3 ms·
> So what is the point in artificially creating a test situation where the student is isolated from resources she'll have at her disposal in real life? I can e
by lotsofpulp 4y ago
> So what is the point in artificially creating a test situation where the student is isolated from resources she'll have at her disposal in real life?
I can envision many scenarios where a person needs to be quick on their feet and does not have time to look things up. Drivers, pilots, doctors, etc. Certification provides a lot of value to society.
The other point of testing is to separate wheat from chaff. To see if someone is disciplined enough to learn the material or see a task through. There are issues of going beyond the ideal amount of testing here, but not totally useless in my opinion.
- wolframhempel 4y agoTrue - and there's certainly a line to be drawn between core knowledge and wider knowledge. A programmer, looking up what an if-statement is each time won't do well, regardless of the resources at their disposal. But I'd argue that realistic test conditions correct for this automatically. If your test is "write a program that does X within two hours" the programmer lacking core knowledge will fail. If your test is "recite 20 programming paradigms from memory" you will have to check for "cheating"
- antipurist 4y agoThose scenarios can be better tested through simulations. E.g. to pass a driving exam you are presented with a road situation, and given only a few seconds to respond — this completely eliminates the possibility of looking things up on the internet. A similar approach can be used for other disciplines. > separate wheat from chaff Wheat can demonstrate/use the knowledge, chaff can't. Why does it matter whether the knowledge is internal or external, assuming results are the same?
- lotsofpulp 4y agoBecause you do not know if the results are the same before making the decision to go with person A or person B. There are time costs in figuring out if someone can do something or is capable of learning how to do something, so test(s) of various kinds are used as a proxy.