5 ms·
Ah, that was pre-deregulation in the US. Now we know what happens with de-regulation. At first, there are lots of new entrants in the industry. Gradually, the n
by Animats 4y ago
Ah, that was pre-deregulation in the US. Now we know what happens with de-regulation. At first, there are lots of new entrants in the industry. Gradually, the new entrants go bust or consolidate. The industry reduces to an unregulated oligopoly with four or less major players.
Examples:
- Wireline telephony. (AT&T, Verizon)
- Cellular telephony. (AT&T, Verizon, T-Mobile)
- Cable TV (Comcast, Charter, AT&T).
- Banks. (Bank of America, Citigroup, Chase, and maybe Wells Fargo)
- Package delivery (FedEx and UPS, plus USPS).
- Airlines (United, American, Southwest, and Delta)
Price competition seems to disappear at 3 or less direct competitors, from an EU study.
- darksaints 4y agoHowever, the brewing and trucking industries have done the exact opposite. Maybe your model is broken. De-regulation is a misnomer, and using it as a pejorative shows ignorance as to how regulation really works. Quality will always matter way more than quantity.
- Animats 4y agoBrewing: * Anheuser-Busch InBev - 45% of US beer market * MillerCoors - 25% of US beer market Trucking: The big ones are FedEx and UPS, who of course dominate small package delivery. For big loads, the big players are XPO Logistics and J. B. Hunt. Everybody else is considerably smaller. Full-truckload shipping has distance cost and is simpler than package delivery, so the network effects are not as strong and there's room for local and regional players. [1] https://blog.bizvibe.com/blog/largest-trucking-companies https://blog.bizvibe.com/blog/largest-trucking-companies
- darksaints 4y agoThat isn't monopolization. There are over 8000 active microbreweries in the US, and they haven't been put out of business by Anheuser Busch. In fact, Anheuser Busch has been scared of their growth for decades now. In 1979, when the wave of beer de-regulation started, there were only 90 breweries in the entire US. There are almost 1M independent public-carrier trucking companies in the US. There are some 300,000 independent owner operators. Your model is broken. De-regulation doesn't inevitably cause monopolization, there is something else that does that. In fact, you already alluded to it: network effects. Along with high fixed costs (which overly aggressive regulation contributes to), they're one of the defining features of a natural monopoly.
- rnk 4y agoI feel like your brewery examples doesn't support your thesis. In brewing we have a couple of mega breweries. There are thousands of upstart local breweries. They have trouble distributing beer because most states have enforced useless middlemen that control this, the liquor distributors. The distributors control whether the local breweries can get on supermarket shelves or into bars. The breweries can't just do this on their own in most states. And guess who owns most of the liquor distributors. Yes, it is other mega breweries. In reality the booming beer industry would be far advanced if there wasn't the constant sequence of breweries selling out to big beer (because the monopolists limit the ability of the small breweries to grow and succeed). We need to break up the monopolists controlling the industry.
- darksaints 4y agoDe-regulation of brewing took us from 90 breweries to over 8000. So at the very least at the local level brewing can thrive. You're right that distribution inhibits smaller breweries from growing a national presence. But again, that is due to regulation. Alcohol distribution is heavily regulated, and there is tons of legacy regulatory capture, and larger distributors are constantly lobbying for more regulations to maintain their stranglehold on distribution. Brewing - deregulated. Distribution - heavily regulated. Maybe you don't need to break up the brewing giants, just dismantle the captured regulation stranglehold they have on distribution.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- classified 4y ago… and the internet overlords, like Google and Facebook.
- Animats 4y agoThose were never regulated. Industries where the network effect is so strong it leads to monopoly used to be rare. In the early days of antitrust, only railroads, street cars, gas, and electric companies had extremely strong network effects. Competition didn't work. So those industries were regulated into common carriers or regulated utilities. Today far more industries have strong network effects. But that's another topic.
- jcampbell1 4y agoThe EU is different than the US. The EU has country club culture of old families that stay off each other’s turf. That used to be the case in the US where airlines split routes, and the cable business is still a mess. Steve Jobs tried to pull that shit with programmer salaries. Frankly I have little issue with US monopolies as many you list only make a 10% margin. I’d rather pay T-Mobile $27 than the $30 I currently pay, but I am not all that upset about it. An Epipen is $600. That is due to the FDA only approving 1 device with $0.10 worth of epinephrine, when the EU has 6 choices all less than $100. Bad government policy can screw us. It would be really nice if the US government relaxed the regulations on a drug invented in 1910 combined with a spring. I’m not disagreeing with you but I just feel like I am as likely to get screwed by regulatory capture as natural monopolies. Wild west entrepreneurial capitalism is a decent antidote to crony capitalism which thrives with regulation. MBS, Putin, Biden, Trump, Xi all want power over industry, media, and education. I question how much I want a savior empowered by the law and a duty to save us from monopolies and tycoons. Elon Musk seems to be creating a monopoly on space access and he is high on the scale of douchbag, but he is unlikely to make my life worse. Even if he controls space. From a monopolistic standpoint, you have to laugh at Zuck getting a Fuck from Chinese TicTok. It may not be good, but he isn’t cronies with Mr. Zhang. It is also worth acknowledging that most of the audience here has benefited directly or indirectly from the obscene profit margins that the US tech scene has created. Complaining about monopolies is biting the hand that feeds. Ignore any negativity as the choir here gets the rich milk of profit margins which have historically only ever been created by monopolies. What makes me laugh is that the US military and US fracking means we Americans get the good life and high programmer salaries because US tech is immune while Europeans hang their laundry outside.
