6 ms·
The Next Mainstream Programming Language: A Game Developer’s Perspective (2005) [pdf]
- mcagri 4y agothat font...
- Tomte 4y agoYeah, isn't it great? Oh, and see what SPJ has to say about quirky fonts: https://graphicdesign.stackexchange.com/questions/38226/what-is-wrong-with-comic-sans https://graphicdesign.stackexchange.com/questions/38226/what...
- barrysteve 4y agoIt isn't 'just fashion'. I agree with SPJ that what we are all here for, is the content of the education, not how it's presented. The problem is that a good font makes it easier for people to relate to the content. Having a comedy font for a dead-serious funeral company technically communicates the required information, yet it's going to limit your audience to those that can tolerate the conflicting tones and the people who will choose to relate to what you're trying to say. It's really so difficult to press CTRL-A and select a different font? Would it cost him so much to relate a little closer to the tried and true methods?
- Tomte 4y agoThere is no readability argument here with just short phrases and bullet points, so your stance is purely middlebrow gatekeeping. SPJ and Tim Sweeney don't care about people who are only willing to listen when the other one does it "the right way". They put something out and if you don't like it, you can leave it unread. I like good fonts, I have bought several "serious fonts" for private use that cost serious money. I would never use Comic Sans in larger texts. I wouldn't probably use it myself anywhere. But this here is whimsical, and cool, and fun.
- barrysteve 4y agoI agree no readability argument. The relatability and tone argument is what I wrote. SPJ and TS don't have to relate to me, or anyone if they so wish. Just making the point SPJ's argument is quite poor, whatever "brow-level" it exists at.
- willyt 4y agoI agree, it's like clothes, sometimes it is appropriate to dress up if you want people to view what you are saying through a certain lens, wether that is wearing gold cufflinks to your job as a banker or wearing a hoodie to your job at Facebook it all signals something. Computer games are a visual medium, where aesthetics is very important, I'm not sure I would want to signal that I don't care about aesthetics to my audience, presumably quite a few of whom will be designer/programmer/artists type people (whatever you call front end in game dev).
- Tomte 4y agoTim Sweeney is a game development legend. He could put handwriting on these slides and people would read it. Did HN's reverence for John Carmack drop because he dabbled in rockets, instead of doing "proper programming"? Stars can afford to be eccentric. I wouldn't recommend slides like these to a normal game developer giving a speech. But it's preposterous to claim that it might hurt Tim Sweeney in any way.
- opyate 4y agoNothing is more "proper" to me than working on an AGI :) https://uk.news.yahoo.com/john-carmacks-agi-startup-raises-224032597.html https://uk.news.yahoo.com/john-carmacks-agi-startup-raises-2...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- richardjam73 4y agoSo a functional modula 3 perhaps?
- PainfullyNormal 4y agoEpic hired Simon-Peyton Jones to work on it (Verse), so I'm guessing more like Haskell. https://discourse.haskell.org/t/an-epic-future-for-spj/3573 https://discourse.haskell.org/t/an-epic-future-for-spj/3573
- agluszak 4y agoI'm looking forward to Rust's adoption in popular game development engines. There's https://bevyengine.org/ https://bevyengine.org/ in the meanwhile
- speed_spread 4y agoI love Rust, but it's "righteous" nature might go against the grain in many game shops where quick and dirty is not only accepted practice but where anything more rigid than C is deemed necessarily inferior. Something like Zig might have a better chance in that space.
- generichuman 4y agoZig also tries to block quick-and-dirty stuff, unused variables are errors for example. There are formatting related things too. This is obviously not as "righteous" as Rust as you put it, but when you look at the source of some shipped games, you'll see that some programming best practices are ignored. None of this will block Zig from being used in games, of course, but I wish they had a "let me work in peace until I get this working and then we can worry about that small stuff" mode in the compiler.
- zaphar 4y agoI think the reasons languages like Zig choose not to make this configurable is because other than the odd exception occasionally very few shops bother to turn on the stricter mode or are actively hostile to the stricter mode. And when you rely on other libraries that sort of less strict mode tends to start leaking out everywhere since that one critical library you really don't want to rewrite won't compile when you use strict and you don't want to carry a bunch of patches for it either. The net result is if you don't start out enforcing cleanliness your community of users will unintentionally devolve into unclean over time.
