7 ms·
Why Is a British Baroness Drafting California Censorship Laws?
- rcpt 4y agoWhoa had no idea about this one. What the hell is that law really as bad as they say? Real irritating
- tmaly 4y agoThe article talks mostly about who sponsored the bill. I would like to hear more about what the ramifications of the bill are.
- rcpt 4y agohttps://www.techdirt.com/2022/08/24/dear-california-law-makers-how-the-hell-can-i-comply-with-your-new-age-appropriate-design-code/ https://www.techdirt.com/2022/08/24/dear-california-law-make... Yeah I was the same way but they link to their analysis.
- wilde 4y agoYeah, the OP article is trash but the analysis has valid concerns. It seems to boil down to: There’s lots of very vague language in the bill that we’re going to need to wait for the agency to actually define in regulation. The article authors would rather the law more clearly define things to keep the agency from overreaching.
- EdwardDiego 4y agoThat still didn't help me understand his concerns. It's just a rant. However he links to something a little more coherent. https://www.techdirt.com/2022/06/29/california-legislators-seek-to-burn-down-the-internet-for-the-children/ https://www.techdirt.com/2022/06/29/california-legislators-s...
- incompatible 4y agoSomething about websites needing to do <something> for their visitors who are aged under 18? Will it be resolved by adding another annoying warning that visitors must be aged 18+ to use the site?
- TeeMassive 4y agoI hear more and more companies avoiding Californians workers, although mostly due to their insane out of state tax policies. I can't help but assume this will precipitate the tech exodus from California.
- dmix 4y agoApparently this would affect almost any website operator in California, since you could argue kids go on almost any website. > This turns the bill into a trojan horse for comprehensive regulation of Internet services and would turn the privacy-centric California Privacy Protection Agency/CPPA) into the general purpose Internet regulator. This would be very bad for tech business in California
- jgaa 4y agoI guess the simplest (technical) solution is to just use IP geolocation data to redirect all HTTP requests from California to a "safe" page stating that the requested content is not the brain food you are looking for. You know, just give everyone in California the toddler treatment. That way we are sure that no Californian children (no matter their age) get in harms way.
- phendrenad2 4y agoAs a California resident I agree with this. Maybe even ask for the person's age first, just to really annoy them when you ultimately kick them off of the site. My fellow California residents need to elect better leaders and a little annoyance goes a log way.
- googlryas 4y agoDoes she live, or spend time, or conduct business in California? Then she should get some input in what laws are proposed. She's not a dictator, it is just a bill being put up for discussion.
- OJFord 4y agoSounds like it, 'with deep connections to Hollywood' is among the quotes OP admits as though it makes it worse somehow. Used to direct films, so presumably at least lived (if not lives) there. The 'British Baroness' phrasing seems like they just thought it was better clickbait than 'a company' - surely the actual issue the article has, by the end, is just this process that allows companies to draft Californian law; not that in this case the company happened recently to hire a British baroness...
- qwerty456127 4y agoTo me it seems like 'British Baroness' attracts attention because it sounds like a person completely foreign to both California and to ordinary people, probably having little idea of the real life there and given authority solely because of her family ancestry.
- OJFord 4y agoExactly, that's what I mean by being better clickbait. But it's just not the case at all, and the author doesn't even really take issue with that, that's just who happens to be behind the company.
- gumby 4y ago> 'with deep connections to Hollywood' is among the quotes OP admits as though it makes it worse somehow. Well frankly it does. As the article says, "with close ties to Hollywood (any time there’s an internet destructive law happening, if you scratch hard enough, you’ll find Hollywood somehow connected)." And if you read techdirt with any regularity you'll find Hollywood is indeed almost always involved in some anti-internet efforts.
- petesergeant 4y agoThe sooner Americans understand what a life peerage is, the more we'll stop having these ridiculous headlines when Britons of note are involved in stuff. I remember some commenter writing off Twitter's governance team on the basis that it had "some British baroness on it", where the lady in question was Martha Lane Fox
- classified 4y ago"We are even more intolerant than our enemies, but our intolerance is politically correct and religiously sanctified."
- tempodox 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Life_peer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Life_peer
- nirimda 4y agoThe purpose of a life peerage is status. If it confers negative status, then it's no problem to rename the House of Lords as the Senate and call them Senators, a la Canada, instead of Baronesses. This is the case regardless of whether the opportunity is taken to restrict the prime minister's rights to choose his (soon, presumably, her) own public advisors on legislation.
