I have no idea what "surrender leftism" is supposed to mean, in relation to Noam or otherwise. However, if we'd paid a little more attention to Noam's points a

I have no idea what "surrender leftism" is supposed to mean, in relation to Noam or otherwise. However, if we'd paid a little more attention to Noam's points about war (clandestine and overt, economic and military) and the media a few decades ago, we the people would be tens of trillions of dollars better off. Millions of brown skinned folk would still be alive, tens of millions wouldn't have had to become refugees, and South America would be immeasurably better off. If you have some kind of beef with Chomsky I suggest you take it up with him; I hear he's quite good at responding to people.