2 ms·
I don't understand the purpose of letting actively used domains expire. It's a flaw in the web that is a constant threat to things breaking. This could easily h
by charcircuit 4y ago
I don't understand the purpose of letting actively used domains expire. It's a flaw in the web that is a constant threat to things breaking. This could easily happen to tens of thousands of business or more.
- kirykl 4y agoSame reason a metered parking spot expires even when a car is in it Or why you pay to have a telephone number
- charcircuit 4y agoThis can be solved by allowing anyone to pay to push the expiration date back.
- rnk 4y agoOf course a big reason they expire is so the registrars can get money from you registering them, they aren't providing much service. A much more sensible system is they wouldn't expire. The domain registration industrial complex, with the zillions of dodgy groups that squat on domains is of course not providing much value to the world.
- tialaramex 4y agoIf you want to have a different policy, you can set up a domain with a different policy. If you have a few million dollars you can do this for a TLD, maybe .charcircuit. But, you will need to figure out where your million dollars a year comes from. Maybe you could require a renewal fee... oh, right. And you'll need some mechanism to clear out useless garbage. For today's domains the renewal fee does that, but you don't want that fee, so... maybe you'll pay interns to look at each domain, weigh up whether it seems "active" enough and if not delete it ? How does an intern guess whether some.example gets a lot of email? Sends a lot of email but with its return address listed? Is mentioned in Java package names for important software? Has a fun text adventure hidden in its DNS answers? Oh they can't do all those things (and dozens of others I didn't think of) ? Then your service isn't fit for purpose or you must commit to keeping absolutely everything, forever, no matter what, which has unlimited cost.
- charcircuit 4y agoYou lookup the IP for the domain and port scan it to see if any services are running. You provide a form where anyone can input a subdomain + domain that will push back the expiration date by a year. You can also have the .com DNS servers see how often the domain is resolved. If it's not resolved for a year it should expire.
- em_te 4y agoThe ENS domain system is similar, but they added a few rules to benefit the domain holder: 1) When the domain expires, it still remains active and still linked to the previous owner. People can still use it as normal. 2) When it expires, the price is set to a very high price for a few weeks. Anyone can buy it at the higher price. If no one buys it, it still remains active and linked to the previous owner. 3) If the previous owner wants to buy it back after it has expired, they just need to pay their original price (not the high price), provided that someone else hasn't already bought it. 4) At the end of the initial few weeks, the price drops a little and remains at this price for a few more weeks. 5) The price eventually drops to the regular price after many weeks. 6) At any time anyone can pay to extend the registration for another year.