- notahacker 4y agoBut it doesn't confer "negative status". The solution to Americans jumping to the wrong conclusions about British institutions is for Americans to stop jumping to the wrong conclusions about British institutions, not for Brits to rename them along American lines. (And I say that as someone who would quite happily see the House of Lords replaced for reasons which have nothing to do with American understanding of it) Anyway, it seems like the clickbait here is "British" and the article would have taken exactly the same angle if her title was Senator.
- likeclockwork 4y ago
- isaacfrond 4y agoBeeban Kidron is a high profile movie director. Why not lead with that instead of her title? https://www.imdb.com/name/nm0452319/ https://www.imdb.com/name/nm0452319/
- dmix 4y agoYeah this seems to be the most relevant explanation: > It was founded by a Baroness with close ties to Hollywood (any time there’s an internet destructive law happening, if you scratch hard enough, you’ll find Hollywood somehow connected).
- PeterStuer 4y agoMaybe because in this context that is less relevant? In her own words: "No one would listen and I was determined – and that was it, I ruined my career. I stopped making films and I started campaigning for children to be given a fair deal online. Cut to 10 years later, this is what I do.”
- mcv 4y agoHow is her peerage title more relevant? Her movie career is the most notable thing about her other than this law.
- Mindwipe 4y agoBecause she used her peerage to push similar laws in the UK as an unelected member of the Lords - the Online Safety Bill and Age Appropriate Design Code were both significantly pushed through and amended by her as an unelected peer, and she used her position on the Bill Committee for the Online Safety Bill to prevent witnesses who might have criticised the problems caused by age verification from appearing. Her peerage is directly relevant to this legislation.
- m-p-3 4y agoThose laws are still put in place by elected members of Parliament, she just helps writing them down. The matter that is becomes law is not up to her exclusively, this isn't a dictatorship.
- m000 4y agoI wonder why we don't see similar articles for bills sponsored by organizations with ties to American billionaires.
- justin66 4y agoWell, those stories exist, they just don’t necessarily mention the billionaires by name: https://www.wkyc.com/amp/article/news/local/ohio/hidden-role-religious-lobbying-group-ohio-education-backpack-bill/95-9a525206-c16b-4d63-af66-d08b3af79c6a https://www.wkyc.com/amp/article/news/local/ohio/hidden-role...
- walterbell 4y agohttps://www.techdirt.com/2022/06/29/california-legislators-seek-to-burn-down-the-internet-for-the-children/ https://www.techdirt.com/2022/06/29/california-legislators-s... > the bill pretextually claims to protect children, but it will change the Internet for EVERYONE. In order to determine who is a child, websites and apps will have to authenticate the age of ALL consumers before they can use the service. NO ONE WANTS THIS. It will erect barriers to roaming around the Internet. Bye bye casual browsing. To do the authentication, businesses will be forced to collect personal information they don’t want to collect and consumers don’t want to give, and that data collection creates extra privacy and security risks for everyone. Furthermore, age authentication usually also requires identity authentication, and that will end anonymous/unattributed online activity.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoThe article, itself, seems to be fairly hyperbolic, and, quite frankly, hard to take seriously. We’ll have to see what things look like, after it becomes law (which seems to be happening). It’s entirely possible that it’s toothless. A lot of these types of things are. Politicians like to have them, so they can point to their “accomplishments,” at campaign time, but they don’t actually move the needle.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pdpi 4y agoBeeban Kidron was a film director and is a children's rights advocate. She was awarded an OBE (for services to drama) in 2012, the same year Toni Morrison and Bob Dylan were awarded Presidential Medals of Freedom for their own contributions to the arts. The brits being who they are, receiving such an honour comes with a life peerage attached. That title is exactly equivalent to "Why is a Presidential Medal of Freedom recipient drafting California Censorship Laws?", which sounds a lot less sinister.
- Mindwipe 4y agoNot especially, since a life peerage gets you unelected upper chamber rights to draft the UK's laws - Kidron heads a pressure group on censorship, and was given the ability to vote on the legislation they suggested, and was allowed to sit on the Parliamentary group criticising the Online Safety Bill legislation which didn't even invite any critics of her plans. That is sinister.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- unknownaccount 4y agoIf this passes, would it be legal if I simply stop serving my sites to California-based IP addresses entirely?
- Ekaros 4y agoSo is there any chance of this law even passing? Drafting and who is doing it is one thing, but entirely meaningless if it won't pass as a law.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- b800h 4y agoOh, you appear to have inherited our Internet Safety Bill, which has been kicked into the long grass on this side of the pond. The UK safety tech sector appears to be quite good at lobbying. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/safer-technology-safer-users-the-uk-as-a-world-leader-in-safety-tech/uk-safety-tech-sector-2022-analysis https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/safer-technology-...