I don't understand why the objections would be moot; they would be the same. The "EA charity" would still invest significant sums in things like AI safety and s

I don't understand why the objections would be moot; they would be the same. The "EA charity" would still invest significant sums in things like AI safety and still be driven by the same ideas that people are criticizing. Also, fwiw, this is effectively already true. The main EA organizations are operating funds you can donate to directly, which they will subsequently distribute.