3 ms·
NASA's future would be much brighter if its programs had a reasonable chance of leading to something worthwhile. Nothing based on SLS will ever be worthwhile.
by pfdietz 4y ago
NASA's future would be much brighter if its programs had a reasonable chance of leading to something worthwhile. Nothing based on SLS will ever be worthwhile.
- biotinker 4y agoThere could very well be worthwhile things spurred or inspired by things the SLS does. If the SLS indeed manages to put people back on the moon in the next 2-3 years, that could inspire a permanent moon presence, and that would be huge for development of future technology.
- willglynn 4y ago> If the SLS indeed manages to put people back on the moon in the next 2-3 years Well, Artemis 2 is scheduled for May 2024. It is to take crew on a lunar flyby, i.e. not even entering lunar orbit, which in my view makes it a lot less inspiring than Apollo 8. Artemis 3 is to put people on the moon, but is currently "no earlier than 2025" with many missing pieces in the critical path. The spacesuits themselves are no earlier than April 2025, and while they loosened the Gateway requirement, it still needs a spacecraft to get from Orion to the moon and back. NASA selected Starship. If SpaceX can put Starship on the moon, what are the odds that Artemis 3 will be its first crewed trip? I don't think Artemis 3 has any chance of being the catalyst you describe.
- gtowey 4y agoIt's just my opinion, but I don't think Starship will ever reach the moon. The leap in difficulty from Falcon to Starship is too big for SpaceX. It's like the promise of fully autonomous Teslas. Musk will never deliver.
- robin_reala 4y agoIt’s provably possible to land on the moon using 60s technology. No-one has yet built a self driving car that can cope with all needed situations without endangering the occupants and other road users. I don’t think the two scenarios are really comparable.
- gtowey 4y agoThat's kind of my point though. SpaceX isn't claiming that Starship is boring old reliable 60's technology. He's promising a rocket with huge leaps in capability. It's a lot to ask to do all these new things and do it reliably enough for human-rated space travel. I mean, their engines are still melting which means they fundamentally don't have the lift capability they claim. I'm sure they could get them to work if they just ran them cooler, but cooler engines means less thrust and that changes everything about a rocket's capability. And that's what makes it exactly like the self-driving car problem in my mind -- they're stuck at an impasse that might not really have a viable solution all while Musk is saying they'll be delivering any day now. You just can't trust a thing he says about when and how much they'll deliver.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoTheir plan of landing a single stage is pure fantasy. The risk of tipping over or damaging the engines with debris makes it unworkable. At best they might be able to pull off a special two stage variant with landing legs but they aren't going to get there in three years.
- versteegen 4y agoThe issue with stability is not that it's a single stage, but rather the tall shape of the lunar Starship. A single stage lander/ascender, with all the weight of the engines on the bottom, will be beneficial for stability. The mass of the engines is a significant fraction of the total because there's rather little propellant. (E.g. the Apollo ascent stage had a propellant mass ratio of exactly 1:1 (2,353kg to 4,700kg gross), despite a low ISP of only 311s.) But certainly you're right about the risk of damage on landing.
- panick21_ 4y agoGood that you know so much more then the people at NASA who investigated the design. The initial design has special high up landing engines btw, this solves the debris issue. And in terms of the stability, Starship has enough mass-fraction to add whatever kind of legs on that thing they want. NASA didn't even list that as a minor issue in the report.
- panick21_ 4y agoNASA has selected Starship as the only lander, if SpaceX wont make it to the moon, neither will NASA.
- panick21_ 4y agoSLS wouldn't put people back on the moon. The actual moon lander is Starship. If people land on the moon. Starship will be the impressive inspirational thing, not SLS. And Starship is what you need to have a permanent moon base. Its a simple fact that there is not enough budget for a moon base, as long as NASA is forced into SLS. Do the math and you will see. There is a reason literally everything other then Orion is already taken away from SLS. Both science missions and all other moon missions and landers are no longer going to use SLS. SLS is literally just there to put Orion into moon orbit. That's it. And that could be achieved other ways as well. SLS is just a crouch that NASA is forced to use. And on the pictures on television, when Astronauts get out on to the moon, it will be a large SpaceX rocket.
- unethical_ban 4y agoLanding on the moon is worthwhile.
- natch 4y agoArtemis will not land on the moon.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- killyourcar 4y agoNo one claimed the first Artemis mission would. The parent claimed "nothing the SLS will ever do" The SLS will (most likely) put people on the moon as part of a later Artemis mission.
- natch 4y agoNope. Starship will do that, not SLS. NASA already gave the contract for landing to SpaceX. And as for later versions of SLS after that… I highly doubt they will ever fly, because the insanity of the cost and they non-reusability will become too glaringly obvious to everyone.
- adastra22 4y agoThe SLS won't land people on the moon either. A completely unrelated rocket system that doesn't rely on the SLS in any way is used for that. SLS is totally redundant.
- bayesian_horse 4y agoSLS isn't redundant. SLS+Orion is a system that is trusted and certified to put Humans into LEO and then lunar orbit. The "completely unrelated rocket" will not be certified to launch Humans in time. The modified Starship that is used as a lander will undergo some certification, but ferrying Humans from lunar surface to lunar orbit is a lot less difficult and risky than blasting off of Earth.