5 ms·
The counting activity doesn't begin when the first item is registered; it begins when the counter is initialized to zero. A decision is made to begin counting,
by kazinator 4y ago
The counting activity doesn't begin when the first item is registered; it begins when the counter is initialized to zero. A decision is made to begin counting, along with the realization that nothing has been counting yet. That's when counting has started. When the first item is seen, the counting is then continuing.
Suppose your job is to count some events. You check in for work at 8:00 a.m., but the first event has not registered until noon. By your logic you should not be paid for four hours, because you're paid to count, and counting started at 1.
- atwood22 4y agoNo, the mathematical definition of counting (i.e. whether or not a set is countable) involves mapping to the natural numbers, which doesn’t include 0.
- kazinator 4y agoI don't think your definition is complete. We can count a set by mapping its elements to the natural numbers, and then identifying that number which is highest. However, we must have a provision for identifying zero as the highest when the set and mapping are empty.
- 8note 4y agoMath counting doesn't care where you start. You could start -400 if it's useful for the problem
- lupire 4y agoYou can name things however you want, but there is a canonical bijection to zero-based ordinals. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ordinal_number https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ordinal_number
- goatlover 4y agoWhat counter? You're saying a counter exists before people start counting? Is this a form of mathematical Platonism?
- lupire 4y agoAre you sure? We are talking about the he numbering, not the work-doing. You start waiting at 8, and you wait between events. But you only count (increment) when an event happens. The 0 comes for free when you are ready to count (hello golang and C++, as well as human intuition). When you count stars in the sky you don't say "0, 1, 2". You say "..., 1, 2", or if no stars show up, you say "there are 0" after timer expires.
- kazinator 4y ago> But you only count (increment) when an event happens. Increment what? > When you count stars in the sky you don't say "0, 1, 2". No, you say, "I'm going to start counting stars now. Okay, 1, 2, ...". The preparation part is the zero. You counted stars before and reached some number; you're not starting at that number.
- anigbrowl 4y agoYou're still thinking like a computer. Most people think of counting in terms of 'here are some apples, how many exactly?' If you just look at an empty space, the # of apples is equivalent is equivalent to the # of dinosaurs, but they're only equivalent by their absence.