3 ms·

I completely agree with you, and it is important to remember that all it takes is very few people to ruin it for everybody. With accountability comes consequenc

I completely agree with you, and it is important to remember that all it takes is very few people to ruin it for everybody. With accountability comes consequences and that fixes the incentive function. However I also think the system requires something kinda like forgiveness, or maybe better yet, redemption. If, once you have been kicked out there is nothing you can do to be let back in then nothing incentivises you to better your actions. Maybe you could be let back in again by paying a cleaning fee, and having to provide pictures after you used the toilet for the next 40 times. Accountability is super important, but if you don't also have redemption then you end up with the US criminal system.

teddyh 4y ago
This is actually a reasonable counter-argument, were it not for the fact that practically every such systems, no matter how lofty their goals or how fair their initial rules, all eventually evolve to be instead a tool for oppression.
- tomjen3 4y ago
  It is a tool of oppression right from the beginning, and its goal is to oppress certain behaviours so we can have a functional society.
  - teddyh 4y ago
    That is not the kind of oppression it will evolve into a tool for, though.
antifa 4y ago
What happens when you've been falsely accused? What happens when the person before you's 2/10 dirty is the person after you's 8/10 dirty? There's also a privacy problem with there being a poop log attached to our IDs.