4 ms·
I totally agree that the cases themselves aren't so bad conceptually (as you say, most of them are basically just prepositions turned into post-positions/ending
by cqfd 4y ago
I totally agree that the cases themselves aren't so bad conceptually (as you say, most of them are basically just prepositions turned into post-positions/endings); I don't think it's any worse than German or Russian. But I have to say that the mechanics of calculating consonant gradations etc. is decently painful—I think you might be overselling the lack of difficulty haha.
I enjoy studying languages and have learned enough Finnish to get midway through the Harry Potter series, and even just getting to the point where I could smoothly look up words, let alone remember them, took a fair amount of practice. (The form you see on the page often needs to be un-consonant-gradated before you can find it in the dictionary, and the rules are somewhat complicated, though very regular.)
One funny aspect of Finnish pronunciation is that the ubiquitous long sounds give it a bit of a herky-jerky rhythm. It's always sounded to me as if the speaker is trying to figure out the grammar too :)
- grishka 4y agoRussian cases are worse because they also apply to people's names. Finnish ones, as far as I know, don't.
- tuukkah 4y agoWhat do you mean? Of course you need to use cases with names too. Pekka's house => Pekan talo (in Finnish)
- int_19h 4y agoI don't know German, but in Russian, the case endings also change depending on the grammatical gender of the word, whether it's singular or plural, and then on top of that there are three different categories with different declensions. It's not entirely orthogonal, since e.g. categorization is itself guided by gender, but still, that's a lot of different variations that have to be memorized for each case.