11 ms·
Psilocybin-assisted psychotherapy vs. placebo in treatment of alcohol disorder
- phren0logy 4y agoThe comparison condition was psilocybin or diphenhydramine (Benadryl), and both groups got addiction counseling. >Participants correctly guessed their treatment assignment in 93.6% of the first sessions, reporting a mean (SD) certainty of 88.5% (23.2%). In the second session, 94.7% guessed correctly, and mean (SD) certainty was 90.6% (21.5%). Study therapists correctly guessed treatment 92.4% of the time for first sessions and 97.4% for second sessions, and their mean (SD) certainties were 92.8% (16.3%) and 95.4% (2.9%), respectively. This is not a criticism, as these trials are very hard to blind, but as you can see in hindsight they could as well have not bothered with blinding at all. So we need to interpret this as a randomized but unblinded trial. The researchers are well aware of this, and I suspect it will inform the next steps of their research. >Several limitations of the study warrant discussion. First, diphenhydramine was ineffective in maintaining the blind after drug administration, so biased expectancies could have influenced results. Control medications such as methylphenidate,42 niacin,2 and low-dose psilocybin1 likewise did not adequately maintain blinding in past psilocybin trials, so this issue remains a challenge for clinical research on psychedelics.
- radicaldreamer 4y agoIt's going to be incredibly hard to blind a study on psychedelics due to their unique and powerful effects... the best might be some sort of VR experience with a dissociative to mimic a psychedelic experience, but even that seems unlikely to be an effective control.
- TylerE 4y agoEspecially when dealing with addiction. In other contexts, a fairly strong sedative is frequently used as the control, which is going to be a lot less subtle.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoYeah, this was what I was thinking as well, but I think researchers should just accept that blinding is fundamentally impossible in studies like this: 1. With a high dose of shrooms, you're definitely going to know whether you were tripping or not. 2. If they can find another agent that mimics the effect of tripping, well then it's not really a placebo anymore.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- roughly 4y agoSomething that's going to be interesting with psychedelics and psychedelic research is that a lot of this sort of research seems to try to "control for" the phenomenological experience in favor of focusing on the biochemical mechanism of action - I think it's possible that the phenomenological experience _is_ the mechanism of action for these substances, that the actual experience of the trip is what makes the difference.
- _yb2s 4y ago> I think it's possible that the phenomenological experience _is_ the mechanism of action for these substances, that the actual experience of the trip is what makes the difference. I was really confused about the entire concept of blinding a study like this until I read your comment... Now I realize they are indeed proceeding from the assumption that the phenomenological experience is somehow distinct from the mechanism of action. That seems really unlikely to me- these drugs are unique because of the phenomenological experience! It seems self evident that this experience is the reason for therapeutic effects. Imagine the absurdity of trying to design a study blinding the effects of meditation for example. Meditation has measurable benefits, but what are the chances those aren't caused by the psychological effects of experiencing meditation?
- rfrey 4y agoIt's self evident to you that there's no effect on brain chemistry that accompanies the experience? A change that could have an impact on the condition? You might be right, maybe you're even probably right, but it's not self evident to me.
- stocknoob 4y ago“Chemical imbalance” antidepressants take weeks of ~100 milligram tablets to take effect. (Nobody can quite explain what the imbalance was to begin with, and what the ideal levels are…) Psychedelics have an impact at the microgram range, with a single dose. They could be hundreds of thousands of times more potent, or, it could be the experience.
- paraph1n 4y agoThere's still a difference between "guessing" correctly versus actually knowing the truth. It's different from an actually unblinded study even if participants can "guess" correctly.
- pessimizer 4y agoLooks to be a vanishingly small difference if they guessed correctly, the first time they were asked, 94.7% of the time with 90% confidence.
- paraph1n 4y agoIn order to understand the difference, you'd have to have a blinded and unblinded study, and compare the results. Then you could understand the difference between a guess with 90% confidence and actually knowing what treatment you received with certainty. It seems reckless to presume the difference (between blinded and unblinded) is small. The numbers you cite (94.7% and 90% confidence) have nothing to do with the question you're trying to answer. For example, an important difference may be with respect to expectations. If you're told you're receiving a psychedelic treatment, you may go into the experience with different expectations than if you were unsure about what treatment you were getting.
