3 ms·
> The answer is simple: Elder care should be a publicly delivered service. Would you put your parents into a facility run by the same people who run the NYC pu
by rayiner 4y ago
> The answer is simple: Elder care should be a publicly delivered service.
Would you put your parents into a facility run by the same people who run the NYC public school system or the DC Metro?
I’m not a “neoliberal” by temperament. I want to believe the government can do stuff in an efficient and non-abusive way. I’m just repeatedly disappointed.
- edmundsauto 4y agothe people who run government funded health facilities are a different set of people that run education or transportation. Only the funding source is the same. Would you put your parents in a nursing home paid for by Medicare? I would, because I saw the care my grandmother received from such a facility.
- rayiner 4y ago> the people who run government funded health facilities are a different set of people that run education or transportation. Only the funding source is the same. They’re the same people. Government employees, belonging to the same unions, subject to the same incentives. > Would you put your parents in a nursing home paid for by Medicare? I would, because I saw the care my grandmother received from such a facility Medicare and Medicaid go out of their way to not be “publicly delivered services.” Medicare pays for privately managed elder care facilities, which may well be owned by a private equity company.
- edmundsauto 4y ago> They’re the same people. Government employees, belonging to the same unions, subject to the same incentives. Similarly, private equity is the same people with the same incentives as Enron, Toys R Us, Sears, and other major collapses. I'm not sure this is a good argument except as to say that nobody should run anything? Government is supposedly less efficient, I'm not sure this is a bad thing, and I'm not sure government is worse at health care than private industry when we are talking about care for the bottom X% (25%?) of society that can't do private payment.
- danny_codes 4y agoGovernment is supposedly less efficient than a perfect capitol market. Healthcare has inelastic demand, so the perfect market would drive the price to infinity (that is, demand as much money from patients as possible). Oh look, that's exactly s what's happening! For people who love capitolism, Americans are surprisingly uneducated on the concept.
- bhupy 4y agoExcept food also has inelastic demand (without it you starve and die), and has a pretty close to perfect market, and prices are not driven to infinity. Healthcare in America is about as far away from "capitolism"(sic) as one could possibly get. Due to Federal mandates and tax incentives, health insurance is predominately provided by employers rather than the individual market (unlike Switzerland, Germany, or the Netherlands). What we're seeing in healthcare costs is analogous to what you might see happen to airline ticket costs if we all got our air tickets through our employers: the vast majority of us would fly business class, while the unemployed would be simply unable to pay for business class fares out of pocket. Employers (especially medium-to-large businesses) have a much higher purchasing power (and hence, willingness to pay) than individuals. If you take this behavior and combine it with the fact that health insurers' profit margins are capped by law, insurers pay more absolute dollars for treatments (which doctors happily accept), charge more to employers (who are generally less price conscious vs individuals), thus bring in more absolute revenue, and therefore more profit because a capped profit percentage of a higher revenue is higher than a capped percentage of lower revenue. It's somewhat counter-intuitive, but the policy combination of an employer mandate and insurance profit cap results in prices rising to infinity. The furthest thing possible from a "perfect capitol(sic) market".
- ggrrhh_ta 4y agoAir also has inelastic demand. It is just that it is too cheap (that doesn't mean that the producers make a good profit) to produce an enormous quantity of it (even though fresh food is perishable), so much, that even the US and the EU agree on agricultural quotas and/or increasing tariffs over a certain quota of imported quantity. For Switzerland & Germany the way the incentives work are different than in the US, but the market for compulsory health insurance is very strictly regulated and the cost distribution for healthcare is distributed across public and private entities (particularly for very expensive treatments, rare diseases, treatments involving machines of great complexity/cost [like for proton therapy]).