3 ms·
The disclosures in the patent aren't what they are suing you over. Read the claims. Patents like this often have a lot of stuff shoved into the disclosure so
by pclmulqdq 4y ago
The disclosures in the patent aren't what they are suing you over. Read the claims. Patents like this often have a lot of stuff shoved into the disclosure so that they can keep the patent application alive to write more patents based on the original disclosure. The claims appear to be written to read on devices like yours: My knowledge of your system is a bit dated, but I thought you had a device that you plugged into a port in the car instead of a manufacturer-installed thing. This is why this patent has a 2007 priority date, but a 2018 application date: they essentially wrote a ridiculously broad disclosure, and kept filing patents based on it.
Dataspeed did appear to have tried to invalidate this patent in 2019 (see the IPR documents linked there), and succeeded on all but claim 20. If your device does not have a relay which shuts off its electrical connection within the car, you're probably safe. You could try to invalidate it, but you should read the docs from the IPR to see what Dataspeed did and what you might need to do.
My gut-check guess is that claim 20 is probably not going to get invalidated unless you can find some weird after-market car part from before 2007 which does a safety shut-off of a car component.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gregsadetsky 4y agoThe DARPA Grand Challenge ran in 2004 and 2005 (i.e. before 2007) and the cars there definitely all had emergency shut off mechanisms. Maybe one of the competitors used an existing (i.e. not custom made) car part for this? ——— Found this from 2004: “A DARPA-provided electronic stop device allowed a remote control shut-down of the vehicle in case of an emergency” Is that a lead? [0] https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Reinhold-Behringer/publication/4092514_The_DARPA_grand_challenge_-_development_of_an_autonomous_vehicle/links/00463534fb60fde831000000/The-DARPA-grand-challenge-development-of-an-autonomous-vehicle.pdf?origin=publication_detail https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Reinhold-Behringer/publ...
- pclmulqdq 4y agoThis is a good start but not fully there. Ideally you would like a bigger published technical description of that electronic stop device, so you can map the device onto the claims to show that a claimed device existed before the patent was filed.
- barelycompetent 4y agoA lead would need to teach significantly more to even be considered. Does the vehicle have (1) an after-market device installed that (2) detects that a first component stopped sending commands to a second component and (3) uses relay switch to disconnect the failed first component from the second component and (4) starts sending commands to the second component on its own that are indistinguishable from those sent by the first component? Technically, the above requirements are needed against claim 20 of '707. Claim 6 requires fewer features. That doesn't help us because: (1) claim 20 is asserted in the complaint [0], and (2) claim 20 was upheld in a previous challenge to its validity (an "IPR"), so it's got some staying power. [0] https://blog.comma.ai/img/20220824085232055.pdf https://blog.comma.ai/img/20220824085232055.pdf