- adamdusty 4y agoWhy not just enforce it in release configuration?
- debacle 4y agoI wonder what the author would think of C# now. Seems he's very much a fan of C++ over C#/Java, which may have changed in the intervening 15+ years. Personally, I think continuing to use C++ for game dev (it is still the lingua franca) is more about momentum than it being the best choice (in most instances). His predictions on what computing power will look like "in the future" (e.g. now) are interesting as well. Some have played out, others haven't.
- smallstepforman 4y agoThe author is Tim Sweeney, creator of the Unreal Engine.
- pelagicAustral 4y agoJonathan Blow has been working for ages on a new programming language that seemed pretty cool last time I checked. Joi, i think it was called. Overall just looked like a more comfy C++ designed specifically for game development. Correction: the language is called Jai https://inductive.no/jai/ https://inductive.no/jai/ Joi is Ana de Armas AI version.
- doodpants 4y agoJust to be pedantic: the command is jai.exe, and the source file extension is .jai, so everyone calls the language Jai. Except Jonathan Blow, who only ever refers to it as "the language" in his videos. I vaguely recall him saying in an interview that he doesn't want to commit to a name just yet.
- pelagicAustral 4y agoAh! thats pretty cool. I wasn't aware of that.
- generichuman 4y agoThe community library wiki will probably be more useful to people who don't want to watch a bunch of videos: https://github.com/Jai-Community/Jai-Community-Library/wiki https://github.com/Jai-Community/Jai-Community-Library/wiki
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Tozen 4y agoJai has not been released to the public. If people are looking for a language that has been very heavily influenced by it and is in a near category, then that would arguably be Odin (https://youtu.be/M763xHjsPk4 https://youtu.be/M763xHjsPk4). Odin is open to the public, where nobody knows for sure when Jai will. If looking for a more general purpose feature rich newer language then people might want to also check out Vlang (https://github.com/vlang/v/blob/master/doc/docs.md https://github.com/vlang/v/blob/master/doc/docs.md).
- danschuller 4y agoI'd be interested to see some non-text super-IDE integrated programming languages. Maybe even hosted in the webbroswer. I think that's interesting territory that can unlock a lot of value. Simple instant variable renaming, far better commenting and interactive debugging that can all be stripped from a compiled final version etc.
- runevault 4y agoHave you looked at visual scripting which is popular in games? It may or may not be what you want but it is non-textual way of creating logic. UE has Blueprints, Unity has Bolt (as well as 3rd party ones available on their asset store, but Bolt is the one Unity purchased). Godot had one though it is being taken out of the core engine in 4.0
- silvestrov 4y ago> All dereference and array accesses must be statically verifyable, rather than causing sequenced exceptions This is such a pipe dream. In so many cases you will not be able to verify array index statically except by having the programmer write assert statements which the compiler could do automatically when it can't prove correctness (like the java JIT which can lift out bounds checking from loops).
- rnk 4y agoThat slide deck is pretty interesting just to see the 10k foot vision of a game. I'm working at that level in infrastructure software and the vision of what comes together for the game development and design is fun to see.
- bluedino 4y agoResources: - ~10 programmers – ~20 artists – ~24 month development cycle – ~$10M budget $166,666 per person a year? Does that include office space, computers, tools, software? Seems very low.
- wizofaus 4y agoFor 2005 though?
- gervwyk 4y agoWhat would a reasonable rate be in today's terms?
- meheleventyone 4y agoLike all budgets it’s wildly optimistic. I’m pretty sure precisely zero games Epic have made fit.