- anigbrowl 4y agoGood point. I can see the normal approach being valuable if studying microdosing, but regular dosing is going to go from 'hmm I wonder if anything will happen' to 'woohoo space llamas' in no uncertain terms. One wonders why even tried this approach, other than satisfying funding and review bureaucrats that prefer not to think.
- colechristensen 4y agoYou absolutely cannot blind a psychadelic study unless you are testing psychedelics against each other or different doses. No more than you could test someone’s performance while drunk against a sober person. The effects are just invited to everybody.
- cameronh90 4y agoI didn't see it in the paper, but I wonder what the difference was in people who correctly guessed their treatment assignment between the different arms. I would imagine that everyone who got psilocybin guessed correctly.
- philshem 4y agoReminds me of the 1962 “Good Friday Experiment” https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marsh_Chapel_Experiment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marsh_Chapel_Experiment
- geokon 4y agoif the intention is to have a blind test, is there a reason it's not administer while the patient is asleep? If you stay up for 48 hours, go to sleep, get a random injection after an hour or two, wake up ~10 hours later. I would think you'd probably cut that ~90% down significantly
- dimal 4y agoA historical counterfactual I've often wondered about is, what would have happened if Timothy Leary didn't exist? Prior to psychedelics going counterculture, there was a lot of evidence that they could help with alcoholism and other disorders. But then he went all "tune in, turn on, drop out", threw acid parties, and then psychedelics got tangled up with counterculture ideas instead of psychology, and we got the drug war instead. Maybe that was all inevitable, but maybe it wasn't?
- mistrial9 4y agoit is possible that there were widespread uses of psychedelics in multiple earlier civilizations, but those social systems either did not last themselves or were defeated in wars and erased. Some of the vigorous rhetoric about "pagans" in the middle ages Europe for example.. psychoactive substances are not new
- radicaldreamer 4y agoThe primary thing that happened is the rise and power of the catholic church, which saw the "direct" spiritual experience offered by psilocybin mushrooms and other psychedelic plants as a threat to their gatekeeping role and violently stamped out knowledge and use of such substances. Similarly, the moral panic about psychedelics was because it threatened vested business and corporate interests (and the economic war with communism), especially when slogans such as "Turn on, tune in, drop out" because associated with them.
- xupybd 4y agoDrug use has been seen as witchcraft withing Christianity from the beginning of Christianity. https://www.massbible.org/exploring-the-bible/ask-a-prof/answers/pharmakeia https://www.massbible.org/exploring-the-bible/ask-a-prof/ans...
- numtel 4y agoAlternatively, see John Allegro's (one of the people who worked on deciphering the Dead Sea scrolls) The Sacred Mushroom and the Cross which posits that Jesus actually was a mushroom.
- unstatusthequo 4y agoTLDR; “Percentage of heavy drinking days during the 32-week double-blind [0] period was 9.7% for the psilocybin group and 23.6% for the diphenhydramine group, a mean difference of 13.9%” [0] And see below with good comment re double blind part.
- loeg 4y agoAs phren0logy points out, the study was essentially unblinded. So it's probably worth clarifying that in a TLDR, or at least removing the explicit "double-blind" claim.
- kallistisoft 4y agoI find that effective dosage is the most surprising aspect of this study >Interventions Study medications were psilocybin, 25 mg/70 kg, vs diphenhydramine, 50 mg (first session), and psilocybin, 25-40 mg/70 kg, vs diphenhydramine, 50-100 mg (second session). Psychotherapy included motivational enhancement therapy and cognitive behavioral therapy. 25mg is an extremely small dose! Much smaller than most micro-dose regiments at 0.5g
- ThePowerOfFuet 4y agoAre you perchance going by weight of dried fruit?
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoNo, 0.5g is the weight of a dried mushroom for microdosing. From another article I read: > Common varieties such as Psilocybe cubensis and Psilocybe semilanceata contain around 6 -10mg of psilocybin per gram of dried mushrooms So a 25mg dose of psilocybin is on the order of 2.5 - 4 grams of dried mushrooms, which is a hefty amount.
