3 ms·
Sorry, yes, poorly phrased. We don't know if he's guilty beyond reasonable doubt, and probably won't, because presidents and former presidents are immune to pr
by CamperBob2 4y ago
Sorry, yes, poorly phrased. We don't know if he's guilty beyond reasonable doubt, and probably won't, because presidents and former presidents are immune to prosecution in this country.
It's always possible the he had legitimate reasons for storing SC information outside a SCIF. No one can think of any, including his own legal team, but hey, ex-President, right?
- wyldfire 4y ago> because presidents and former presidents are immune to prosecution in this country. I think saying things like this is deliberately provocative -- it's not the case. "The arc of the moral universe is long, but it bends toward justice." Trump commits crimes flagrantly and to such a degree that Nixon never would have dreamed. He will get some kind of legal consequence ... eventually.
- yupper32 4y ago> He will get some kind of legal consequence ... eventually. I don't see how you could possibly be confident of that. Even if he is absolutely guilty and gets to the point of a trial, which alone is a huge huge huge huge step, he may be able to delay things for the rest of his life.
- Consultant32452 4y agoAre you aware that Trump could have tweeted a copy of every top secret document the government has and it would have been perfectly legal?
- CamperBob2 4y agoMaybe. That's not what he did, though. If you think it's a good idea to allow a former POTUS to retroactively and implicitly declassify information he is caught with after leaving office, or to issue a sweeping declaration that any documents he takes out of the Oval Office are automatically declassified, I suspect you won't be as blasé when someone of the opposing political party does it.
- wyldfire 4y ago"Buttery Males!"
- the_optimist 4y agoYou invented 'retroactive.' I suppose you are blasé about this because it applies to someone of an opposing political party.
- CamperBob2 4y agoIs there any actual evidence that he declassified all of that material while in office? Did he even tell anybody? No? Well, then, any such claims are necessarily retroactive, or else they're invalid from the get-go. Which do you prefer?
- Consultant32452 4y agoAny ideas you have about the President having to follow any sort of official process regarding classification are nothing but illusions. The most you're going to get here is he's irresponsible in a way people don't like but is not criminal. Even if I were to imagine he were technically breaking the law with some of these documents, look at it from a practical standpoint. At one point he could've done whatever he wanted to with any documents, including tweeting them publicly. He may or may not have taken some sensitive information and stored it in a building wholly owned (secured) by the secret service. There is not really any risk here, any crimes would be mere technicalities. Of all the crimes every President in my lifetime has committed, including Trump, mishandling some secret documents in this way is a total nothingburger. It's almost certainly not a crime and even if it is a crime it's a paperwork technicality crime.
- Jochim 4y agoI could've written down the correct numbers for the lottery but I didn't, therefore I don't get to claim any winnings. I think it's kind of ironic that - speaking generally - the "patriots" don't seem to care at all that a former president took state secrets after leaving office. I wonder how big the "nothingburger" would be if it turns out he actually did leak them.
- GauntletWizard 4y agoYes, Trump definitionally cannot have leaked secret documents while he was president, because he had the authority to declassify them and the act of distributing them would have been a form of that declassification. Reality Winner had no such authority to declassify documents.
- r2_pilot 4y agoThe former president[T] could absolutely leak secret documents in violation of existing law. The former president[O] signed Executive Order 13526, which was never [publicly] rescinded nor modified by TFP[T], and that EO defines how classified material is to be handled. Agree that Reality Winner had no authority to declassify documents. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_Order_13526 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_Order_13526
- wyldfire 4y agoTrump's duty as a civil servant, whose role included "support and defend the Constitution of the United States against all enemies, foreign and domestic" -- that ended on January 20, 2021. Along with the end of his duty, ended all of the power he wielded. In terms of real legal powers, he's just like you and me.
- decebalus1 4y agoUnfortunately that's not what he did. I also can't FOIA the documents he took, can I?
- r2_pilot 4y agoThis is not a true statement. The AEC has its own Restricted Data classification which is not under the purview of the president to declassify. There are other cases of classification but this is one that is not easily debatable.
- User23 4y ago> The AEC has its own Restricted Data classification which is not under the purview of the president to declassify. They can certainly say that, but since the executive power is constitutionally vested in the president in Article II, it can't be true barring a constitutional amendment. I believe there are court cases already establishing that Congress does not have the authority to limit the President's power to classify and declassify[1]. In this particular case a constitutional argument isn't even necessary since Trump's conduct appears to be protected by the Presidential Records Act. Of course this is Trump we're talking about, so half the country will happily shred the constitution to "get" him, including many federal employees. [1] https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/484/518/ https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/484/518/
- r2_pilot 4y ago> They can certainly say that, but since the executive power is constitutionally vested in the president in Article II, it can't be true barring a constitutional amendment. Re: that case; yes for executive classification [The Supreme Court determined in its 1988 decision on Department of the Navy v. Egan that the president’s power over classified information comes from executive authority granted by Article II, Section 2 of the U.S. Constitution, which says, in part, that the “President shall be Commander in Chief of the Army and Navy of the United States.”]. However, Restricted Data is under the SOLE authority of the Department of Energy[1] to declassify, even if the DoE is under the executive branch. The law is specifically written, in fact, so that the president is not explicitly given the authority to declassify materials, yet does play a role in declassification once the DoE initiates the process, which implies that Congress did not wish to grant the presidency that power. But I'm not a lawyer, and my opinion means little. [1]: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/2162 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/2162
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoPerhaps - when he was president. He wasn't president when Mar A Lago was searched, though.
- Consultant32452 4y agoIf he took them while he was still President it was perfectly legal to do so in any manner he chose. His mere act of doing it made it official policy because that was his unique Constitutional power. The next President can create new policy, re-classify information, etc. The only real risk is if Trump perjured himself or something about the docs when asked. All of his property is secured by the secret service. The idea that anything at Mar-a-Lago was stored in an insecure way is preposterous on its face.
- CamperBob2 4y agoAll of his property is secured by the secret service. Yeah, that's not how this works.