3 ms·
>Unless one doesn't consider writing compilers, linkers, GPU debuggers, container management, syscall emulators, unikernels [to be] systems programming. Since
by coldtea 4y ago
>Unless one doesn't consider writing compilers, linkers, GPU debuggers, container management, syscall emulators, unikernels [to be] systems programming.
Since you can write the above with any language, perhaps even Python or Lua if you wanted to, it's not exactly the ability to write the above or the fact of having written the above in a language, that makes a language to be considered a "systems programming language".
In some way, what is called a systems languge it's not a technical capacity thing ("can do X, Y and Z, so it's a systems language").
It's a term applied deliberately, that also includes other aspects.
- pjmlp 4y agoSure one can play word games all day long if that is your point.
- coldtea 4y agoCivilization is all about word games, is my larger point, and those games are important business and what drive characterization - they're not something incosequential that we can "set aside and get to the real work". Doubly so if what we're concerned about is labelling itself, like "what is and what isn't considered a systems language". Then we're in the word domain, not in the measurement domain.
- pjmlp 4y agoActions matter more than words, and in that field Go has already proven itself, regardless of what the priests of the holy church of system programming might preach at the pulpit. In fact their holy C can only be used for the daily activities, when going outside the ISO C Bible, tainting itself with unholy compiler extensions.
- sophacles 4y agoI challenge you to find me two concurring definitions of systems programming that also include enough detail to set clear bounds between what is and isn't systems programming. If you succeed at that, I further challenge you to: find me two concurring definitions of systems programming language that include enough detail to qualify and disqualify languages consistently. By "enough detail" and "clear bounds" i mean: a group of people independently arriving at the same sets of classification based on your provided definitions.
- coldtea 4y ago>I challenge you to find me two concurring definitions of systems programming that also include enough detail to set clear bounds between what is and isn't systems programming. There's no such thing - that was the whole point of my comment. A systems language is not such because of conforming to a definition, it's a delibarate classification ("this language is, that one isn't" as opposed to "this langauge is because it conforms to this definition"). And that "is/isn't" isn't even up to the individual programmer, it's cultural. There are characteristics that drive this classification, but it's not driven by a strict definition. It's more of "know it when I see it" kind of affair.
- pjmlp 4y agoPity that even ISO C fails at it, and needs language extensions to play game.