4 ms·
That's a fair point, and I'm wrong to imply that, at least in the case of the "Loot Train Battle", that the problem is with GRRM, since IIRC, the books have not
by danso 4y ago
That's a fair point, and I'm wrong to imply that, at least in the case of the "Loot Train Battle", that the problem is with GRRM, since IIRC, the books have not yet reached that plot point (and I haven't read the books).
But I do think it's fair to still critique the TV show, fantasy trappings and all, for shallow and inconsistent world-building and logic. The Loot Train Battle is an event that is symptomatic of the showrunners rush to wrap up the sprawling threads that they so carefully rolled out in the earlier seasons — by season 7, teleporting across the continent was just an accepted thing, and that correlated IMHO with a rise in incoherent and unsatisfying subplots.
What I liked about the early seasons of GoT was that even for a fantasy world, there was a real sense physical space. Many of the 1st and 2nd season's developments arise because distance is a factor — e.g. the time it takes to go from Kings Landing to Winterfell, from Winterfell to the wall, etc. The Red Wedding results because the only sensible crossing from north to south is controlled by a long-declining minor House.
Not sure how the showrunners could've worked around GRRM creating an improbable situation where Kings Landing is supplied by The Reach/Highgarden (again, haven't read the book, so maybe this is not the case?). But the showrunners seemed dead set either way to depict a big dragon-vs-army battle, logistics be damned.
- the_af 4y agoThanks for your reply. I think a critique or analysis of the internal consistency of AGoT is valid and fun! The blog is fascinating in its depth. I just don't think it's necessary to call the books or show "shallow" when they deviate from real-world history or plausibility; like the late Terry Pratchett would argue, it's all about "the story". And the story is engrossing, in my opinion. You'll get no argument from me about the TV show getting inexplicably rushed and inconsistent in the later seasons. I think most viewers were disappointed by that :(