- justinlloyd 4y agoIn 2022, in a HCOL, $150K base for an exceptionally senior/lead developer with 10 to 15+ years of experience, writing hard-core C++ and multiple shipped AAA titles, in the games industry, working on console or PC or mobile, with a BSc, that isn't connected to blockchain/web3/nfts/crypto, is actually on the high side. If the developer is pure Unity (even if they are writing C++/HLSL every day), you can cut another $20K off of the price. Senior developers sit around $100K to $120K. Mid-levels below that. I am specifically talking HCOL US wages. I got a "generous" offer last year where the company struggled to get to $160K base for the Los Angeles area. There's a reason that Roblox, Amazon, Microsoft, Google can slurp up pretty much any software developer in the games industry. Artists and designers will rarely break $100k. There will also be project management (director & producer), and QA. Though depending on how the studio is set up, QA might be a shared resource and only get line items towards the end of development. Tool & software budgets in the games industry are miniscule. Training and continuing education are non-existent. Bonuses hardly exist. You might get a $40 "special sale" office chair that at least four other people have had before you. Unless you buy your own or get really lucky, that keyboard and mouse you're given has been there since the company was founded and are now considered religious artifacts. A fully loaded team of 10 developers is going to be one lead, two or three senior SMEs, 50% mid-levels (if you're lucky), and the rest are juniors or developers who are (non-visual) scripters building visual (UI, effects, game play) in Lua or some other scripting language. We can argue the numbers back and forth in endless pedantry, but my salary numbers are going to be pretty close to reality, with $5k to $10k here and there based on current industry trends. I keep my finger on the pulse of the industry pretty closely. In 22+ years, high-end salary of $100K in 2001 has slowly crept up to $130K-ish in 2022. Over my 40 year career I've spent a good two decades doing AAA development, have been senior/lead/tech director and CTO, and run my own studio, built multiple teams and managed large projects and have hired a lot of game developers over the years.
- wly_cdgr 4y agoCool. So, C++ it is, then, for our next real game
- SleepyMyroslav 4y agoIts funny how nothing of that actually got implemented. Instead we have visual scripting to allow people that cannot program at all to contribute. There are no near future improvements that fit game development people. All people who could have been creating and using new languages are not even going to go to job interviews. Because ads, fin-tech and web are paying a lot more.
- naikrovek 4y agoBlueprints in Unreal are a very good prototyping tool for non-developers.
- SleepyMyroslav 4y agoBut how did they improved life of those of us who are programmers and work on games? The article was about programmers being able to express their intent in code better. Life went completely different way. And most of comments even in 2022 here are still following that old dead end path and arguing benefits of different programming languages that maybe will change game industry.
- naikrovek 4y agohave you had a back-and-forth with someone who sat with you so you could type while they designed a system, because they can’t code and you’re not a game designer? Blueprint eliminates the developer time needed for that design work, and lets the designer design at their own pace. when they are happy, you (the developer) can turn that into code quite quickly, without the days required pairing with the gameplay designer to get the behavior where they want it. More generally, there are benefits to every programming language ever made, if you count learning what not to do.
- SleepyMyroslav 4y agoIn my experience with such tools the part 'you can turn that' means that you do not let them go far away from the cage and quickly destroy whatever they did. Which is not what I see happening. I see that now you have 2 layered system forever. You need to fully understand both layers to make changes. You need to keep everything like it was designed so design person will be able to continue their work. You now need to design code blocks to the puzzle to make it look like its a software. Currently I am coping with what I see and the only feeling I have and I know its wrong, is that whatever prototype team gets from this visual stage has to be stripped for ideas and redesigned from clean slate before going into next steps. But I have been in business long time and I know I will not see any clean slates anytime soon. We are going to ship whatever 'works'.
- dang 4y agoRelated: The Next Mainstream Programming Language: A Game Developer’s Perspective (2005) [pdf] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30139794 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30139794 - Jan 2022 (1 comment) The Next Mainstream Programming Language: A Game Developer's Perspective - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2802897 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2802897 - July 2011 (1 comment) The Next Mainstream Programming Language: A Game Developer's Perspective (2006) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2044261 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2044261 - Dec 2010 (18 comments) The Next Mainstream Programming Language: a game developer's perspective - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1296608 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1296608 - April 2010 (22 comments) The Next Mainstream Programming Language: A Game Developer’s Perspective - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1029820 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1029820 - Jan 2010 (14 comments)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- makapuf 4y agoWow unreal engine in 100kloc of c++ ! Should be a dozen millions now.