4 ms·
I think one major piece is consistently missed in those articles. Yes, the chances of him hitting 2900 do not depend only on his performance against other playe
by epolanski 4y ago
I think one major piece is consistently missed in those articles. Yes, the chances of him hitting 2900 do not depend only on his performance against other players, but from their elo as well. If the following 25 players in the world where all 2800+ Carlsen would already be 2900+.
Thus, Carlsen's best chances largely depend on elo inflation to widen the elo distribution itself.
One example of this: Louis de Bourdonnais which was #1 in the world in the 1800s skyrocketed his elo rating from 2600 to 2650 mostly as a result of the following 10 players moving their average elo from 2350 to 2450.
His winrate against them never changed. And what is required for 2350 players to go higher? That the players below they skill also raise their elos giving the top 10 more points when beating them. The more players will be fide rated the more Carslen's chances will increase but without a sufficient supply of 2700s, those at 2750 won't raise in elo, etc, etc
- trashtester 4y agoI would also argue that there is a source of ELO deflation going on. As the top level players all get better, theory evolves, people generally play better chess. A player with a rating of 2750 today might have beat Kasparov in his prime, simply because chess has evolved. In a way, it's similar to sports. Plenty of people today might have beat Carl Lewis at 100m 30 years ago, but they would probably not be considered greater athletes. So in order to beat 2900, it would help if several other players got rankings of 2800-2850, but only if they did so without actually playing much better chess. Or he could just have a temporary lucky/confident streak, and gain 40 rating points in a few tournaments.
- soperj 4y ago> In a way, it's similar to sports. Plenty of people today might have beat Carl Lewis at 100m 30 years ago, but they would probably not be considered greater athletes. Same with Lance Armstrong...
- trashtester 4y agoI did remember Lance's drug use, but had forgotten about Carl's :)
- selectodude 4y agoCarl Lewis’ positive tests would now be marked as negative due to being under the threshold.
- epolanski 4y agoElo doesn't measure absolute but relative strength. It is not relevant whether the top players get better, what matters is their winrates against each other. The fact that chess has evolved is irrelevant because it applies to all players from carlsen to beginners everyone has the same tools.
- dmurray 4y agoThe Elo system didn't exist until 100 years after Labourdonnais. There are several attempts to extend it backwards, but they're not well defined. It doesn't make sense to say Labourdonnais went "from 2600 to 2650" without changing his playing strength: it's an artifact of some particular guy's methodology to estimate historical ratings.
- robrenaud 4y agoElo takes match results and spits out ratings. Why does it matter that it was invented after the matches took place, as long as the game records are accurate? The timing of the games is irrelevant.
- jononomo 4y ago"If the following 25 players in the world where all 2800+ Carlsen would already be 2900+." Why are you assuming that Carlsen would always win against other players if the other players are that much stronger? Maybe if the following 25 players were all 2800+ then Carlsen would take more losses.
- epolanski 4y agoBecause, as already explained elo measures relative strength not absolute one. If he's a better player he's going to beat them more often than not while not losing all the points he does now for drawing.
- jononomo 4y agoYeah, but he wouldn't be a better player than them if they were better players.