5 ms·
Any news on a fight against targeted harassment and murder attempts?
by viraptor 4y ago
Any news on a fight against targeted harassment and murder attempts?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kossTKR 4y agoMurder attempts and harassment? Please elaborate.
- viraptor 4y agoOne of cloudflare's customers is a forum known for repeatedly organising swatting, which in practice is a murder attempt (in the US anyway) and other nastiness. Cloudflare seems ok with that, but recently there's more pressure on them. So far only radio silence from the management like Prince and JGrahamC. Check out https://twitter.com/stealthygeek/status/1485731083534667779 https://twitter.com/stealthygeek/status/1485731083534667779 for a longer story for example. It's been an ongoing issue for quite a while but in the last few days there seems to be some effort to make them not ignore it and spread the knowledge.
- thegeomaster 4y agoIf the customer is doing something illegal, it should be the job of law enforcement to judge on that and stop them, not a CDN company.
- geowwy 4y ago
- viraptor 4y agoSure, they just dox specific people and the same people coincidentally get swatted by completely unrelated individuals. Also, I've got a bridge to sell you...
- blackearl 4y agoMaking fun of people should be illegal?
- sascha_sl 4y ago"making fun" is putting it lightly. They will dig through your accounts, archive everything you say, interpret it the worst way possible. And if that doesn't work, they'll also sometimes outright make shit up (also known as defamation). Usually, for trans people, some groomer narrative is established. It's essentially high grade stochastic terrorism. They hand you a gun and tell you where to aim, but then get upset when someone implies they encourage pulling the trigger. Those affected also don't often talk about it, because it encourages even more harassment.
- bauruine 4y ago>They will dig through your accounts, archive everything you say, interpret it the worst way possible. This sounds exactly like what the Twitter "good guys" do all the time to cancel people.
- sascha_sl 4y agoYour false equivalence doesn't interest me. This "but the others are just as bad, therefore it's okay" mentality that has almost become an ideological reflex really needs to be added to the things HN considers bad contributions. I could feed an ebooks bot HN comments and get these exact words out.
- psyc 4y agoIf people make things up, they're doing so against the written rules. I'd link to it, but the site is under a DDoS attack being very proudly and loudly organized by an individual they believe fits said narrative. The gist is: "[Stick to what you can document, that's more than funny enough.] Misinformation is not welcome here." The un-bracketed part is verbatim if memory serves. Narrative is a tricky thing. Neither side of the controversy would exist without their narratives.
- arez 4y agohow is that different to 4chan?
- sokoloff 4y agoSo Cloudflare provides CDN services for a forum that has content that (in some opinions) should be illegal (but probably isn’t) and, on that basis, Cloudflare should refuse them service? I’d hope to live a world where Cloudflare would host speech that I like and agree with and speech that I disagree with on equal terms. (If it’s legal, the bits flow.) I literally do not want opinions different from my own to be silenced.
- Vaslo 4y agoActually I’m pretty sure you should be allowed to make fun of any subject at any time, even if in very poor taste. That’s not your call or the government’s.
- simiones 4y agoIt would be outrageous for CloudFlare to cut off service to this company/organization or its members over simple allegations, or anything short of a court order, wouldn't it? Surely you can understand this?
- mschuster91 4y ago> It would be outrageous for CloudFlare to cut off service to this company/organization or its members over simple allegations The behavior of Kiwifarms and their users has been documented often and deep enough to say that this is no longer a "he said they said" territory.
- simiones 4y agoSo if enough people believe OJ killed his ex-wife, we should shun him from society because it's no longer in "he said they said" territory? The rule of law and due process are important factors. While you are personally free to refuse your own business to anyone based on any criteria you like, demanding and expecting others to do so based on what is ultimately hearsay is pure entitlement.
- mschuster91 4y agoIt is not too much to expect of a dozens-of-billions-of-dollars worth multinational corporation to conduct an investigation based on that "hearsay" and to react on that investigation. Operating a global business does not absolve the business from the need to prevent harm caused by it, in fact some form of abuse management has been expected from any good Internet citizen since its inception, e.g. in Usenet [0] or e-mail in general [1]. Or for a real-life equivalent: if I were to stand outside of the home of a person and blaring into a megaphone that she deserve to die... I'd at least get the cops called on me for a noise violation or a harassment charge, and if I were to incite others or coordinate their behavior, I would get a conspiracy charge. Why should Internet trolls enjoy legal protection for the same behavior? [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usenet_Death_Penalty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usenet_Death_Penalty [1] https://www.ietf.org/rfc/rfc2142.txt https://www.ietf.org/rfc/rfc2142.txt
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- simiones 4y agoWhy would CloudFlare have any responsibility for the use of their services in this way? Do you expect the power company to cut off power to that forum? The water company? How about the power and water companies cutting power to known members of the forum, to "fight against targeted harassment and murder"?
