4 ms·
Railroads. Specifically freight rail. There is stunningly little literature on any R&D in conventional freight rail transport, something I discovered when loo
by dredmorbius 4y ago
Railroads. Specifically freight rail.
There is stunningly little literature on any R&D in conventional freight rail transport, something I discovered when looking for any published research some months back.
High-speed rail, yes. Regular old freight, no.
Contrast this with autonomous and electrified trucking as alternatives, with which rail could offer considerable synergies.
I'd suspect that break-bulk, trainset assembly and disassembly, and routing might all offer opportunities.
But ... nada.
I suspect other modalities within the transport sector might be similar, notably ocean shipping.
- bombcar 4y agoI know that BNSF did wonders with modernizing how they dispatch trains (the old way is build a train until it's as long as it can be and then send it off, which meant you never could really predict when something would arrive) and they also are doing monitoring, etc: https://www.bnsf.com/news-media/railtalk/safety/artificial-intelligence.html https://www.bnsf.com/news-media/railtalk/safety/artificial-i... How much of it is fluff I don't know.
- dogman144 4y agoCheck out Shift5
- dredmorbius 4y agoCare to unpack that / explain what element(s) are addressed?
- dogman144 4y agoShift5 is a company doing the R&D and documentation on tech concepts around railroads, specifically fleet monitoring and security.
- tylerlh 4y agoI think this has much to do with certain parties controlling most of the dataflow for NA rail freight moves. Definitely a problem on the ocean and in the port terminals as well. We should chat!
- Bakary 4y agoI wonder if that is the case outside of the English-language world.
- dredmorbius 4y agoIf anywhere, I'd suspect China. That literature would be pretty opaque to me.
- h2odragon 4y agoI think there's a number of little regional rail companies popping up now that the bigs have gotten to big to care about those customers; I bet they're reinventing where they have to and would possibly even be willing to fund some knowledge collection and sharing efforts.
- landonxjames 4y agoI saw a talk by an engineer from Parallel Systems [0] and they seem to be doing some very cool stuff for the future of rail. Autonomous Electric rail cars and some other interesting things [0] https://moveparallel.com/ https://moveparallel.com/
- ripper1138 4y agoVery strange product. The benefit of traditional rail freight is scale and cost over long distance. The benefit of truck freight is last mile delivery (no need for warehouse storage, can make multiple stops, etc). Their product seems worse than either except that it’s electric. Fortunately, electric trucks are well within reach. Cool that they are building the tech though, maybe it will get bought out by an actual logistics/freight company that can find a use for it.
- sofixa 4y agoIsn't that because rail freight is pretty much a solved problem with little left to research? Each one of those you mentioned have been discussed, optimised and reorganised hundreds if not thousands of times across hundreds of countries during the last more than a century of rail history. The answers are there, just not everyone bothers to look and apply them. Autonomous electric trains exist. Scheduling optimisations to the second are well developed. However there's R&D into cheap electrifying with battery railcars - which is IMHO a dumb idea outside of niche railroads, electrification pays for itself in the medium to long term, a battery bandaid doesn't get you far. Ans there's also a kind of innovation from India - dedicated rail freight corridors.
- dredmorbius 4y agoThere's a argument to be made for this. As of about 30 years ago, I had the opportunity to observe a freight yard at which the tech was 1920s -- 1930s vintage (electromechanical relays controlling switches). I suspect there are many such instances still in operation. To an extent, what works, works, but there are also limitations and sheer maintenance. But at a bigger-picture view, as I read what's being discussed for trucking, I keep thinking that far greater energy efficiencies are attainable by a switch to rail, though a huge problem remains in the flexibility and time elements. There have been expedited / express long-distance rail initiatives, though those have been on the range of ~14 days for coast-to-coast transit in the US. There is a very small number of Class 1 railroads in the US: Amtrak, BNSF, Canadian National, Canadian Pacific, CSX, Kansas City Southern, Norfolk Southern, and Union Pacific. One of those is passenger-only, and two are Canadian-owned. That leaves five US-owned freight carriers. As with the broadband industry, these tend to operate independent territories and routes.
- zip1234 4y agoTrucking is also highly subsidized via highway money, with gas/usage taxes covering less than half of roads..= Take that away or make trucks pay for wear and tear and maybe we would see more investment in rail. Long haul trucking almost shouldn't exist given how much cheaper and more efficient rail is.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- WheelsAtLarge 4y agoSelf driving train seems like a no brainer. I suspect that even with the tech 10 years ago it could have been solved. Where are they and why isn't someone working on it? I suspect when something is this obvious, yet we don't see a product, it has to do with someone in the industry fighting change and making sure it does not happen.
- Balgair 4y agoUnions?
- rewq4321 4y agoYep, unions are fighting against even allow moving to 1 crew member per train, let alone zero. https://smart-union.org/our-priorities/legislative-issues/ https://smart-union.org/our-priorities/legislative-issues/ https://public-inspection.federalregister.gov/2022-15540.pdf https://public-inspection.federalregister.gov/2022-15540.pdf
- dogcomplex 4y agoProbably little savings in just outsourcing that one (small team of) humans to AIs, and you lose your custodian for negotiating out-of-the-box situations. Seems easy enough though.
- dredmorbius 4y agoRail already has a tremendous labour advantage over trucking. The principle limitations seem to be net transit speed (freight moves on average at or below 30 mph net, and peaks at 79 mph in the US) and the sheer delay and confusion in arranging shipments. Freight's worked well for high-volume bulk commodities (coal, grain, tanker cars). Intermodal ("piggyback" or containerised cargo) works quite well, but still sees delays compared to trucking, and generally is not viable for distances under 500 mi / 1000 km (within the US). Sub-car shipping (equivalent of less-than-truckload or LTL for trucking) is a nightmare for shippers. Rail doesn't seem to be integrated into much consumer logistics. Yes, the net flows are slower, but it's far less energy intensive than truck-based shipping (or air cargo), and should be far more economic. The logistics and scheduling though seem to be a real concern. Trackage consolidation's been an issue, there's been a net decline of trackage for most of the 20th century AFAIU. That especially includes suburban and urban centre transport. Railyards are still large-area operations which are expensive in terms of locked-in real estate within urban regions. There are major crossing points and exchanges (including both ports and mid-line switching operations) which have been major choke-points. The basic technology works. It's tremendously efficient. It actually is a largely un-sung success story in the US. And yet it seems it could be so much better.
- ccooffee 4y agoAn old college friend went to work for CSX (I think), and we caught up after he'd worked there for a few years. He said that most of his job consisted of digging into old COBOL code to explain why a train was routed a certain way (e.g. Reno -> Phoenix -> LA -> SF instead of Reno -> SF), and that he rarely ever changed the code. They just made summary documents saying "there was rail congestion on the normal route". I've always hoped that he was just yanking my chain and that they did...well, anything really.
- tmaly 4y agoThis seems like something Prolog could be good for.
- mikedelago 4y agoI had an opportunity to work at a company that developed one of the more prominent software suites for railways in America. Unfortunately, the pay was too low and the company was having people come into the office in June of 2020.