4 ms·
Overall the medieval era was something of a setback in the aggregate if you look at social development overall in the western core. (See Figure 3. https://aspen
by ghaff 4y ago
Overall the medieval era was something of a setback in the aggregate if you look at social development overall in the western core. (See Figure 3. https://aspeniaonline.it/why-the-west-rules-for-now/ https://aspeniaonline.it/why-the-west-rules-for-now/)
However, you're absolutely correct that any explanation of why the Roman Empire didn't have an industrial revolution (without moving the goalposts around the technological advancements the Romans did make) has to account for why there wasn't an industrial revolution in the Eastern Roman Empire or China. And the reasonable explanation is that the technology tree wasn't developed enough.
- WastingMyTime89 4y ago> Overall the medieval era was something of a setback in the aggregate if you look at social development overall in the western core I'm not especially fond of the world system theory and I'm extremely wary of the concept of core countries but even if we accept for a minute that it makes sense, there is a very simple explanation to that in the theory: western countries which now form the core weren't part of it at the time.
- bombcar 4y agoThe amount of technology that was developed in the Medieval times is quite long: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medieval_technology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medieval_technology Romans had a similar list of accomplishments; but we're all too tempted to group them together and assume they were simple and easy. Once you actually start to dig into it you begin to realize how everything is connected together and that while perhaps you could jump start it with a time machine at just the right place; you might not be able to speed it up as much as you'd think. A "build the tools to build the tools to build the machines to build the tools to build the machines to build the tools" problem, if you will.
- ghaff 4y agoI basically agree. Arguably there are some innovations in health and science that the right knowledge in the hands of the right ruler/influential person could have advanced by centuries. But, in general, I'm not at all sure that technology overall could have been accelerated all that much even if a time traveler showed the right ruler a stack of modern how things work-style books.
- bombcar 4y agoYeah specific ideas would be powerful and actionable (germ theory, for example; though people had somewhat of a rough working idea of some of it with the concepts of "bad water") though many of those were somewhat in play even in ancient times (often as religious practices). There have been some books that explored the idea - I recall a series "The Cross-time Engineer" which isn't actually that great, but does have some obvious engineering knowledge. One thing I do think it gets right is that if you're sending someone back in time to change the past, you do NOT send a scientist, you send an engineer or a mechanic with the Handbook of Chemistry.
- ghaff 4y ago>you send an engineer or a mechanic with the Handbook of Chemistry. Yeah, you want someone who, armed with some basic knowledge can build things. CRC Chemistry Handbook, B&M mechanical engineering handbook, Henley's formulas, How Things Work, information on finding and refining basic materials, how to invent everything...
- tjs8rj 4y agoThis answer is circular though: “they didn’t have the technology because they just didn’t have the technology yet”. Time alone isn’t even really an answer. It only takes time because of the pace of innovation, and the pace of innovation depends on things like culture, tech, geography, population, communication, money, etc
- WastingMyTime89 4y agoDoes it though? Seems to me that the pace of innovation is mostly dictated by previous innovation. Political systems and organisations shift and change. What passes for the core moves. Meanwhile things march on. I don’t really see how it’s circular. They didn’t have the technology because developing technology takes time. Innovation used to happen on a time scale which made political structures not very relevant.
- evv555 4y agoThe technological progress of the modern era is a product of the Renaissance movement beginning in the 14th/15th century. A transformations that cuts through culture, society, and technology. Social changes like the emergence of scientific organizations and Rationalism are impossible to meaningfully disentangle from modern technological artifacts.
- ghaff 4y agoYou're right that the pace will vary--starting with geographical determinism--but there's still some sense of a technology tree that has to be traversed to some degree whether more quickly or more slowly.