3 ms·
In San Francisco JCDeaux already does that. Those units are self-cleaning, handicapped-accessible, and cost about $300K each. They're complicated, with motors,
by Animats 4y ago
In San Francisco JCDeaux already does that. Those units are self-cleaning, handicapped-accessible, and cost about $300K each. They're complicated, with motors, sensors, and valves. All the hardware and controls are Telemechanique industrial grade. SF has a big problem with those. Vandalism, people shooting up inside, people dumping trash in them, etc. There's no problem providing public bathrooms for rich people. It's providing public bathrooms for homeless people that's a problem.
Wheelchair accessibility triples the size and price of the units. Here's what JCDEaux installs in countries that don't require it.[1]
San Francisco has an attended 24 hour portable restroom operation in poor parts of the city, called "Pit Stop". Total operating costs are around $30 per flush.[2]
The most workable low-end solution currently seems to be the Portland Loo.[3] "The sleek and modern kiosk discourages crime with graffiti-proof wall panels and open grating that allows you to see if and how many people are inside." It's not self-cleaning like the expensive JCDeaux units, but it can be hosed down or if necessary pressure-washed.
[1] https://www.jcdecaux.lt/en/news/modern-public-toilet-klaipeda-city https://www.jcdecaux.lt/en/news/modern-public-toilet-klaiped...
[2] https://www.businessinsider.com/san-francisco-public-pit-stop-toilets-cost-per-flush-2019-12 https://www.businessinsider.com/san-francisco-public-pit-sto...
[3] https://portlandloo.com/ https://portlandloo.com/
- neurostimulant 4y ago> San Francisco has an attended 24 hour portable restroom operation in poor parts of the city, called "Pit Stop". Total operating costs are around $30 per flush. At this price, isn't it cheaper to operate traditional restroom with full time janitor instead?
- erenyeager 4y agoWhat a frightening solution that Portland loo is. Compromising on the most basic sense of privacy that a bathroom should provide. And putting the hand washing station on the outside? This just reeks of cultural bias and not considering the bathroom uses of others. Some people like to carry bidets they can fill to clean themselves, some people like to wet toilet papers they use for cleaning, some people feel safety and more secure being able to clean themselves and make ablution in an enclosed bathroom environment. Certainly hope the project fails.
- tedmiston 4y ago> San Francisco has an attended 24 hour portable restroom operation in poor parts of the city, called "Pit Stop". Total operating costs are around $30 per flush.[2] This is some questionable math. They took the costs of the units and staff and divided by the number of late night usages to arrive at ~$30 per usage. But if they were used twice as much that rate would be halved, etc. In any case the fixed costs are the same regardless of usage metrics. It's very misleading to take a highly fixed cost and label it like a usage-based cost.