4 ms·
My question is, “Why do this now?” Print has been an increasingly-niche distribution format for many years, and anyone targeting print already has Adobe CC and
by CharlesW 4y ago
My question is, “Why do this now?” Print has been an increasingly-niche distribution format for many years, and anyone targeting print already has Adobe CC and will never be switching to GIMP for print work.
I’m not trying to be negative for negative’s sake, because I’d truly love for something to be to images what Blender is to 3D. I just wonder if anyone’s thinking about the costs-vs-payoff here.
- dagmx 4y agoPrint isn’t that niche. People think print as just magazines or news but it’s majorly advertising.
- CharlesW 4y agoWhat kinds of print advertising in particular are you thinking of?
- dagmx 4y agoBillboards, flyers, bus side advertising, shopping cart backings, benches and bus stops etc… There’s a lot of advertising out there. Granted many will use RGB inputs but with cmyk working spaces
- ekianjo 4y agoEverything around you in the physical world
- gilrain 4y agoWhen you walk into a grocery store, all those colorful products you see? They aren’t digital… they require pigments, dyes, and paper. We’re not in VR just yet.
- kitsunesoba 4y agoIt's also still a thing for various types of printed products, like desk mats.
- dotancohen 4y agoI'm a software developer in a printing house. Print is far from dead. People are printing less paper, but today anybody can print a custom photo album, or T-shirt, or business cards, or custom pens, or mouse pad, or vehicle C-pillar sticker, or literally hundreds of other custom items. All that runs on CMYK.
- hiccuphippo 4y agoSo the original source for custom things is probably a jpeg image, does it matter to convert it to CMYK before before giving it to the shop vs converting it right before giving it to the printer?
- gilrain 4y ago> So the original source for custom things is probably a jpeg image This assumption is wrong.
- dotancohen 4y agoNo, it's not. The vast majority of consumer-oriented printing originates in a jpg or png image. The file format really isn't that important, the point GP was making is that these images are in RGB space. That's actually correct. Work that comes in from professional design shops come in as CMYK. But not from small businesses that are not in a tech field, such as grocery stores, restaurants, sports teams, children's or senior's activities, security firms, hardware stores, hair stylists, etc. All that comes in as RGB.
- dotancohen 4y agoYes, it matters because it will look different.
- dagmx 4y agoIf you don’t care about color, then it doesn’t matter. If you do care, as most professionals should, it matters greatly. RGB and CMYK have extremely different gamuts of reproduction, not even counting what your output medium is capable of rendering (whether that’s your display range or your ink+surface range)
- ben-schaaf 4y agoThis is open source land, so the cost is some free time and the payoff is that the software does what you need it to do now.
- thrdbndndn 4y agoI never use GIMP in depth but I imagine if they can't even read CMYK file before, it would be a big flaw. I don't work in printing or publishing but I have opened hundreds of CMYK files in Photoshop for further editing. Also lots of (most of?) PDFs use CMYK.
- larusso 4y agoThe sad part is that CMYK color space is really important (and that is just one little part) to be able for a tool to be used in the professional print world. There are printing houses mainly for consumers who really don’t care what you throw at them. But these companies have technical designers (I don’t know the correct term for a photoshop user who only works with colorspace correction etc) who prepare the media for print. In smaller print houses there is a stricter process. They define tight requirements what you can send to them. And PDF with all the bells in whistles in the correct colorspace etc is defacto standard. So for an FOSS tool it is sadly a lot work to implement all these things to support the print Workflows which are dominated by Adobe. The question is if this must come from a single tool. Photoshop is already a tool with too many faces.
- prokoudine 4y agoThe cost is covered by Google Summer of Code program.