4 ms·
I do not like this essay, but its central point is a good one to me. It seems to me that a somewhat superficial reason people criticize "effective altruism" is
by pessimizer 4y ago
I do not like this essay, but its central point is a good one to me. It seems to me that a somewhat superficial reason people criticize "effective altruism" is because of the dogshit politics and worldviews of most of the people advocating and participating in it. The fact is that valuing efficiency in humanitarian work is commendable, and anyone arguing for inefficiency in charity is trying to rob you.
I think the motivations behind the loudest objectors, however, are because donating to charities in your own backyard, that work on things that you enjoy as a fan or as a hobby, that employ your friends and family etc. are the vast bulk of charities. And the bulk of the cash that goes to them is eaten up by a combination of overhead in the form of salaries, travel, and accommodations, and for the big boys hiring contractors with personal and political relationships to do studies and reports that deliver recommendations, rather than any direct improvement on the targets that are the nominal purpose of the organization.
People just prefer to give money to charities that get kids to paint murals, or their local art museum (where their niece works) than those that would have a far larger effect on lives farther away that they relate to less. That's of course true for plenty of the effective altruists, too, it's just that their hobbies are ideological or science fictional, so the charities that they think are effective are often outlandish, hyper-libertarian, or simply stupid.
But criticize the individual donating badly, not the idea. The complaint that effectiveness is impossible to measure so therefore the mean of all giving is inevitably moderate effectiveness is defensive nonsense and a direct appeal to the law of averages. We're just trying to hide the fact that, with the bizarre out-of-touch narcissistic elites that we've bred with our terrible politics, we pray that they're ineffective in pursuing what they think is best. Every time a rich guy accomplishes what he thinks is best, a public school closes.
But the criticism largely seems to be coming from a middle class segment who thinks that charities are best when they're about going to parties, expressing yourself, being thanked, and pushing periodic press releases to raise awareness. I think it'd be better to ditch the larger brand, and push for effective alleviation of hunger, or effective relief of homelessness, or taking effective care of refugees or immigrants. Just get the ideology out of the way immediately i.e. this is the thing that I think is most important to do, let's find the most effective way to do it.
Sorry for the rant.
- zozbot234 4y ago> a middle class segment who thinks that charities are best when they're about going to parties, expressing yourself, being thanked, and pushing periodic press releases to raise awareness Isn't it a bit ironic then that so much of the criticism of EA has to do with these very activities? There is a legitimate role for awareness raising, as long as it's not consuming huge amounts of valuable resources. > push for effective alleviation of hunger, or effective relief of homelessness, or taking effective care of refugees or immigrants. This is exactly what EA's are doing. But picking the most viable cause areas is also important. Some incredibly popular causes, e.g. short-term disaster relief in foreign countries, really are a lot less viable than what EA's typically fund.