artemis a good program? Hell no. But that’s not a way to compare it.
- advisedwang 4y agoBesides Apollo 1, which other commenters mentioned, I wanted to do a fair comparison so looked up the first numbered apollo mission, 4. Wiki has a whole "Delays" section. I guess the closes equivalent was that it was originally rolled out Aug 26, 1967 but only launched Nov 9. So "no scrubs and typical schedule delay was 1 second" is totally untrue.
- belter 4y agoTotally true from Apollo 7 to Apollo 17. These are the missions in the reference link. But if we are going to include previous programs before Apollo 7, then we should include the predecessors programs of Artemis 1. Meaning, none...What speaks to the delays and lack of execution. Also caused of course, by Congress mandates.
- mikece 4y ago> "...Only Apollo 17 had a long launch delay of 2 hours 40 minutes, Apollo 14 of 40 minutes. Most delays were less than a second..." NASA is out of practice (and it's not being run by Germans anymore).
- melling 4y agoAt what point do we say “you were wrong, project canceled!” We are way past the original timeline and budget. You fail! After 2 decades, time to acknowledge it: https://www.nybooks.com/articles/2004/04/08/the-wrong-stuff/ https://www.nybooks.com/articles/2004/04/08/the-wrong-stuff/
- pfdietz 4y agoWhen the senators behind the program are out of power.
- Torkel 4y ago"NASA is not being run by Germans anymore." Literally laghed out loud on this one and had to explain to coworkers what was so funny :)
- belter 4y agoNow that you mention it, until 2021, the Vice President of Mission Assurance at SpaceX was German... :-)
- belter 4y ago[1] "...The Saturn second stage was built by North American Aviation at its plant at Seal Beach, California, shipped to NASA's Marshall Space Flight Center, Huntsville, Alabama, and there tested to ensure that it met contract specifications. Problems developed on this piece of the Saturn effort and Wernher von Braun began intensive investigations. Essentially his engineers completely disassembled and examined every part of every stage delivered by North American to ensure no defects... ...This was an enormously expensive and time-consuming process, grinding the stage's production schedule almost to a standstill and jeopardizing the Presidential timetable. When this happened Webb told von Braun to desist, adding that "We've got to trust American industry." The issue came to a showdown at a meeting where the Marshall rocket team was asked to explain its extreme measures. While doing so, one of the engineers produced a rag and told Webb that "this is what we find in this stuff." The contractors, the Marshall engineers believed, required extensive oversight to ensure they produced the highest quality work. A compromise emerged that was called the 10 percent rule: 10 percent of all funding for NASA was to be spent to ensure in- house expertise and in the process check contractor reliability..." [1] https://history.nasa.gov/Apollomon/Apollo.html https://history.nasa.gov/Apollomon/Apollo.html
- simonh 4y agoThe first uncrewed test flight of a Saturn V was Apollo 4. >The original launch date was planned for early 1967, but was delayed to November 9 because of a myriad of problems with various elements of the spacecraft, and difficulties during pre-flight testing.... These issues delayed the flight through much of 1967. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apollo_4 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apollo_4
- ddevault 4y agoApollo also had its fair share of problems, some of which cost lives. This launch is a test flight, so such problems are normal, and delays are much better than an exploding rocket. Launch delays of this nature are very common across the space industry. The Artemis program is going straight to crewed flights after this one so they are being very cautious. I wouldn't rise to an unconditional defense of SLS as a whole, but this particular issue is picking nits.
- altacc 4y agoIt is wrong to compare these two very different eras. The Apollo program was an ideological race, so there was a mush higher tolerance of risk and financial and human costs. Remember, people died on the US & Soviet space programs as they were figuring things out. There might not have been many launch scrubs but there were plenty of failures. Today, the tolerance for risk is much lower, the costs higher and the budget much more controlled. There are many politicians who want to greatly reduce NASA's budget in favour of private ventures. A failed launch is ammo for their cause. So whereas Apollo could proceed (with some delays) after people burnt to death in a capsule, if that happened today the whole program would be halted indefinitely and NASA heavily questioned as to why it needed to take such risks. 50 years on from Apollo, NASA has learnt that an abundance of caution is needed.
- panick21_ 4y ago> There are many politicians who want to greatly reduce NASA's budget in favour of private ventures. No actually they want to give NASA more money so NASA can buy what it needs from private ventures.
