2 ms·
I challenge you to do wny intellectual task without knowing the basics by heart. For example, try writing a large program in APL today - you can easily Google t
by tsimionescu 4y ago
I challenge you to do wny intellectual task without knowing the basics by heart. For example, try writing a large program in APL today - you can easily Google the symbol for any function you want.
Memorization, while not sufficient, is an absolutely necessary part of learning. No amount of googling can help you become skillful at something.
Note that searching for new information or old information that you may have forgotten the specifics of is also perfectly normal, and an important skill in itself. But even there, Google will usually be more of a tool for recall (what was the order of those two parameters? What was the name of that substance that they use for liver issues?) then completely new fact finding.
For example, if I ask you what is the complexity of finding an element in a red-black tree, it would be OK to quickly Google the speicifc answer. But if you have to Google what complexity means, or what a red black tree even is, or if you're not sure whether the complexity is better or worse than searching a linked list, then it's clear you don't have working knowledge of red black trees.
- nulbyte 4y ago> I challenge you to do wny intellectual task without knowing the basics by heart. So, in other words, you propose a test. Presumably it's open-book, since you are testing an ability to apply knowledge and not an ability to merely remember it. This sounds less like a rebuttal and more like a validation.
- necovek 4y agoThe GP comment is specifically referring to "reciting basic factoids", but they are the "basics" that you need to know by heart to manipulate them. While testing for "reciting" them is certainly suboptimal, it's cheaper to prepare a test of the sort than a test where you are effectively putting that knowledge to use. A balanced test would do a bit of both (so it does not take ages to prepare and grade, yet ensures you know the basics and can apply them in some problems).