- pavlov 4y agoPower and water companies are utilities. I don't think Cloudflare would want to be categorized that way, as it comes with massive regulation.
- simiones 4y agoSure, but that is a technical legal issue. If the GP wishes to disrupt the business of some other organization that has not been proven in a court of law to break any laws, they should be logically consistent and ask for this cessation of business not just from CloudFlare, but from every company; that the utilities are legally barred from cutting service in this way is secondary.
- pavlov 4y agoThat's a strange definition of logical consistency: asking for something you know to be possible is conditional on also asking for something that you know to be impossible.
- viraptor 4y agoCloudflare is not a regulated provider of essential services / utilities. Right from their tos: "We may at our sole discretion suspend or terminate your access to the Websites and/or Online Services at any time, with or without notice for any reason or no reason at all." (and they have done so before)
- simiones 4y agoSo? Are you arguing that it is good for a company to have and wield this kind of power to attack other organizations that it believes are engaging in conduct they don't like? Or has Kiwi Farms been shown in a court of law to have engaged in the behavior you describe?
- thematrixturtle 4y agoFor others feeling out of the loop: apparently one of Cloudfront's customers is "Kiwi Farms", which is apparently a discussion forum for trolls, some of whom have apparently conducted swatting ("murder") attempts against trans activists. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kiwi_Farms https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kiwi_Farms
- convery 4y agoIt's pretty much the forum equivalent of LibsOfTiktok, people post clips / screenshots of people acting silly and people laugh at them. The site is constantly being DDoSed by the people/groups laughed at and Keffals (the latest big personality being silly) is now leading a crusade against Cloudflare to drop their DDoS protection so the attacks can be more effective. Worth noting is that the admins of that forum removes anything illegal and they make fun of everyone acting silly regardless of politics / ideology.
- psyc 4y agoI'd link to the thread, but the farms are presently under ongoing DDoS attack at the behest of one 'Keffals', noted Twitterninja and the Fastest Ratio-er in the Wild Wide Web. They have been having some trouble with n00bs trolling. What do you expect when the media and, frankly, most of you spend 7 years telling everybody it's a 'trolling and harassing forum', i.e. lying through your blueteeth, just because you want to see the site gone. The thread I was going to link is the sole site admin literally begging the n00bs (people who've joined relatively recently and think trolling is cool) to stop trolling the subjects. There are a lot of joke threads and the Kiwis are ironic in the extreme, but that thread is not a joke thread. It's been Josh's stance forever: look and laugh, don't mess with them. If you're an asshole and you want to make dumb trolling plans, do it elsewhere. It isn't just the admin and the mods, either. Pretty much all of the OG users have always tried to quash trolling talk as much as they can. What the hell else can they do? They can't control what a few of their thousands of users do off-site. Ask yourself if you want a global pseudo-public internet where any one of its critical private infrastructure companies can de facto censor the planet-wide web at the request of aggrieved Twitter mobs. Ugh. I don't think I have the energy for this today.
- bauruine 4y agoOne of those murder attempts that allegedly! was done by members of Kiwi Farms was against Marjorie Taylor Greene, one of the worst anti Trans right politicians in existence. With a message that says "This is swatting. btw. I'm a moderator from Kiwi Farms" This just looks so obviously like a false flag that I'm actually not sure wtf's going on.
- convery 4y agoCloudflare didn't respond to their tweets demanding removal of DDoS protection, police informed them that sharing public content and laughing at you is not illegal. Of-course the next step would be trying to frame them for political extremism against protected groups (reason Cloudflare dropped Stormfront) and SWATing (illegal), both at the same time. Targeting a politician they don't like in-case it actually worked breaks the narrative and makes the red-flag more obvious though..
- psyc 4y agoSo, this was 100% a false flag, there's not even a question. The caller did give the user name of a current moderator. That mod didn't even know what happened until people told them like hours later. Nobody on KF thinks it was them, and it makes zero sense. Despite what most people seem to believe, SWATing is insta-bannable on Kiwi Farms, where almost nothing is considered ban-worthy. A current moderator doing something he bans people for, and for which the admin would ban them for in 2 seconds? Unlikely. Secondly, I forget where but somewhere in the site rules or in Josh's Plea it explicitly states "DO NOT UPSET THE U.S. GOVERNMENT IN ANY WAY". So again. A current moderator SWATing MTG - WHILE the site is under intense and very possibly existential scrutiny already? Come on.
- dang 4y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32592487 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32592487.