- omreaderhn 4y agoThese are some of the most regulated industries in the US.
- worik 4y agoRegulated oligopolies. Hardly market forces! If you believe in the utility of markets then breaking up the oligopolies formed by market failure (unless price gouging monopolistic practises are not viewed as "market failure"...) is very important. Regulating them is ineffective because the oligopolies get so rich they heavily influence, if not actually write, the regulations. By bribing the regulators.
- rufus_foreman 4y ago>> Banks. (Bank of America, Citigroup, Chase, and maybe Wells Fargo) This one is a pretty bad example. If I want to avoid Spectrum, I don't get cable. If I want to avoid FedEx and UPS, I don't get to order things online. If I wan't to avoid Bank of America, Citigroup, Chase, and Wells Fargo (which I do, particularly that last one), I bank at a credit union. But yeah, it's fun to imagine what it would be like to live in a world where any company with more than 4% market share gets broken up as a monopoly.
- userabchn 4y agoA corporate tax rate that increases with revenue would naturally disincentivize such monopolies/oligopolies (by making it easier for small companies to compete against them) without requiring the government micromanagement of deciding what is and what isn't a monopoly.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tasuki 4y agoI don't think that'd work well: Companies would just split into smaller ones, led by the same people.
- diordiderot 4y agoIf I own 50 meat Packers totaling 50% of the market, I get taxed like one totaling 50%. Cartels are already illegal.
- brutusborn 4y agoCould you split them while retaining the aspects of the business that made them a monopoly to begin with?
- As_You_Wish 4y agoCorrect. Which is why breaking apart companies that form monopolies is so important. Break up Facebook. Break up Amazon. Break up the Warner Bros Discovery merger that just happened (why was that allowed in the first place?). Monopolies are the one major failing of capitalism. Busting up monopolies is an important function of government. Unfortunately, all our congress is now bribed (they call it lobbying and PACs) and work for the monopolies or oligopolies. So that's how Warner Bros Discovery has happened to create this huge news and media organization. In any merger, I like to see who the new CEOs are and get a sense of them. David Zaslav is the new CEO. If you haven't seen David Zaslav, the new CEO, speak, here is a little video of him good little speech: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0i0v5GVZ30o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0i0v5GVZ30o Because our US congress is being bribed, a main solution to monopolies is term limits. About 90-95% of representatives are re-elected to Congress year after year. And about 80-85% of the Senate. For example, Diane Feinstein has been a California Senator for 30 years, and I am almost convinced that they have put an android in her and there's just a thin coating of her skin over it. Why is this happening...why don't we have term limits? Maybe 6 years for both, then the politician is OUT.
- worik 4y agoYes. But why do you concentrate on "term limits"? Surely it is campaign finance reform that is needed in the USA? Term limits might be useful, it would strengthen parties and party discipline. Is that a good thing? I use to think so, but what has happened to the GoP is disturbing (from a distance - I am no expert on your USA politics)
- roenxi 4y agoMono- generally means "one". When the lists being discussed all have a minimum of 2 companies we aren't talking about monopolies. Those companies aren't monopolies either, they all compete with a large number of successful groups. Ticktok has been banned in some markets because they are too successful at competing with the existing social networks- it isn't from the US.
- As_You_Wish 4y agoGoogle owns like, 90% of the market. If you are going to argue that there are other players, like Bing and ... whoever else there is, then I'm not buying that. Amazon should be broken up, even though there are tons of other people with online stores. Amazon is a monopoly at what they do. And even when there are 2,3,4 competitors, one has to have governmental regulators to make sure there's no collusion, which effectively makes a monopoly. As far as tiktok goes, it is banned mainly because it is a Chinese company and they are collecting data on US citizens. And China is a dick, so that's why banned. While this is somewhat off topic, as far as China goes, I'd put super harsh limits on everything that they do here. I'd make them follow the exact same rules that they make others follow in their country. China is ALL about forced partnerships, for example. with forced partnerships, so that they can steal IP. One of the conditions of working in China is FORCED transfer of technology. Foreign banking, telecom, payment systems are not allowed. China has banned Facebook and Google. China requires all foreign fund management companies to set up an internal unit for supervision by the Chinese Communist Party. So this applies to companies like Blackrock Fidelity, etc. So Tiktok isn't a particularly good example for me.
- ianai 4y agoYou really want 100s of competitors. If they’re running advertisements they’re exploiting market power.
- Animats 4y agoI need to find the reference, but an European Union antitrust study indicated that price competition usually disappears around when the number of real competitors drops below 4. Below 4, you tend get implicit collusion, where nobody wants to cut prices much to gain market share.
- ianai 4y agoAn efficient market doesn’t have price competition because MR=MC. Price above the margin and nothing sells. Price below and you’re losing money-and no one has money to lose for market power. I realize I’m talking about markets people would have a difficult time looking for examples. This illustrates how wide spread concentration is. I’m not concerned with the N=M inflection points.
- jl6 4y agoThose all seem like fiercely price-competitive markets, with the exception of wired comms where there isn’t competition in regions which have been divided up between one provider or the other. Also, they are all highly regulated industries, so it’s hard to disentangle whether any observed issues are due to market failure or regulatory failure.