8 ms·
Two research teams grew synthetic mouse embryos using stem cells
- jonas-w 4y agoI read "House embryos" and was like, okay how far have we come?
- csours 4y agoTreehouse of Horror embryo
- daenz 4y agoEthics aside, it would probably be good to conquer the population size problem. Then people can stop fighting about birth rates and immigration.
- reb 4y agoI dunno, I can't imagine industrializing our domestic supply of infants would do anything but accelerate that particular arms race.
- irrational 4y agoWhat population size problem? Birth rates have plummeted in all developed countries. As more countries become developed the same thing will happen. The population size problem is already solved - birth control, freedom for women, middle class lifestyles, etc.
- daenz 4y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32589499 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32589499
- nabakin 4y agoPopulation size isn't much of a concern right now so idk what OP is talking about, but I doubt population size is solved. Natural selection, in absence of premature death, selects for those that give birth the most. So while at the moment, we are in a sort of lull, eventually the people who have a low birth rate, will be selected out of the population. The only way this doesn't happen is with another force acting in the opposite direction. For example, maybe whatever is causing the birth rate decline now, actually counters the incentives of natural selection over hundreds or thousands of years, or the population exceeds the carrying capacity of the Earth such that premature death becomes common once again.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nashashmi 4y agoThere is no such thing as overpopulation problem. In urban planning we are always considering ways we can engineer cities to hold 100 million people to a billion people. In fact, that would be a great alternative to suburbanism and increase forestry with the extra land. So this whole random idea of overpopulation is alarmism over nothing. Granted, high population also means small 'mansions' and maybe THAT is their greatest worry.
- daenz 4y ago>So this whole random idea of overpopulation is alarmism over nothing. Underpopulation is what I was referring to. Some countries have extremely low birth rates, and stabilizing them is important.
- Andrew_nenakhov 4y agoThe population size problem is not because people can't have enough children, it's because they don't want to have (enough) children. I don't see how cloning helps with that.
- daenz 4y agoRegardless of the source of the problem, the end result is the same: not enough people. Cloning treats that symptom even if it doesn't address the source. But yes, you're left with a new problem: who will raise these new people? If it came down to it, the state. Or the state would assign children to couples.
- Andrew_nenakhov 4y agoCouples are unlikely to accept. So the only option would be for the state to raise them... I think I saw some sci fi movie where the galactic republic solved a problem with hostile robots this way..
- daenz 4y agoI was thinking more along the lines of Vivarium (very mild spoilers, sorry!), but yes.
- klyrs 4y agoIf the clones are wards of the state, then an industrialized/automated approach to child-rearing becomes plausible. Yes, this is dystopian. But if we're going to do it, we should use the Montessori model, with each cohort helping raise the next.
- ben_w 4y ago> Then people can stop fighting about birth rates and immigration. If human cloning ever becomes accepted, I suspect racism will end up promoting an even smaller gene pool than it already does, with anyone who isn't a clone of Dear Leader And His Chosen Ones forming the out-group. Such a system would still hate immigration.
- Victerius 4y ago"They are totally obedient, taking any order without question." Seriously, we need to loosen the regulations on cloning, including animal and, yes, human cloning. We are holding back innovation.
- rhacker 4y agowhy should we allow human cloning? at some point won't we just get evil clones coming out of russia to fight the next big war? We could even alter them just enough to call them sub-human, store them in cages and teach them to shoot machine guns.
- arthurcolle 4y agoApe together strong
- wszfahwbwbaha 4y ago[flagged]
- junon 4y agoThat's not how discourse works here. Take that to reddit please.
- wszfahwbwbaha 4y agoWhy should someone be allowed to say truly deranged ramblings? But calling them out for it is not okay? Truly a vile culture and you should be ashamed for creating a safe space for people to spout eugenics.
- junon 4y agoEugenics was not the topic of their comment. You immediately assumed malintent. HN is a place of Curious conversation. Your comment did not reflect that. I suggest you read the HN guidelines linked at the bottom of this page.
- roschdal 4y ago
- marshray 4y ago"Hanna hopes to use the technique to develop human synthetic embryos that can be a source of new organs and tissues for people who need them."
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nikhizzle 4y agoIs this a basis for explaining immaculate conception?
