3 ms·
> I got older, and now automatic transmissions are so much more efficient than manual transmissions * for ordinary people *. It’s not just ordinary people. The
by masklinn 4y ago
> I got older, and now automatic transmissions are so much more efficient than manual transmissions * for ordinary people *.
It’s not just ordinary people. The opposite, if anything. F1 and rally cars haven’t been manual for decades. I don’t think any modern super is manual.
Though with the ev-ification the point is moot as save for a few rare exceptions they’re single-gear.
- vlan0 4y agoWhile true, the motivating factors for F1 and mass production vehicles are not the same. F1 is pure min/max. Which of course means manual is gone. But min/max on my GTI means I lose connection with the vehicle and my ability to drive matters less. For what? .4 faster 0-60 or 1/4? Eh
- masklinn 4y agoThe comment I replied to was a statement of efficiency. Not a statement of the pleasure you derive from transmission vinyl.
- vlan0 4y agoHuh, thanks for calling me out on that. My brain must have been in a different gear.
- mstump 4y agoF1 isn’t even about max performance, it’s about trying to maintain an element of driver skill as a factor of outcomes. It’s why they outlawed the Williams continuously variable transmission (CVT). A lot in F1 is done to maintain the suspense/excitement of a race for the TV audience.
- originalvichy 4y agoSaying they aren’t manual can be misleading. F1 and rally cars have automatic clutching but they certainly gear up and down manually.
- masklinn 4y agoThere’s nothing misleading about it. Shift paddles are pretty standard on cars with automatic gearboxes. The only difference is that outside of sports cars “consumer” gearboxes will usually restrict the range they’ll let you use with semi-automatic shifting and will override that if you redline or bottom out.
- hugh-avherald 4y agoF1 cars will not automatically shift gears though. That's the defining feature of automatic transmission.
- masklinn 4y agoIt’s completely irrelevant to the discussion at hand: whether the user or the computer initiates the gear change does not change the efficiency of the gearbox. When manuals are discussed on the internet, it’s the manual clutch which is the central difference, not what’s essentially a firmware feature or lack thereof. That’s what’s mentioned in pretty much every comment other than your nitpicks.
- djhworld 4y agoThis feature is on ordinary cars too (sometimes called 'semi automatics') I actually have it on my car, there are paddles behind the steering wheel that can shift the gears up and down. It's a bit of a gimmick for ordinary driving as you can just let the car choose the appropriate gear, but I guess if you want to shunt down a few gears quickly on a hill to get some engine braking it can be useful
- jacquesm 4y agoI use this for people that get easily carsick, it allows me to pull away in 2nd gear rather than first and that means fewer gearshifts and more smooth starting. It's not super good for the clutch but it certainly beats cleaning up...
- jjav 4y ago> F1 and rally cars haven’t been manual for decades. In racing, but particularly in F1, you can't leave a single millisecond on the table because the competitors won't. So F1 gearboxes shift in milliseconds which is obviously impossible for a human to do with a clutch pedal. And that is all F1 teams optimize for, speed. When driving purely for fun (as most street sports cars are used) there is no stopwatch, so it hardly matters if the shift happens in 10 milliseconds or a 1000. What matters is how much fun it is and that is where a good shifter and a clutch pedal with a nice feel shine.
- masklinn 4y ago> What matters is how much fun it is and that is where a good shifter and a clutch pedal with a nice feel shine. The comment I replied to was talking about efficiency, and my reply was in those terms as well. If what matters to you is the car equivalent of putting your audio cables on pyramids you do you, but this is not “what matters” to what we were talking about. It couldn’t be any further really.
- R0flcopt3r 4y agoRally transmissions at least are very much manual. Along with most other race transmissions. They use dog-ring gearboxes, which are just really beefy synchronizing rings that let you just slam it into gear without decoupling from the engine. The paddles are electric, but they tell some pneumatic system to push a lever forwards or backwards. F1 might use some decoupling? But I would expect them to work like most other race transmissions, by not decoupling. There are computers that control the rev-matching, but that's technically on the engine side of things. There are sensors on the gearbox that let the controller know when to add throttle, but it's still very much not the responsibility of the transmission. There are also downshift protection to make sure you don't over-rev the engine, but this is also on the engine side of things, but it does block the signal from the paddle shifters.