- zmgsabst 4y agoHow many versions of Starship did Space X explode or crash? They seem to have produced better results on less money — so if NASA can’t follow the strategy that works, why should we throw more into the money pit?
- mavhc 4y agoSpaceX want to produce the least rocket they need, NASA want 0 failures, so they'll always have too much rocket Also SpaceX plan to make 1000 Starships, and NASA plans to make about 5 of theirs
- dotnet00 4y agoUnfortunately NASA doesn't have the ability to even appear to fail explosively while SpaceX can afford to laugh about it. Any significant explosion would have the tech illiterate Congress breathing down their necks.
- klausa 4y agoAh yes, the glory days of Apollo 1 and Challenger.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoThe Apollo program cost was roughly $257bn adjusted for inflation. The Saturn V rocket project cost roughly $50bn adjusted for inflation. Artemis is roughly $35bn. The SLS rocket project cost $23bn. Perspective helps
- ekianjo 4y agoRather than pure dollar costs, better the compare in % of government budget.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budget_of_NASA https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budget_of_NASA Doesn't get much clearer than that chart. Oof!
- shagie 4y agoThere's a Neil deGrasse Tyson video titled We Stopped Dreaming that gets into the NASA budget (and the related society changes) https://youtu.be/CbIZU8cQWXc https://youtu.be/CbIZU8cQWXc The part about the NASA budget is at 2:00 though it's all a good watch.
- psim1 4y agoIt was a time of, frankly, reckless engineering and hubris, though with great results. Challenger taught us a lesson. They pushed ahead into disaster due to ego. NASA won't do that again.
- unethical_ban 4y agoI suggest you look up Apollo 1 if you think everything was rosy during the first set of missions to the moon. edit for humility: I had to look up the Artemis details last night to see that SpaceX is part of the critical path to a moon landing, so I'm not faulting someone for ignorance. It happens.
- kemiller2002 4y agoI remember the challenger explosion. I know exactly where I was. I remember seeing the teacher's face on the tv. That's what take unnecessary risks gets you. I understand being careful.
- foobarbecue 4y ago"The teacher" being Christa McAuliffe?
- lb1lf 4y agoPresumably you're thinking of Christa McAuliffe's mother, who were, unless this is a fake memory in my head, shown on live TV just as the space shuttle blew up right in front of her face. Understandably, her face was all in turmoil. It is three first picture popping into my mind whenever Challenger comes up.
- brycewray 4y agoShown, yes. Shown on live TV, no. It was a while after the explosion before the networks began running the tape from the camera focused on Ms. McAuliffe’s parents and sister in the grandstands on the beach.
- lb1lf 4y agoThanks! (I was eight at the time and in Europe, so while I remember it as being live, it is not unlikely it was an edited news segment shown on Norwegian TV.)
- bnralt 4y agoIt also makes one question just how useful spending those resources on going to the moon in the first place. After spending all that time and all those resources (not just financial; it also occupied the time of our limited pool of top engineers and scientists) on going to the moon, over 50 years later we're still struggling to return there. People don't seem to understand that we make good use of space and space flight, but humans in space just aren't that useful at the moment. At the beginning of the space age it seemed like they might be; there were ideas for a manned spy satellite, such as the Manned Orbiting Laboratory[1]. But as tech advanced, the people who actually using space flight to accomplish things realized that automated systems functioned better. NASA spends 44.9% of its budget on human space flight, and just 3.5% on aeronautics[2], when it's likely the aeronautics research improves people's lives much more than the human space flight efforts. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manned_Orbiting_Laboratory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manned_Orbiting_Laboratory [2] https://www.planetary.org/space-policy/nasa-budget https://www.planetary.org/space-policy/nasa-budget
- trasz 4y agoYou can’t claim territory without sending people.
- bnralt 4y agoConsider the last inhospitable area there was a rush to explore, Antarctica. The efforts to claim it haven't amounted to much, mostly because it's such a terrible place to build settlements. Chile and Argentina have tried to make settlements at the very tip, but the population there is smaller than the population of the USA's McMurdo Station. Antarctic exploration is a good analogy. A little over a century ago, it was the new frontier. But as we advanced, the excitement gave way to cold reality. Though it was exciting at the time, I doubt most people could tell you who the first person to reach the South Pole was. And the doubtful that the journeys actually provided any benefit to modern researchers there. If we had simply waited a few decades and started exploring when the technology was there (the so-called "Mechanical age" of Antarctic exploration), fewer lives would have been lost and we would have been in the same place we are today.