- juancampa 4y agoThey are measuring how much psilocybin (the compound) while people normally measure how much dry mushrooms by weight
- eklitzke 4y ago25mg is not a small dose if you're actually measuring the psilocybin rather than the dried weight of the mushroom fruit. The exact psilocybin weight ratio depends on the strain of mushroom, but typically dried P. Cubensis is about 1% psilocybin by weight. This means that 25mg of psilocybin roughly corresponds to 2.5g of dried shrooms.
- wearigo 4y agoThe previous comment (~4g) is correct, most studies have put standard cubes at around 0.6% psilocybin. https://www.leafly.com/learn/psychedelics/how-to-dose-mushrooms https://www.leafly.com/learn/psychedelics/how-to-dose-mushro...
- brian_c 4y agoNetflix's _How to Change Your Mind_ (based on a book with same name, I believe) has been a nice digestible look at psychedelics' uses in various therapies, now and in the past, if you're interested in that kinda thing. (And, off-topic, but the scrollbar on the left here is interesting. Looks like it's a LTR block overflowing a RTL block. I don't think I like it, but, interesting!)
- ipnon 4y agoYou will know when we have made real progress because an informed, responsible adult will be able to make their own decisions about what to put in their own body. Medical progress in psychedelic theory is a altruistic slippery slope. It clearly bends attitudes towards acceptance in the general public, slowly at first.
- 09bjb 4y agoCognitive Liberty and Religious Liberty FTW. Medicalization implicitly promotes the idea that you should need a "medical issue" in order to have the government's permission to ingest plants and fungi that spring out of the ground spontaneously.
- rootw0rm 4y agothank you. 100% agree.
- heap_perms 4y agoThe idea that cognitive liberty should be a global constant for all humans — seems self-evident to my mind. The freedom of the individual should be placed above everything else, as long as it's not hurting anybody. Astonishingly enough, quite a huge part of the population don't seem to think this as important. This honestly shocks me.
- el_nahual 4y agoI don't necessarily disagree, but playing devil's advocate: What about ill-informed, irresponsible adults? 30% of Americans believe in astrology [1]. A growing number are anti-vaxers. The number of people that believe some amount of utterly batshit things is not small!
- fredgrott 4y agothen there is the other side of your argument via past human history of 10,000 years taking and harvesting plant chemicals for other uses. Let's list them: 1. Cocoa beans 2. Coffee beans 3. Cola Beans 4. Macca 5. Ginkgo and the list keeps going and growing every decade.
- troops_h8r 4y agoJust popping in to say that psilocybin shrooms + therapy permanently changed my life for the better and I STRONGLY recommend it to pretty much everyone if their therapist specializes in that kind of thing
- unclekev 4y agoIf anyone knows of anyone in Australia (or surrounding countries) doing psilocybin or MDMA assisted therapy, please reach out. Desperate.
- nilradical 4y agoget in touch with the aus psychedelic society. they can't assist you directly, but someone in the community will point you in the right direction https://www.psychedelicsociety.org.au/contactus https://www.psychedelicsociety.org.au/contactus
- somedangedname 4y agoHey dude the Aus govt. has a register of open trials in Aus/NZ. It's searchable (tho not well) and you can apparently set up email alerts for new trials. Hope it helps! https://www.australianclinicaltrials.gov.au/anzctr_feed/form https://www.australianclinicaltrials.gov.au/anzctr_feed/form
- upupandup 4y agoAccording to my friend, psilocybin itself is therapeutic and allows introspection, provided it is done in a safe environment.
- rootw0rm 4y agois your friend named SWIM? I concur though, i've personally helped a number of people experience psychedelics for the first time, though it definitely helps to have some benzos on hand for the outliers who are just incompatible with psychedelics. Some people, for whatever reason, are just unable to separate themselves from the experience or accept what is happening without extreme stress. It's almost like classic psychedelics act more like disassociatives for them.
- yeswecatan 4y agoHas anybody come across any studies with adverse outcomes with psilocybin? I've heard of HPPD (hallucinogen persisting perception disorder) though it's somewhat rare. The benefits seem overwhelmingly positive.
