8 ms·
Teenager invented a low-cost tool to spot elephant poachers
- whycombinetor 4y agoSurely you can discriminate a human from an elephant _by size alone_ with a thermal camera, without needing to resort to movement patterns.
- remram 4y agoProbably measuring the size is difficult, unless your camera is reporting depth? I don't know.
- whycombinetor 4y agoIf you are flying a drone overhead, you know the altitude and can do basic trig to find total distance from sensor angle. With even very approximate distances one should be able to distinguish a 200lb, 0.4m wide, 0.2m long human from a 10,000lb, 1.5m wide, 4m long elephant.
- abailin 4y agoRelated in world news: France taxman deploys AI spy to spot hidden swimming pools https://www.france24.com/en/live-news/20220829-france-taxman-deploys-ai-spy-to-spot-hidden-swimming-pools https://www.france24.com/en/live-news/20220829-france-taxman...
- TrackerFF 4y agoIt's a nice project, from start to end. Gives you real insight how "real world" ML-backed systems work. Data acquisition, feature engineering, model design / tuning, etc. This kind of system is what you'd expect to see in maybe a graduate level ML/DL class, maybe even Bachelors thesis. Whether or not it actually works for catching poachers isn't all that important IMO, even though they're marketing it that way. As many have mentioned, for it to really work, you'd probably need a small fleet of drones - and more likely, data from satellite providers. In my area of work (surveillance / intelligence), we do a lot of similar stuff - students like these are awesome to work with for summer internships / thesis projects.
- yonaguska 4y agoIt's neat, but the real solution is fixing the incentives for poachers in the first place. It's an economic issue at its root
- mijail 4y agoKudos to her. Conservation tech is a challenging and exciting test bed for "hackers" because it's a hyper dimensional chessboard of constraints and strategies. It's easy to reduce the solution to "just do this." From one end, poaching is lucrative in areas with massive economic disparity. And from the other, climate change and the pressure we put on natural resources is unbalancing ecosystems driving human wildlife conflict. A project I've worked on is Trailguard AI, ran by resolve.ngo, the principal is Eric Dinnerstein who is the former chief scientist at WWF. I can say they our running a start up in every sense of the word but the result is beautiful: a satelite/ gsm connected, battery powered AI enabled cryptic trail cam that can be used as a swiss army knife from animal censuses, to poacher detection, illegal logging truck detection and preventing human wildlife content (detect tiger + sound alarm). Good article on trailguard: https://globalconservation.org/news/tech-parks-trailguard-ai/ https://globalconservation.org/news/tech-parks-trailguard-ai...
- shreyshnaccount 4y agoI made a very very similar project in year 12 in school. (got nationally ranked too). looks like they have taken it a few (very important) steps further www.github.com/itsa-mee-mario/guardians-of-the-wildlife. (sorry for the cheesy name ad)
- EvanKnowles 4y agoI was in the Kruger this weekend, and our guide was lamenting that they've already lost over 340 rhino this year, and said poachers keep hacking their radios and finding out where the rhino are, even when they change code they speak in. I find the chance of that to be roughly zero though - clearly a bunch of the guides have been paid off. This isn't a problem tech can solve.
- SV_BubbleTime 4y agoSecret shopper and encrypted radios? If the radios can be trusted, you feed bad data to specific people and see when the poachers show up. Seems like there are some solutions. When I was in South Africa, the anti-poaching crews were clearly underpaid judging by their cloths, demeanor, and gear (old radios, and the ratty shotguns). If the job is so important it should be better paid.
- hackernewds 4y agoInstalling your people as guides > paying off poachers.
- la-di-da-do 4y agoNow that is what I call girl power what a girl boss girl girl girl! You go, girl!
- SoftTalker 4y ago“I was quite taken aback,” the 17-year-old from Chappaqua, New York, recalls. “Because I always thought, ‘well, poaching is illegal, how come it really is still such a big issue?’” Life lesson. If an activity can generate income, someone will do it. Law notwithstanding.
- msadowski 4y agoThis reminds me of this thread on the Ardupilot forum from someone in the field using drones to find poachers: https://discuss.ardupilot.org/t/autonomous-anti-poaching-drone/25344/98 https://discuss.ardupilot.org/t/autonomous-anti-poaching-dro... . The gist of it was that the drones were not that effective at spotting poachers (8 cases in two years of operations), and even if you spot them they will likely be gone by the time someone can arrive there.
- sbf501 4y agoWell, if we don't solve the poacher problem, eventually it will solve itself: no more rare animals to poach.
- dmje 4y agoAnnnnd my "bitter, cynical, grumpy HN type" radar just bust a cog :-)
- aaron695 4y ago
- adultSwim 4y agoI feel like we are solving the wrong problem. People are being killed for living and working land that they have used for ages.
