3 ms·
> Baptist’s data and arguments are convincing, and I must agree with him in acknowledging Southern cotton slavery played a significant role in the development o
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
> Baptist’s data and arguments are convincing, and I must agree with him in acknowledging Southern cotton slavery played a significant role in the development of industrialized capitalism in the U.S. mainly because the first types of factories were textile mills, which used the cotton picked by slaves.
Okay, so we're all agreed then. Thought they were going to start denying basic historical facts for a moment there, and undermine everyone's faith in yet another academic discipline because they spoke the politically incorrect truth..
> Still, I believe it is incorrect to say slavery was the most important factor in capitalist development in this country. Slavery in itself does not promote capitalism, as evidence by the lack of capitalist development in Latin America and the Caribbean where slavery was just as intense, if not more intense, as it was in the American Deep South.
I don't think anyone was claiming that the Deep South was 'capitalist' at that time, just that the capitalists got rich off the slave produced raw materials from the Deep South in their factories. Which you just agreed happened.
> Additionally, the abundance of cotton in itself did not spur entrepreneurs in the northern US states to open textile mills and inventors to develop accompanying technologies. Something else—the American free market system, property rights, the freedom to command one’s own destiny, and the rugged individualist spirit—did.
I love that last paragraph. It wasn't the slave picked cotten that fed the textile mills, it's was good old American pluck and ingenuity.
> Another important point of discussion is how the country can live with itself knowing the role slavery played in its development. Many liberals and leftists use the types of findings and arguments found in works like Baptist’s as fodder for iconoclasm aimed at this country
Ah, here we get to the point. You can't connect capitalism to slavery, because slavery is bad and capitalism is good. To prevent that connection being we'll just brazenly deny slavery ever happened, if you prove it happened we'll suggest it was a good thing, it you prove it's a bad thing we'll say it was nothing to do with us.
This is very reminiscent of climate change. Somehow they don't get that this makes them look worse. Climate change wasn't caused by capitalism? You just pretended it wasn't happening because you didn't like the policy implications? That's not a good look. If you question someone about a murder and they claim that no-one died, it doesn't do their credibility any good when the body slumps out from under the table and they claim "Wait, I just had some minor quibbles with your police procedures".