3 ms·
If true, this is borderline criminal incompetence. However, I can't reproduce the issue described in the article.
by hedora 4y ago
If true, this is borderline criminal incompetence.
However, I can't reproduce the issue described in the article.
- silisili 4y agoSame. The author says when you enter an email, an SMS is sent and number revealed. What really happens is that it asks me for a password. Below that there's an option to get a one time code. Clicking that reveals the first digit of the area code, then the last 4 digits. You must then click yet again to make it actually send. So in short, it didn't immediately send an SMS and never showed the full number.
- yew 4y agoBut the author says a partial number is revealed? Edit: I just tried logging in. It's exactly as the author describes - I enter my email and get a "Log in with a one-time code" page with my partial phone number. The code is sent automatically. Must be A/B testing. (No password prompt is shown unless I click "Try another way" below the code field.)
- Thorrez 4y agoThe author never says the full number is revealed. The author says the partial number is revealed.
- silisili 4y agoThe article has been changed. The word partially was added in the sentence below after I commented. > enter an email address to log into PayPal, an SMS is immediately sent and the phone number is partially revealed. That said, below that it mentioned number guessing so I probably could have guessed that's what they'd meant to write.
- levymetal 4y agoOP here - yeah that's my bad - I never intended it to be interpreted as fully revealed but a sentence taken out of context can read that way, so I tweaked the article (as well as fixing a few spelling mistakes). Apologies for the confusion.
- Thorrez 4y agoOther parts still said partially though. Your comment was left at 4:40 UTC[1]. Here's a snapshot from 4:07 UTC[2]. It says >PayPal helps them by partially revealing a significant portion of your phone number >Remember Mat Honan, who’s digital life was destroyed when his iCloud account was wiped in a targeted attack? In that attack, the hacker used social engineering to obtain a partial credit card number from an Amazon employee which Apple then accepted as verification of identity. With PayPal no such social engineering is required; instead revealing half your phone number to anyone who merely enters your email address on the login screen. >Of course, PayPal also allows users to log in by entering their phone number. Now armed with a partial, a bad actor needs only to enumerate the remaining digits to reveal your full phone number. [1] https://hacker-news.firebaseio.com/v0/item/32615770.json https://hacker-news.firebaseio.com/v0/item/32615770.json [2] https://web.archive.org/web/20220827040709/https://christianvarga.com/whats-going-on-with-security-at-paypal/ https://web.archive.org/web/20220827040709/https://christian...
- 8ytecoder 4y agoI was able to reproduce it in incognito. I’m guessing it works only on devices I have signed on before? Someone they have a way to fingerprint me? Irrespective of it, this whole dumbing down security for UX is unacceptable. It’s not even good UX for someone like me with a password manager.