- Avalaxy 4y agoSo it doesn't detect poachers, it detects humans. And it requires drones flying non-stop over gigantic masses of land. Edit: having dabbled in this field myself during my studies, I know from research that one of the biggest problems is simply corruption among rangers. It doesn't really matter if you can spot a poacher if a whole group of rangers will decide to not do anything about it (because for them the financial incentive of doing nothing can be HUGE). Of course the corruption problem stems from very low incomes and poor living conditions in those countries. If your monthly income is $100, it's quite tempting to accept a $10.000 bribe. Edit 2: I worked on this: https://www.hackthepoacher.com/ https://www.hackthepoacher.com/. We tried it with cell phone detection.
- cultofmetatron 4y agoalso, drones cause major distress to elephants. it sounds like bees to them. its a major reason you are not allowed to fly them in chiang mai.
- orangepurple 4y agoIf the US rented a Northrop Grumman RQ-4 Global Hawk equipped with appropriate imaging systems to these governments the poaching game might change. Lesser reliance on corrupt rangers. Unfortunately I doubt these things make financial sense in the name of conservation
- jjtheblunt 4y agoSo pay rangers more, with bonus incentives to capture or kill poachers, wanted dead or alive like famous wild west posters from the 1800s?
- elp 4y agoThis was pretty much what the owner of small game park told me. The drones are too high tech and expensive for them to run. He said having small teams patrol every night worked better. When the teams haven't been able to patrol, for example due to flooded roads. He said it only took a couple of weeks before the poachers started showing up again. I always wonder if the better solution isn't to re-legalize ivory and rhino horn. All the game farms have room full of the stuff. Dumping that onto the market will kill the price, at the same time there is suddenly a financial incentive to keep the animals safe. Currently its $10k a horn on the black market vs a bit of tourism money to incentivize keeping the parks safe. The saddest part is that horn and tusks grow back so it could be a renewable resource if farmed properly. The poachers only kill.
- throwaway290 4y agoI wonder if poachers quickly learn to alter behavior in presence of drone noise...
- scrose 4y agoI have a rather loud drone(DJI mini 2). From about 70m and up, the noise is practically non-existent, even when hovering directly overhead.
- nobodyandproud 4y agoDrones can be very quiet. I saw my police flying playing with one and it was a whisper even from 30 feet away. I was surprised because I thought all drones had that annoyingly loud hum.
- gigatexal 4y agoUnless killed for meat by indigenous folks who need it I 100% support the tracking/hunting/fining/imprisoning/etc of anyone that kills an Elephant for its tusks or worse for sport.
- googlryas 4y agoWhat about villagers killing elephants who raid and destroy their crops?
- gigatexal 4y agoI'd say that's ok, too, though that's tougher since humans are spreading and clearing ever more acreage of land for farming that it's affecting what used to be the habit of many animals not just the elephant. There's no clear, easy answer here, but surely we can take a hard stance on folks that hunt them for sport or the ivory trade.
- gigatexal 4y agoCorrection: I don’t support the hunting of people even if they are hunters.
- what-imright 4y agoThere should be laws against these 'look at my clever wiz kid' articles. It's not that far off from beauty pageants and equally sick and pretentious. I remember just last week here in Berkeley seeing a young teenager playing Beethoven's 9th on an electric keyboard, perfectly. He was playing on the street and had all of $10 in change in his bowl. The look of misery on his face as his fingers effortlessly worked out the melody was astounding. He looked like a caged animal, living out his parent's dream in captivity. $50 says he blows his brains out by his thirties. This is abuse plain and simple.
- SV_BubbleTime 4y agoAnytime there says “there aught to be a law…” there almost never should be. That said, I agree the whiz kid articles are dumb, but not for the reasons you listed. More just “yea, let’s see how they do when they don’t have infinite time and zero responsibilities”.
- klyrs 4y agoReally? This kid clearly cares about the world and wanted to apply herself to a problem. There should be a law against rewarding such initiative with publicity? She's 17. When I was that age, I was completely bored to death by what I was "learning" in high school and I had one foot out the door. With regards to that musical kid... I've got resting bitch face. When I'm focused on a difficult task, it's way worse; I call it "thinking murder face." I'm a musician, and if I'm playing a complex piece, I couldn't smile if I tried, even though I'm loving every second of what I'm doing.
- vadym909 4y agoWon’t the poachers just change their speed and turning radius to not appear as humans? I’ve become a bit skeptical of these stories on kids doing what normally experienced professionals do (research, startups). I’d understand if a kid accidentally discovered or invented something cool that no one else thought of. I wish kids focused on fun and learning in school. Some of these stories seem like ‘spike’ projects to help the kids college application standout.
- bena 4y agoThis is the kind of shit I would be doing for fun and learning in school. Kids have the disposable time to dedicate to grind stuff like this out. All they really need is the spark of interest, then everything else takes care of itself.