4 ms·
(This is why I find Occupy Wall Street threatening.) I do not think OWS, to the extent it has a coherent set or ideas or ideologies, is anti-business per se; I
by jseliger 15y ago
(This is why I find Occupy Wall Street threatening.)
I do not think OWS, to the extent it has a coherent set or ideas or ideologies, is anti-business per se; I think it is opposed to the zero-sum thinking that characterizes much of Wall Street and political life right now. See, e.g.: http://www.slate.com/blogs/the_reckoning/2011/11/21/it_s_the_politics_stupid_.html http://www.slate.com/blogs/the_reckoning/2011/11/21/it_s_the... :
<blockquote>In fact, blame for the failure of the congressional super committee belongs with every American who failed to vote in the 2010 midterm election. Nothing encapsulates the dysfunction of American democracy better than the fact that we abdicate responsibility for governing our country (and running our economy) to a radical minority every four years out of laziness and, to a smaller extent, deliberate efforts by both parties to depress turnout they know will favor their rivals.</blockquote>
Or, from HN, http://www.forbes.com/sites/stevedenning/2011/11/18/clayton-christensen-how-pursuit-of-profits-kills-innovation-and-the-us-economy http://www.forbes.com/sites/stevedenning/2011/11/18/clayton-... (Clayton Christensen: "How Pursuit of Profits Kills Innovation and the U.S. Economy.")
Notice how people are not saying "Occupy tech firms in Silicon Valley," and I think they aren't because it's pretty clear that Apple, Google, etc. are generating real value that improves lives; it's not at all clear finance and many parts of government are doing so at the moment and it may be that they're actually destroying value while taking advantage of an insider's feedback loop that prevents market forces from actually acting on them in any serious way. If anything, I suspect OWS, to the extent it has a coherent ideology, would be pro-business, as long as that business isn't doing things to hurt people, institutions, or government.
- peterb 15y agoOWS is not against capitalism, it is against corporatism. It wants the same laws enforced weather you are rich, poor, an individual or a corporation.
- noahc 15y agoPerhaps I'm nitpicking here, but I believe they don't actually want the same laws for individuals and corporations. They don't want corporations to have the same rights as individuals.
- wnight 15y agoSort of. But if you played a small form of the recent mortgage scam a police officer would put cuffs on you and take you away for running a Ponzi scheme. Run a large enough one and they bail you out and let you keep profiting on it. I haven't seen a single person charged in the mortgage meltdown despite that almost everyone at every bank was in a better position to see the problems than I was, as a borrower, did. If our laws were applied without regard for the wealth of the guilty almost every bank employee in the majority of the world would be charged with conspiracy to defraud their customers and at least permanently banned from ever professionally handling money. (They did worse than Kevin Mitnick, they deserve worse punishments.) As for corporations having rights, it's ridiculous. My cycling group doesn't have rights, the individuals in it have rights. Corporations are groups of individuals and thus, indirectly, have all the rights they need. Anything beyond that is corruption.
- natrius 15y ago"I think it is opposed to the zero-sum thinking that characterizes much of Wall Street and political life right now." No, I think OWS is very pro-zero-sum thinking. Its core messaging pits "the 99%" against "the 1%". It's class warfare in its purest form. There are many smart people who are painting more reasoned critiques of our society onto OWS than the movement is actually articulating. Perhaps that's inherent to mass movements in general, but I judge OWS by its most common messages, which are far from what you've described. There are two OWS-related messages that would have broad appeal, and I'd suggest they focus on those: "Our Laws Are Not For Sale" and "Too Big To Fail Is Too Big To Exist".
- jberryman 15y agoHistorically invoking the term "class warfare" has been a way to scare liberals out of broaching issues of class and wealth disparity in America. Using it here makes you look like a shill. The Occupy movement is about finally having a discussion about these issues.
- natrius 15y agoAllow me to restate my claim without the words of which you disapprove. The most common message of OWS reduces to "households that make more than $500,000 a year are against everyone else." This is problematic.
- olefoo 15y agoIt is problematic; more so because it is true. Households that make more than $500,000 a year pay less in taxes as a percentage of their earnings than households that make $50,000 a year. They also benefit disproportionately from the protections our society offers and suffer less from the economic uncertainty that has become the bane of middle-class existence in the last two decades. Now I am certain you can find more than a few members of that group who are sympathetic to the plight of the middle class but how many can you find that would be in favor of rescinding the Bush tax cuts?
- 15y ago