4 ms·
Not that there is anything the least bit good to say about nursing homes run by distant, uncaring, profit-obsessed managers...but also consider the brutal econo
by bell-cot 4y ago
Not that there is anything the least bit good to say about nursing homes run by distant, uncaring, profit-obsessed managers...but also consider the brutal economic reality of 24x7 care, at even the best possible nursing home. (Excluding facilities for the actual wealthy, where cost isn't much a concern.)
To have ONE bottom-rung direct care staffer available, 24x7x365, and paid ~$12/hour... After employer-contributed payroll taxes, unemployment insurance, and workman's comp. insurance, figure the home's actual cost is $15/hour. $15 x 24 x 365 is $131,400.00 per year. More-skilled staff (you do want a nurse or few around, right?) are proportionally more. Plus, even the leanest-run facility will need a few folks cooking the residents' meals, doing their laundry, doing physical therapy, handling paperwork in the office, etc. The most humble of donated buildings (so we're imagining no mortgage payments) still requires ongoing maintenance, utilities, & such.
Add all this up, and you can easily hit $250,000/year per bottom-most-rung direct care staff person.
Now, assume that you (or the society you're doing thought experiments on) can't actually afford $250,000/year for each and every person who needs nursing home care. What fraction of that "one per one" care are you willing to settle for? Notice that even at "one per ten" staffing, your cost of running the facility is still $25,000 per resident per year. Multiply that by as many millions, or tens of millions, as need such care. (Yes, one per ten is well below the legal minimums in many states.)
Does your society have the actual resources to do that? If "yes" - are you really comfortable with how capable, caring, and responsible the bottom-rung caregivers willing to accept ~$12/hour to clean up incontinent and disoriented elderly folks at 3am actually are? And you're aware that our "suitable building was donated" fudge is a really big fudge?
Oops, also - that nursing home bill only covers the nursing home care. If your residents need to have some medications, doctor office visits, occasional hospital stays when (say) they fall & break something - that's all additional costs & resources.
- kickout 4y agoIt's a complex situation no doubt. There is massive shenanigans in the billing aspect of this (thus the attraction of profit hungry assholes). Society has cared for it's elderly basically forever, and _now_ we're saying it's too expensive? As the article mentioned, the incentive for the religious group running these places was theological and human centric. Those religious groups are/have collapsed so there is this giant vacuum attracting all the wrong people. I honestly can't believe there isn't enough money in the 'system' to provide decent care for the vast majority of elderly. The numbers cited today (likely correct) aren't sustainable b/c it's basically free money to harvest (at the cost of human comfort). Regulate the industry and prosecute the bad actors. If member's of congress had family in these facilities, it would like be solved. They likely don't for the same reasons they don't have the same healthcare benefits as most Americans. Disconnected from reality. (I say this as someone well aware of the costs of nursing homes, and specialized care.)
- drekipus 4y ago> Society has cared for it's elderly basically forever, and _now_ we're saying it's too expensive? Because individuals used to look after their own elderly. Now there's a lot more institutions involved, meaning a lot more other people work, meaning a lot more other people need wages paid. It's a bad, crappy job that no one wants to work in, and no one wants to pay high fees for looking after mum and dad
- kickout 4y agoCorrect. I don't disagree. However, in my experience increased money and scale (i.e tens of millions of people need this assistance) don't seem to be helping the problem. In my head I think its similar to the problems of public education in America. We pay extremely high $/kid on public education due in some areas, it doesn't improve outcomes. It's like the whole model is un-scaleable or something.
- John23832 4y agoEh, not true. Communities looked after their elderly. We've just removed any aspect of community from society. Individualism to a fault is causing these problems.
- danny_codes 4y agoTotally agree. I've been thinking about this a lot lately, and it seems there are many causes. Increased ability to move, and desirability of moving (school, jobs, exploration). Bad city design (at least in North America, we have a car problem) meaning it's difficult to have a local community. The decline in religious involvement and no replacement lined up. A culture of extreme individualism to the point of absurdity. These all seem tractable, but it is sad that we've let it get to this point. I feel there is a shifting in the wind though. At least for younger people, American capitalism and individualism seems to be viewed with increasing skepticism.
- drekipus 4y agoYes, totally agree with that.
- giraffe_lady 4y agoSeems like the reduction of everything into market-based economies has some limits! Maybe we should break from the frankly radical notion that all problems can be solved and all relations understood in this way.
- drekipus 4y agoMaking everything state/public funded doesn't change how much it costs unless you have slaves working for free.
- hotpotamus 4y agoMy parents have noticed the costs are quite high and the lack of interest among their children in taking care of them. Whenever they mention it, I just assure them that robots will be tasked with taking care of them in a decade or two, so whoever is working on that, please get to it. Science fiction gave us the obvious economic answer with "Logan's Run" and "Soylent Green" many years back.
- soco 4y agoSoylent Green doesn't even use robots to take care of the elderly, just a feelgood video clip and a bit of medication.
- soco 4y agoMaybe I misread your calculation but to me it seems you assigned to every "patient" (excuse the word) dedicated 24x7 on call and basically all that supporting stack, thus the 250k/person/year - not even the nursing homes for wealthy offer this kind of service. And even the start of the 131k is actually three persons manning the phone... so to me the calculations seem totally off, difficult to build an argument on bad math. Not at least, everywhere in the world there are functioning nursing homes so the concept can obviously work, so I really don't get your point.
- bell-cot 4y agoNo - I am using "one 24x7 bottom-lever care giver" as my (admittedly simplistic) unit of measure, for nursing home staffing. (Yes, I know there are wide variety of care options with visiting nurses, "independent" housing, etc. - where the staffing is definitely not 24x7. In my part of the U.S., the term "nursing home" seems reserved for facilities which are the (mostly) long-term primary residences of people needing some type(s) of 24x7 semi-skilled physical and medical care.) How many residents (or patients, or ...) each 1 staffing unit has to care for is brought in later. I briefly assumed 10 residents per staffing unit. (I am not sure how to interpret your "even the start of the 131k is actually three persons manning the phone" comment. Though from my own experience - quite a bit of staff time is consumed by talking on the phone with the family members of residents, with outside doctors & such for residents, with insurance providers for residents, with pharmacies, etc., etc.)