- kupopuffs 4y agolike all scary experiences, start small
- bowsamic 4y agoI have only anecdotes, but I have met a lot of people with some form of HPPD even after moderate and safe usage. I think it is probably a bit underestimated right now. My guess is that it is one of the bigger risks of using psychedelics, along with PTSD from the experience and DP/DR. Andrew Callaghan of Channel 5 news has it pretty strongly but he did abuse it at a young age. He spoke about it on "therapy gecko". Obviously the benefits is a fleeting and difficult to pin down thing. Outside of a clinical setting, experiences with psychedelics range from life-changing to life-destroying, with most people seemingly in the middle with "it's just fun". It certainly does not seem reliable.
- Loeffelmann 4y agoI have DP/DR induced by LSD and I am always skeptical of psychedelic usage in psychology. I think that especially people with psychological problems to begin with should not be taking LSD or mushrooms. Even it's a small minority who get HPPD it's potentially life ruining.
- bowsamic 4y agoI also have minor DP/DR and HPPD induced by very minor LSD usage years ago, which comes and goes depending on the situation. I've had times before where I literally start tripping, just for a moment, like I totally enter the trippy headspace or have a very trippy feeling. For example I will be cooking and suddenly the barrier between me and the food disintegrates and I just feel completely whack for a while. I also have lost a sense of what is in my peripheral vision, for example I was in a meeting earlier and in my periphery someone's bag fell over and I was convinced for a moment that it was an animal even though we were just sitting in an office. This happens basically every day and slowly getting worse tbh and I'm convinced it is an LSD thing. Also sometimes if my mental health is bad I have tactile hallucinations, like someone is tapping on my shoulder but no one is there. I had actual HPPD for about a year after my trip, e.g. I could reproduce certain visual effects by looking in a certain way. I think it also caused my tendency to experience pretty strong open-eye hallucinations while meditating, which are called "makyo" in Japanese. Of course, maybe none of this is due to the LSD usage, but I think some of it probably is. After my 2 LSD trips with 100ug and very good setting (and I thought at the time good enough set) I slowly became very depressed and suicidal and had a total crisis. I actually had to seek out religion (which I always hated as a life long atheist) to be able to cope and not kill myself. It got close at some point and basically every since suicide has been lingering over my head. It made it a possibility: before LSD if I had stress I would lament at the world being unfair or something, after LSD if I have stress (even just minor work stress) I just can't stop thinking about killing myself. I'm on a waiting list for therapy but it is very long. The absurd part about the LSD community is that even after telling other psych users all that, the response of about 50% of people is that I should take more at a higher dose...
- nilespotter 4y agoI have a friend I went to rehab with who after numerous relapses post-rehab decided to give "micro dosing" a try. I was and am doing well with regular old AA. At a certain point there was a meeting I didn't want to go alone and I tried to get him to come with me. He wanted to but felt like he'd have to lie about what he's doing or face a barrage of advice and doom and gloom predictions, and he was right. For my part I don't think this is a good long-term solution for as we call them "real alcoholics" but in my experience AA is very combative to this kind of thing, which is unfortunate.
- tvanantwerp 4y agoIt's interesting that AA is so hostile to psychedelic therapies when their founder believed they could be very useful. https://www.theguardian.com/science/2012/aug/23/lsd-help-alcoholics-theory https://www.theguardian.com/science/2012/aug/23/lsd-help-alc...
- rootw0rm 4y agoi was honest with my sponsor about using THC edibles to wean myself off of sleep meds i was prescribed in rehab. he was supportive, in his own way, but said he couldn't continue taking me thru the steps even though he personally knew of quite a few people on "team green" in AA.
- yosito 4y agoAA is really more of a religion than an evidence based approach. Some find it helpful. For others it's harmful. Statistically speaking, IIRC, there's no significant difference between AA and other approaches to long term sobriety. If it works for you, great! For anyone who is skeptical or having a hard time with AA, I recommend the book The Sober Truth.
- hackernewds 4y agoCurious how the therapy is working out for your friend in comparison to yours.
- rootw0rm 4y agowhen i checked myself into rehab last year, it was solely based on the self-realization gained by a shroom trip. i shared this at rehab and nobody was shocked.
- rootw0rm 4y agocan we talk about methoxetamine while we're at it?
- hackernewds 4y agoHow are these controlled for? It should be pretty apparent to the user that they're on the placebo segment given that psilocybin has some pretty apparent effects.
- green_on_black 4y agoReally? I can be the judge of that.