3 ms·
It's also fundamentally limits the growth potential of BTC. In a PoW system, the amount of work done must be proportional to the total value of all BTC (if not,
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
It's also fundamentally limits the growth potential of BTC. In a PoW system, the amount of work done must be proportional to the total value of all BTC (if not, it would make 51% attacks feasible).
So if BTC uses an Argentina's worth of energy now, if the value of BTC grew 10X it would have to use on the order of 10 Argentina's worth of electricity. Obviously, that is not sustainable, and it ensures BTC can never grow in value too much if it sticks with PoW.
- TheDudeMan 4y agoHave you seen a graph of global energy use over time? It goes up.
- TheDudeMan 4y agoNow I see that "throwaway" probably didn't mean "the amount of work done" but instead "the amount of money spent on work done".
- zaroth 4y agoIt’s not really so clear cut. Perhaps if a 51% attack let you fully steal coins yes. But there are only specific things a 51% attacker can do, and even attempting to pull off the attack has game-theoretic impact on the price if Bitcoin. The more practical attacks are greedy miner type attacks which just boost a large miners win rate. The 51%-esque chain rewriting, double-spending and transaction censorship stuff is a different story. What you can definitely say is that economically the profitability of the block reward and transaction fees will drive new entrants into mining. As BTC price increases the willingness to spend more on mining (wasting electricity) increases. But the block reward also halves now and then to reduce the value of new blocks and prevent the waste from getting absurdly out of hand.
- kkielhofner 4y agoIt also makes BTC positively radioactive to mainstream adoption. There are countless examples of $CORP announcing some bitcoin initiative or another only to roll it back almost immediately after the outrage expressed from a population that is increasingly aware of and concerned about climate change.
- OGWhales 4y ago> In a PoW system, the amount of work done must be proportional to the total value of all BTC (if not, it would make 51% attacks feasible). I’m confused. Why must this be the case and how would it lead to a 51% attack if it were not? I know the difficult goes up when the price goes up because more people are able to mine profitably and the system will automatically scale the difficulty to maintain the 1 block per 10 minutes rate, but I don’t understand what the difficultly being proportional to value has to do with 51% attacks being feasible.
- pcthrowaway 4y agoI'd argue it's susceptible to 51% attack already, but as BTC's value grows, the profitability from pulling off a 51% grows as well. Therefore, the hashrate not scaling with the market cap of BTC makes the prospect of funding a 51% attack more and more appealing.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y ago1. The whole design of "Proof of Work" is that a miner must prove that he has spent a certain amount of money (in the form of electricity spend) to mine a block and win the block rewards and fees. 2. First of all, this means that (eventually) the amount of electricity spent on mining is proportional to the total rewards earned (again, block rewards PLUS fees). So if the value of BTC goes up, it's a classic arbitrage play - miners would spend more electricity to win the more valuable rewards. Of course, everyone with the capacity would do this, until the difficulty level is set at a higher level. 3. Similarly, the value to be gained from a nefarious mining attack is proportional to the total value of BTC, so the difficulty must increase to keep a 51% from being feasible. The fact that electricity spend absolutely must be proportional (over time, there can be short term imbalances before they are arbitraged away) to total value of the coins in a PoW system is a fundamental, undeniable fact. It is simply how PoW works. Yet I still am amazed how many BTC fan boys try to wave this away.
- josu 4y agoIf the hashrate can't keep up with the price increase because it has exhausted all sources of available electricity, then difficulty will adjust down. This doesn't limit the potential growth of Bitcoin, it only puts an upper bound on the security per block.
- TheDudeMan 4y agolmao, this would be apocalyptic.