3 ms·
If the answer doesn't basically translate to "luck" then I'm very suspicious of it. Similar to evolutionary psychology, it's very easy to come up with just so
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
If the answer doesn't basically translate to "luck" then I'm very suspicious of it.
Similar to evolutionary psychology, it's very easy to come up with just so stories to flatter your biases.
Similarly, anything that suggests it's the "one neat trick" is dubious because we know things are so incredibly complex.
It might be interesting to do the opposite and come up with plausible sounding alternate histories that exclude one particular factor as an exploration of how important different factors are. Arguing against the actual history is very hard though, people really heavily weight what actually happened even if it was pure chance and could have gone either way.
Like modern Europe without the Protestant reformation.
Or the British empire without a navy.
Or industrial revolution without coal.
Genghis Khan without horses.
- iraqmtpizza 4y agosounds like a luck bias. it's easy to say ah, there are so many variables, and they're extremely difficult to isolate. must be luck. that way we don't have to do the gruelling historical analysis
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoNo, you can do the analysis but if you end up with two competing theories like: * we accidentally started our civilization on top of oil which would come in handy 2000 years later Vs * My ancestors were super smart and did this one thing that I am really overinvested in today Then there's a kind of Occam's razor that leans towards the luck based explanation.
- keybored 4y agoNot really. There can be still be causes of things which are known and analyzable... But “luck” says that agents didn’t cause them (intentionally).
- cs702 4y agoThat's the main answer proposed by one of the five books on the list: "Guns, Germs, and Steel," by Jared Diamond. It's one of the best books I've ever read. It reaches its conclusions by considering verifiable facts and methodically reasoning about them. Highly recommended if you haven't read it.
- UncleMeat 4y agoIf you want a macro history that is more widely respected by historians today, Braudel’s “The Mediterranean” is far better.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lukas099 4y agoEverything is luck when it comes down to it.
- cortesoft 4y agoIf you go back far enough, any explanation is going to come down to ‘luck’ in the form of chance circumstances. However, that doesn’t mean we shouldn’t still examine what form the ‘luck’ came in.