3 ms·
"The DNS blocking is basically the same power as domain seizing, which the feds already have today." A similar point was made during the SOPA congressional hea
by feralchimp 15y ago
"The DNS blocking is basically the same power as domain seizing, which the feds already have today."
A similar point was made during the SOPA congressional hearing (sorry I forget by whom).
The problem with that argument is that it mischaracterizes recent government behavior with powers that the government actually has a well-established legal right to assert.
As I understand it, they "have the power" to seize domains in the same way that they "have the power" to attach surveillance devices to your car without a warrant. i.e. "Because they're doing it and we haven't successfully sued them or otherwise forced them to stop."
- snowwrestler 15y agoWhether or not one thinks the feds should have the power to seize domains, my point is just that SOPA does not expand that power w/respect to U.S.-based sites.
- RobertKohr 15y agoYou are right, it doesn't expand power, but it legitimizes it. When questioned years later by some potential opposition, they can can state that they were on the right side of the law.
- snowwrestler 15y agoFair point, I hadn't looked at it that way.