5 ms·
Cynically, this can be the point. When building anything at all becomes prohibitively hard, most things don't get built, and the environment remains unchanged,
by nine_k 4y ago
Cynically, this can be the point.
When building anything at all becomes prohibitively hard, most things don't get built, and the environment remains unchanged, that is, presented.
Only things absence of which causes a real, strong, unceasing pain can withstand the process and finally get built, at much larger expense and at a smaller scale than planned initially.
- rayiner 4y agoIt is the point but there’s nothing cynical about it. In the 1960s-1970s when NEPA was passed, the environmental movement was focused on conservation. They didn’t think subways were a great thing. The alignment of environmentalists and urbanists is a later trend that’s arisen in response to climate change concerns.
- hammock 4y agoI wouldn't go so far as to say it had anything to do with global warming or climate change. Urban sprawl is terrible for the environment in so many other ways, and this fact has been known long before global warming became a big issue
- CSSer 4y agoMost people appear to have a very one-dimensional view of the environment overall. If this is true, it means that even if most agree urban sprawl is bad people still struggle to agree on how to fix it. Have you ever read William Cronon’s The Trouble with Wilderness? It was published in ‘96. The core idea still doesn’t seem widely accepted or even acknowledged. For a humorous anecdote to support this, I once matched with a girl on a dating app who did so only to lecture me about building cairns because I had a picture containing one (dodged that bullet). She had no idea I was within city limits and didn’t seem to care. I had violated the sanctity of nature because someone had told her that she should think so.
- QuadmasterXLII 4y agoFrom a hacker news pragmatism point of view, I wonder which wins a marginal ratio of amphibian lives saved to economic damage contest: shutting down or regulating polluting industries vs imprecisely lecturing cairn builders on tinder
- nine_k 4y agoUrban sprawl, among other considerations, was seen in 1950s as a way to save more lives in an event of a possible nuclear war. It is easy to destroy the entire Manhattan with a couple of nukes, but it won't have the same effect over Houston or Bay Area. Now this consideration is moot, but the planning decisions made back then took root. Powerful interests like car makers, NIMBYism, white flight, etc all played to that same hand.
- kmeisthax 4y agoOne thing to note is that environmentalism itself has undergone some very odd political shifts and realignments. 70s-era conservationists have more political ground in common with Donald Trump now than they do with their ostensible successors fighting climate change. The Sierra Club of that era wanted to shut down the US immigration system because exporting that way of life was considered an environmental catastrophe. Similar concerns over overpopulation were used to dogwhistle racism - after all, the problem isn't us, it's them. I suspect this is also why California is full of NIMBYs. While there are plenty of loud-and-proud right-wingers in that state, they're also far easier to circle the wagons around. If you are a racist in California it's more effective to do the normal liberal virtue-signalling thing, and then concern-troll the shit out of literally anything in your state that might actually make progress towards your stated goals. It's the "rich Mexicans only" strategy. Correctly point out the injustice of the American immigration system, but find every excuse you can to build a shadow immigration system out of housing costs and property tax grandfathering that's far more opaque and biased.
- panick21_ 4y agoThis something always ignored, environmentalists were very strongly against population increase. Books like 'the Population Bomb' I consider this essentially, anti-human philosophy. Many people for example wanted to prevent technology exchange with India, in order to make sure Indians starved now, rather then millions later. They also wanted domestic population control measures, harsher then even those in China. Forced sterilizations and so on.