5 ms·
The problem is the double standard. It's only ever conservatives who are criticized for this kind of pointless politicking and tribalism, while it goes unchall
by zozbot234 4y ago
The problem is the double standard. It's only ever conservatives who are criticized for this kind of pointless politicking and tribalism, while it goes unchallenged from the other side.
- Sohcahtoa82 4y agoConservatives get criticized for tribalism more than the left because they're simply so much more tribal. All you have to do is look at how many Trump flags you still see compared to Biden flags. Also, believe or not, the far left dislikes Biden.
- happytoexplain 4y agoAgreed - the accusation of tribalism may be unfairly over-applied in many cases, like most political criticisms, but, also like many political criticisms, it is extrapolated from an opinion that is more reasonable (regardless of whether it is definitely true), which is that conservatives have, on par, too much party loyalty, and liberals have, on par, too little party loyalty.
- Sohcahtoa82 4y ago> and liberals have, on par, too little party loyalty. My knee-jerk reaction is "this is a good thing", but this is wrong. The left's lack of party loyalty costs us elections. The farther left hates the "Vote blue no matter who" mantra, which allowed Trump to win 2016. The right votes red no matter what because they think every democrat is a socialist.
- tptacek 4y agoNo, it's not only conservatives who are criticized. You just notice it when they are. Your brain has a finite capacity for keeping score on this kind of stuff; this is one of the tricks it plays on you to keep you from being anxious about that.
- Chris2048 4y agoInteresting that this comment has two replies: yours: "they aren't criticised more, this is bias of observation on your part" other comment: "that's b/c they are more tribal!" Observation bias exists, but that doesn't mean there isn't a moderation bias, one way or another. However, I think the distinction of "conservative" is maybe a red-herring - it invites tribalism. As an example, I think people refusing to wear mandated COVID masks are provocative/incorrect. I also believe the authorities (gov and media/corps) are incorrect, and actively biasing scientific discourse. So, is my opinion conservative, or not?
- tptacek 4y agoI don't know what you're asking, but my reply isn't ideologically specific. It applies just as well to liberals. I'm specifically not saying either side is more tribal; I'm saying that we have cognitive biases that make us sensitive to corrections of opinions we agree with, and insensitive to corrections of opinions we disagree with.
- Chris2048 4y agoBut you didn't say there might be cognitive bias. You stated there was, and implied there is no such bias on HN? I'm not so sure. My question was to imply - there may be talking points, or "biases" considered conservative/liberal, but this is an ambiguous thing. Often, full perspectives are a mixture of both, but people might still be censored on the "perception" of their tribe, or on individual points. As such, the perceived tribes are not a useful distinction to make.
- tptacek 4y agoI just told you what I meant.
- happytoexplain 4y agoWhy is it "interesting" that two people have different opinions? It sounds like you're doing that thing where somebody points at one ostensible counterexample with a bit of snideness ("You say global warming is real, but there's a historic snowstorm outside. How interesting."), but I could be misinterpreting.