3 ms·
>What are the options to "improve society" so people don't make a mess in shared bathrooms? 300% public shaming. Japan is an example of this working, to an unb
by Dalewyn 4y ago
>What are the options to "improve society" so people don't make a mess in shared bathrooms?
300% public shaming. Japan is an example of this working, to an unbelievably ideal extent even.
Public restrooms in Japan are *clean*, they are spotless and sanitary no matter what time of day you visit one. You can probably eat off of those toilet seats, for all I know.
The reason for this is because individuals who do not clean up after themselves in public spaces are shamed and ridiculed by Japanese society at large with no holds barred. It's "just not how upstanding members of society operate" to make a mess, be it in a public restroom or anywhere else, in Japan.
You might see Japanese people picking up trash and cleaning up after themselves when leaving a public venue like a stadium or theater, probably other peoples' refuse too while they are at it. Frankly bewildering acts from the perspective of most westerners, but it's literally that sort of social attitude to be upstanding individuals that leads to clean public restrooms.
- napier 4y agoThat's part of the why but not the root of it. Underneath the social sanction element you mention is the fact that Japanese society raises people to give a thought for the sake of others, otherwise known in the west as manners / the golden rule.
- ryandrake 4y ago> The reason for this is because individuals who do not clean up after themselves in public spaces are shamed and ridiculed by Japanese society at large with no holds barred. Not being from Japan, I’m curious: how does this work in practice? If I were to go into a bathroom in Japan and smear my own shit all over the walls and leave, 1. how does anyone know I did it, 2. if somehow someone actually knew I did it, how exactly would I be shamed and ridiculed, and 3. how would that negatively affect me if I didn’t care about shame or was incapable of feeling shame.
- Dalewyn 4y agoThat's the thing: It is deeply ingrained in the very foundations of Japanese culture and society to always conduct yourself in a manner that will at the very least not hinder others unnecessarily. Japanese are raised from the very beginning to be ashamed of making a mess and not cleaning up, to be ashamed of being irresponsible. Everyone is taught that "the Sun is watching you", that someone (or something!) somewhere is always watching you and judging you for your actions. A westerner might shit up a public restroom, intentionally or otherwise, and say to himself "I don't care; cleaning this up is the janitor's job." A Japanese person won't even dare, because they are taught to clean up regardless of a janitor. It is a common tradition and mandate in Japanese schools for students to clean their classrooms (and every-so-often even restrooms!) themselves at the end of the school day. Yes, the schools have janitors, the students are told to clean up themselves anyway because that's just how good people behave. This is all a facet of education and parenting, and the result of generations and millenia of such teachings. Their thought processes are fundamentally different from the west: A better society starts by being better individuals themselves first. Public restrooms in the west being an absolute shit show (pun intended) are a reflection of failed education and parenting in western society. The west can, and should, do better.
- SilasX 4y ago>A Japanese person won't even dare, because they are taught to clean up regardless of a janitor. Great, but this contradicts your other post that seemed to be claiming that bathroom shaming specifically was the solution the bathroom problem, which the parent was rightly incredulous of as how it actually works in Japan.
- Gareth321 4y agoJapanese social contracts are remarkably complex, and last a lifetime. A person caught smearing shit on the walls could be permanently ejected from their friend groups, families, and workplaces if discovered. Which they would be, if caught by the police. The secret sauce is of course the shared belief that smearing shit on the walls is worthy of ostracisation; and the will to enforce it. Not all communities and cultures around the world punish members for antisocial behaviour. There appears to be a concerted effort in America today to permit antisocial behaviour under the guise of various social movements. This appears to be rooted in an incorrect belief that people aren't responsible for their behaviour. Society is responsible when someone smears shit on the walls. Under such a belief system, social ostracisation doesn't work.
- Gareth321 4y ago> 300% public shaming. Japan is an example of this working, to an unbelievably ideal extent even. This also works for obesity, and I've seen it in action in many nations apart from just Japan. Social pressure works. We've known it works for millennia. I'm not sure why we suddenly started believing that social pressure to not litter and eat less was ineffective and even immoral.
- bart_spoon 4y agoThe thing is, I think you have the causality wrong. I lived in Japan and I can’t remember anyone being shamed for anything. I think individuals feel shame if they break societal norms because they value cohesion over individualism. They don’t value cohesion over individualism because they will be shamed if they step out of line. That’s a key difference, because there are many people these days who are, for various reasons, effectively beyond shame. Simply attempting to shame people for their actions won’t improve outcomes because the same people causing the issue likely don’t care enough to feel shame. Ultimately the difference is that American society is one in which individualism is prized over all. The greatest evils are those that would in any way infringe on something that could be considered a personal liberty. And it’s only gotten worse in the last 50 years. I can’t imagine modern American society rising to meet any major challenge of the last 100 years the way we have in the past.