3 ms·
Ask HN: Consumer Spectroscopy?
Is there any way, as a consumer, to use spectroscopy to determine what atoms/molecules are contained in a product?
For instance when you buy gold leaf to check that it's really gold. Or to see if your water is contaminated with, say, lead or PFOA. Or even to compare different kinds of water, like different brands of bottled water.
As it is, as a consumer, I have to rely on marketing and regulatory oversight. And while there are commercially available tests for, say, water contaminants or phthalates, these are expensive, they are slow, and they only test for specific compounds.
Ideally, I'd like to have a device that I can just point at a sample, and which will tell me exactly what atoms are present in there, and, ideally, a list of probable compounds.
Is there any device that does this, even just remotely? If not, what obstacles are there for such a device to exist?
- mackatsol 4y agoAfter some searching, I found https://linksquare.io/ https://linksquare.io/ Look up handheld or portable spectrometer. There are a lot of them that are more lab / industrial focused (and priced!). Really what we want is a tricorder. :-)
- leobg 4y agoOh this looks great! Basically that’s the landing page I would have written for what I was searching. Now I just hope it also does what they say it does. Tricorder would be even better, of course! :-)
- giantg2 4y agoI think I saw some consumer focused ones a while ago. It seemed to me like they were not very accurate (required a high theshold) based on the reviews. They also seemed unbelievably cheap to me. Not sure if there are any really good ones that aren't lab focused.