- csours 4y agoOr self-cloning? Here's a thought to give you the shivering frights: What if a someone created a self-cloning version of themselves? Humanity could be replaced by a single clone. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marbled_crayfish https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marbled_crayfish https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parthenogenesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parthenogenesis
- numtel 4y agoNo, that's parthenogenesis. We can already do that with mice.
- nsxwolf 4y agoImmaculate Conception is a doctrine pertaining to the conception of Mary, not Jesus. /pedant
- marshray 4y agoMary was conceived immaculately too?
- numtel 4y agoWake me up when I can grow a mouse from my own body and see from its eyes. http://latenightsketches.com/detach-2.html http://latenightsketches.com/detach-2.html
- EForEndeavour 4y agoThat short story contains the highest density of mind-blowingness per unit text I've seen in a long time.
- numtel 4y agoThank you so much!
- psychphysic 4y agoHow has Netflix not greenlit this already? It could revive black mirror.
- upwardbound 4y agoSuch a cool story :) If you'd like this breadcrumb as something that could help make the world of the story feel like it could be our world, here's an interesting thing which is that Alan Turing thought that telepathy could be possible, and tried to account for this when designing the Turing Test. https://stackoverflow.com/questions/19728844/extrasensory-perception-turing-computing-machinery-and-intelligence https://stackoverflow.com/questions/19728844/extrasensory-pe... If telepathy were to be possible as described in your story, you could explain it as mind-body dualism being real https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mind%E2%80%93body_dualism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mind%E2%80%93body_dualism and that the new animal born from the person temporarily shares a neural link with the person's brain, causing the sharing of one spirit, and that when the neural link is broken as the animal separates, the spirit is still anchored to both parts of the formerly-unified nervous system. The explanation for why this wouldn't happen during standard childbirth is that mother and child don't share a neural link, only a blood link. Here's another breadcrumb for this idea https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2017/01/170125093823.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2017/01/170125093823.h...
- sometimeshuman 4y agoAs I understand it, this procedure would result in a near perfect clone baring a few random mutations in the stem cell which they could probably screen for. To digress. I want a clone, more than anything. It's only thing I'd pay more than $100k+ for aside from housing. I submit that society would benefit if every other generation was a clone. If I were raised by my parent-clone I would have matured faster and been more skilled at playing baby-roulette with a natural child. Whenever I meet a 20-30 year old that has the temperament and calmness of a 40-50 year old I suspect one of two things: 1) their young-ish parents won at baby-roulette and their child had a personality similar to theirs and were able to guide them through adolescence in a more optimal way. 2) their parents were older and maturer and could navigate the personality conflicts in a way that didn't lead to long-term family dysfunction. but even #2 is rare since not all older parents can handle all personality types, hence my suggestion for a third option: family lines based on alternate generation cloning.
- daenz 4y ago>If I were raised by my parent-clone I would have matured faster and been more skilled at playing baby-roulette with a natural child. This is leaning heavily on the assumption that your personality is primarily a product of your genetics, and not of your life experiences. Outside of relating on physiology, what makes you think you would understand their reactions to unique life experiences at such a young age? Speaking as someone who had a dramatic personality shift from early trauma, I don't think that what you hypothesize is true.
- sometimeshuman 4y ago"This is leaning heavily on the assumption that your personality is primarily a product of your genetics" Not really. If you allow that it is even 1% due to genetics, that better parenting compounds over generations. And there is a lot of evidence that it is much more than 1%. I too experienced numerous traumatic events by the time I was 12 and was then prone towards neuroticism for decades after. I still submit I'd be a much better parent to a clone than someone who has half my dna.
- pepperonipizza 4y agoI can't understand why countries like China aren't investing more in researching ectogenesis. It seems a good solution for the future of their population, the fertility rate will probably never go back to 2.
- raarts 4y agoI think we are about to find out why evolution dropped cloning as a viable mechanism for reproduction.
- biotinker 4y agoNumerous organisms regularly reproduce via cloning, including most of the oldest and largest organisms, e.g. Pando. Bacteria, many plants, and some simpler animals primarily reproduce via cloning. Parthenogenesis is also a strategy employed as needed by fish, reptiles, and some birds. I'm not suggesting that cloning is superior, but to call it "not a viable mechanism" is a mischaracterization.
- thaumasiotes 4y agoThe premise is false; cloning is all around you. However, bacteria have other ways of exchanging genetic material with each other, and more complex clonal organisms go extinct fairly quickly in geological time frames. But more will arise.
- lisper 4y agoHow is this different from cloning?