5 ms·
Effective CO2 reduction can only happen if a sensible and effective policy is taken, to wit: 1. a tax on the carbon content of fuels 2. nuclear plants for bas
by WalterBright 4y ago
Effective CO2 reduction can only happen if a sensible and effective policy is taken, to wit:
1. a tax on the carbon content of fuels
2. nuclear plants for base load power
and the rest will be taken care of by natural market forces.
Green energy will never be practical without nuclear power:
https://www.wsj.com/articles/why-the-energy-transition-will-fail-11661547051 https://www.wsj.com/articles/why-the-energy-transition-will-...
- rglover 4y agoThank you. This is a dirt simple and obvious track that would create a wealth of jobs and potential for everyone. It's the ultimate pro-humanity solution to our concerns around energy/pollution.
- fundatus 4y agoIt's literally natural market forces that are "killing" nuclear energy. It's simply too expensive compared to modern, emission-free alternatives.
- fi358 4y agoHave you solved the problem of intermittent power production by solar and wind energy and included the costs of it to the calculation? It seems to me that the solar and wind energy are causing problem in the energy market with their unreliable production and not paying the cost of solving this problem.
- choko 4y agoMarket forces heavily influenced by politics, so not "literally".
- pfdietz 4y agoPolitical considerations push nuclear more than the market by itself would. There has not been a single merchant nuclear power plant (that sells into a competitive power market) built anywhere in the world.
- qqqwerty 4y agoThat is an opinion piece from a conservative talking head. Maybe try linking to primary sources next time.
- epistasis 4y agoThe climate efforts of the past 20 years refute both of these claims decisively. First, carbon taxes, when they have been enacted they have not been effective. And there are massive barriers to enacting them, because there is no constituency that advocates for them. The progress we have made with reducing emissions has been through industrial policy of various sorts, rather than through single taxes. For every problem, there is a solution which is simple, obvious, and wrong. And I think that the history of carbon taxes has shown them to be this obvious and unfortunately wrong solution. Similarly, baseload, or more properly firm energy supply, can come from all sorts of carbon free sources. From storage (hydro or battery), to geothermal, to advanced geothermal, to hydrogen, to ammonia storage, to who knows what will be developed over the next few decades. We have a rich portfolio of solutions, and most of them are reducing in cost quickly. However nuclear is not reducing in cost, and it's not clear that it will ever be able to compete again. Attach 12 hours of storage to a solar array and you'll get a "baseload" source, and it will be cheaper than new nuclear.
- fi358 4y agoAt least in countries like here in Finland, you get almost no energy from solar panels during winter months. 12 hours of storage to a solar array is not going to work at least here.
- pfdietz 4y agoFinland is one of the worst places in the world for renewables. This means that any industry using significant amounts of energy is going to move away from Finland, once fossil fuels are no longer used.
- fi358 4y agoMost of the electricity in Finland is not produced by using fossil fuels. For example during year 2020 14 % of the electricity in Finland was produced by fossil fuels.
- 4y ago
- Schroedingersat 4y agoJust do the first one. No need to force the issue. If nuclear is amazing as claimed it will be adopted. If the claims are the same empty ones we've heard for 70 years then we'll get some electrolyzers and gas turbines running green ammonia
- WalterBright 4y agoBuilding nuclear plants requires that the government remove legal and regulatory hurdles that stifle them, like endless lawsuits.
- Schroedingersat 4y agoHow about we do that after we do the same for trains, and LEVs and bikeways and local insulation regulation and the local bans on solar and wind facilities and the property taxes that are 1000x for a solar plant compared to a coal plant and the taxes on rooftop solar and the free security for nuclear and the government funded price guarantees for nuclear and the free insurance for nuclear in the form of an upper limit for liability.