3 ms·
The study doesn't cover one of the possible reasons for this. For example, take George Zweig who discovered quarks before Murray Gell-Mann did, however Gell-Ma
by DiabloD3 15y ago
The study doesn't cover one of the possible reasons for this.
For example, take George Zweig who discovered quarks before Murray Gell-Mann did, however Gell-Mann got the credit because Zweig was an undergraduate and Gell-Mann was a well known name in the physics community.
Gell-Mann ended up getting the Nobel in 1969, and Zweig ended up leaving physics and going over to the neurobiology camp and made significant contributions to wavelets.
- splat 15y agoYes, this is an example of the Matthew Effect: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Matthew_effect_%28sociology%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Matthew_effect_%28sociology%29
- frisco 15y ago> Zweig now works for Renaissance Technologies on Long Island, NY. [Wikipedia] That's depressing.
- gwern 15y agoTo cover a possible reason, you need to show a phenomenon which varies over the same time-period as the observed aging. Is stealing-credit a social practice which varied over the same period as the aging? That is, were scientists completely honest or something in the late 1880s/1890s such that the first Nobel year in the study (1901) was awarded honestly? And did academic dishonesty steadily increase until it's so rampant that apparently a ton of young academics in the 1990s and 2000s have been screwed out of the Nobels by their seniors? (Only some Nobels were stolen, you say? But then, are these few thefts enough to shift the average age all the way up to 48? Do these few thefts change matters even a little? If not, then why are you quibbling and generalizing from a single anecdote?)